Makin' Memories Fishing Charter 

4.9
(37 reviews)
 Mariana Drive, Conneaut, OH 44030, United States–

Makin' Memories Fishing Charter 

Conneaut, OH, United States
–
30 ft
6
4.9
(37 reviews)

Makin'Memories Fishing Charters invites you to join their Lake Erie trophy Walleye, Yellow Perch, and Steelhead fishing trips. Lake Erie is known as the Capital of Walleye and produces the finest specimens of this species year-round. Captain Jim Fishel, who has chased trophy fish since he was a boy with his father, will take you to the best spots where the best fish can be found.

The Makin'Memories team will take you fishing aboard Makin'Memories, a 30' Cherokee offshore sportfishing boat with 12' beams. The deck of the boat is so spacious it can carry six guests and crew comfortably. You and your group will enjoy a secure, relaxing, and pleasurable ride. The boat is equipped state of the art fishing and navigation equipment.

Captain Jim Fishel has many great stories about the days of the 'Blue Pike' that were caught on Lake Erie. His passion drives him to track the Walleye migration as it passes by the Port of Conneaut. He has over 60 years of fishing experience on the Great Lakes.

In 1991, Captain Jim Fishel teamed up with Captain Jim Holtzman, and since then, this dynamic duo has been running trips from daylight to dark, whenever the fish are biting. This fishing tag team has over 100 years of Great Lakes experience together!

Makin'Memories Fishing Charters will include live bait, lures, rods, reels, and tackle on your trip. At an additional charge, your catch can be cleaned and filleted for you by the local bait shops once the trip is over.

Book today to experience the awesome fishery that Lake Erie has to offer!

Makin'Memories Fishing Charters invites you to join their Lake Erie trophy Walleye, Yellow Perch, and Steelhead fishing trips. Lake Erie is known as the Capital of Walleye and produces the finest specimens of this species year-round. Captain Jim Fishel, who has chased trophy fish since he was a boy with his father, will take you to the best spots where the best fish can be found.

The Makin'Memories team will take you fishing aboard Makin'Memories, a 30' Cherokee offshore sportfishing boat with 12' beams. The deck of the boat is so spacious it can carry six guests and crew comfortably. You and your group will enjoy a secure, relaxing, and pleasurable ride. The boat is equipped state of the art fishing and navigation equipment.

Captain Jim Fishel has many great stories about the days of the 'Blue Pike' that were caught on Lake Erie. His passion drives him to track the Walleye migration as it passes by the Port of Conneaut. He has over 60 years of fishing experience on the Great Lakes.

In 1991, Captain Jim Fishel teamed up with Captain Jim Holtzman, and since then, this dynamic duo has been running trips from daylight to dark, whenever the fish are biting. This fishing tag team has over 100 years of Great Lakes experience together!

Makin'Memories Fishing Charters will include live bait, lures, rods, reels, and tackle on your trip. At an additional charge, your catch can be cleaned and filleted for you by the local bait shops once the trip is over.

Book today to experience the awesome fishery that Lake Erie has to offer!

Makin' Memories Fishing Charters
Charter Operator
Makin' Memories Fishing Charters
ID & credentials verified
responds within an hour

Select date to see availability

Trip date:
Group Size:
November 2026
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
Group Size
2 adults • 0 children
Change
2 Hour Sunset Cruise - no fishing
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
2 hour trip starts at 8:00 PM
Seasonal trip
Jun 1 - Oct 1
US $300
Entire boat: up to 4 people
4 Hour Trip – Steelhead (AM)
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
4 hour trip starts at 6:30 AM
Seasonal trip
Sep 25 - Oct 8
Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)
US $440
Entire boat: up to 4 people
4 Hour Trip – Steelhead (PM)
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
4 hour trip starts at 3:00 PM
Seasonal trip
Sep 25 - Oct 8
Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)
US $440
Entire boat: up to 4 people
8 Hour Trip – Drifting Special
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
8 hour trip starts at 5:30 AM
Seasonal trip
Jun 1 - Jul 13
Walleye
US $700
Entire boat: up to 4 people
8 Hour Trip – Walleye (AM)
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
8 hour trip starts at 5:30 AM
Seasonal trip
Jun 1 - Oct 18
Walleye
US $800
Entire boat: up to 4 people
8 Hour Trip – Yellow Perch (AM)
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
8 hour trip starts at 6:30 AM
Seasonal trip
Sep 15 - Oct 8
Walleye
Perch (Yellow)
US $800
Entire boat: up to 4 people
7 Hour Trip – Walleye (PM)
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
7 hour trip starts at 3:00 PM
Seasonal trip
Jun 1 - Oct 1
Walleye
US $800
Entire boat: up to 4 people
8 Hour Trip – Yellow Perch (PM)
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
8 hour trip starts at 3:00 PM
Seasonal trip
Sep 15 - Oct 8
Walleye
Perch (Yellow)
US $800
Entire boat: up to 4 people
8 Hour Trip – Walleye/Perch (AM)
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
8 hour trip starts at 5:30 AM
Seasonal trip
Sep 15 - Oct 8
Walleye
Perch (Yellow)
Perch (White)
Bass (White)
US $980
Entire boat: up to 4 people

Customer reviews

4.9
37 reviews
4.9
Boat & equipment
5.0
Captain & crew
4.9
Fishing Experience

Anglers' gallery (65)

What anglers say

100%
Great experience
100%
Friendly captain
100%
Good boat
97%
Recommended
97%
Caught fish

Reviews (37)

  • Justin Nobilese
    Justin Nobilese
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2023
    5.0
    Verified

    Awsome Fishing Charter

    8 Hour Trip – Drifting Special on June 1, 2024 • 4 adults

    We decided to do a trip with Captain Jim. I have went out on his boat 5 other times. When I had a few guys that wanted to go this year I couldn't think of anyone better to go with that Makin Memories! The knowledge Captain Jim has of the lake and the fish is outstanding. This crew will go above and beyond the get you the fish you deserve! Went out this past Saturday and had an amazing time! We couldn't ask for better weather, more fish, or a better crew to guide us on this fishing trip! If your looking to go and want a charter group that makes your trip a priority and has the knowledge to go along with thier skills Makin Memories is who you want!

  • Matt Crawford
    Matt Crawford
    us
    Ohio, US
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Awesome trip!!

    Special 6 hour trip for Matt Crawford on July 30, 2025 • 2 adults

    Everyone caught their limits. Friendly captain and crew. They bent over backwards to make it a great trip.

  • Anna Norris
    Anna Norris
    us
    Ohio, US
    Member since 2021
    5.0
    Verified

    Full day walleye trip

    8 Hour Trip – Walleye (AM) on September 10, 2021 • 4 adults

    Captain Jim and First Mate Mariah were great. This was the first experience on such a trip for a couple of us. The Captain explained our options to us regarding the weather, the waves and any seasickness. He was very patient and accommodating. Captain Jim is a seasoned Captain who clearly knows what he is doing. He also worked hard to be sure we caught all the fish we could, even turning to go back out so we could fish longer in deeper water to catch more fish. We had a good day on the lake, caught our limit of walleye and enjoyed the experience. Will definitely use Making Memories again if we do another fishing trip. You will not regret going with this Charter.

  • Todd Weaver
    Todd Weaver
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2020
    5.0
    Verified

    Half Day Walleye with Captain Jim

    7 Hour Trip – Walleye (PM) on July 26, 2020 • 5 adults

    We had an absolutely great time with Captain Jim and First Mate Jim. Our experience was beyond expectations. They were both fully engaged for the entire trip making sure that our Father/Son fishing memories were ones that will last forever. All 5 of us limited out and we will be back making more memories with the Makin Memories crew in the future. If you are considering a charter, I recommend this one with two thumbs up. Thank you for a fantastic time!

  • Teddy Ripley
    Teddy Ripley
    us
    Hawaii, US
    Member since 2020
    5.0
    Verified

    Fishing trip with Mike and his 1st mate

    8 Hour Trip – Yellow Perch (AM) on September 15, 2020 • 4 adults

    Great sailor whom was professional and objective. Caught some beautiful fish and observed Jim navigate with the rules of the road in mind. Can say that with 27 years experience as a Navy veteran. Solid boat with plenty of leg room that is indeed blue water capable. We will return for a follow up fishing trip. There is no need or desire to call someone else to get the job done.

  • Kara Matthews
    Kara Matthews
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2020
    5.0
    Verified

    7hr walleye trip

    7 Hour Trip – Walleye (PM) on July 18, 2020 • 2 adults

    I bought this trip for my boyfriend who love to fish. We will definitely be coming back! Captain Jim was very nice and knowledgeable. He helped us catch our daily limit of fish. He helped direct us where to get our licenses and where we could go around town for camping, food and where to get our fish cleaned. I would suggest Makin’ Memories for anyone interested in fishing Lake Erie.

  • Brock Selman
    Brock Selman
    us
    West Virginia, US
    Member since 2021
    5.0
    Verified

    8 hour drift and troll

    8 Hour Trip – Drifting Special on June 20, 2021 • 4 adults • 2 children

    It was an off day, nobody on the lake was catching anything but Jim and Mario still made it a memorable trip. Cranked in some big ones, had fun and learned a lot about catching walleyes. We'll be back!

  • Craig Holcomb
    Craig Holcomb
    us
    Ohio, US
    Member since 2020
    5.0
    Verified

    Half day trip with Captain Jim

    8 Hour Trip – Walleye (AM) on July 8, 2020 • 4 adults

    It was a slow day for most, but Captain Jim and Maria worked hard to assure we caught our limit of Walleye. We had a great experience and Captain Jim is very knowledgeable, but also personable and friendly. Would def go again and recommend to anyone. Had my family up from Louisiana and we “made memories” for sure!

  • Renay Crouse
    Renay Crouse
    us
    Ohio, US
    Member since 2020
    5.0
    Verified

    1/2 day trip

    7 Hour Trip – Walleye (PM) on August 8, 2020 • 5 adults

    Fun day filled with memories and a lot of fish. The captain and first mate worked hard to make sure we had an amazing time and came home with fish.

  • John Szurley
    John Szurley
    Repeat angler
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2020
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great 85th Birthday Trip

    7 Hour Trip – Walleye (PM) on July 23, 2020 • 3 adults

    Captain Jimmy and Captain Jim provided everything we wanted for this trip. It took us only a few hours to get our limit. They lived up to their name! Thanks

FAQs about Makin' Memories Fishing Charter

Makin' Memories Fishing Charter offers the following trips to customers:
  • US $300 per group, additional US $50 per person after 4 guests - 2 Hour Sunset Cruise - no fishing (2 hours)
  • US $440 per group, additional US $110 per person after 4 guests - 4 Hour Trip – Steelhead (AM) (4 hours)
  • US $440 per group, additional US $110 per person after 4 guests - 4 Hour Trip – Steelhead (PM) (4 hours)
  • US $700 per group, additional US $175 per person after 4 guests - 8 Hour Trip – Drifting Special (8 hours)
  • US $800 per group, additional US $200 per person after 4 guests - 7 Hour Trip – Walleye (PM) (7 hours)
  • US $800 per group, additional US $200 per person after 4 guests - 8 Hour Trip – Walleye (AM) (8 hours)
  • US $800 per group, additional US $200 per person after 4 guests - 8 Hour Trip – Yellow Perch (AM) (8 hours)
  • US $800 per group, additional US $200 per person after 4 guests - 8 Hour Trip – Yellow Perch (PM) (8 hours)
  • US $980 per group, additional US $245 per person after 4 guests - 8 Hour Trip – Walleye/Perch (AM) (8 hours)
When you book a trip with Makin' Memories Fishing Charter, you can expect the following amenities onboard:
  • Toilet
  • GPS
  • Fishfinder
  • Radar
Trips booked with Makin' Memories Fishing Charter include:
  • Rods, reels & tackle
  • Live bait
  • Lures
  • First mate
Makin' Memories Fishing Charter offers the following type of fishing:
  • Lake fishing (Erie)
Makin' Memories Fishing Charter offers the following fishing techniques:
  • Light tackle
  • Heavy tackle
  • Bottom fishing
  • Trolling
Top targeted fish species with Makin' Memories Fishing Charter include:
  • Bass (White)
  • Perch (White)
  • Perch (Yellow)
  • Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)
  • Walleye

Your operator

Makin' Memories Fishing Charters
Makin' Memories Fishing Charters
Conneaut, Ohio, United States
49 Fishing Reports
ID & license verified
40 Customer reviews
Typical response within an hour
Member since April 2017
For Captain Jim fishing Lake Erie is his job as well as his passion. It all began more than five decades ago, when he had the chance to share his passion for fishing Walleye with family and friends. Captain Jim and his team will teach you their fishing tricks, such as what bait works the best, or how deep you should target feeding fish. They will take you to the best spots and will make sure you have the very best experience. And that's what people love the most about Jim's business. Their passion for fishing as well as making their clients have a wonderful time on the water.
Makin' Memories Fishing Charters
Makin' Memories Fishing Charters
Fully verified
49
reports
40
reviews
2017
member since
~1h
response
For Captain Jim fishing Lake Erie is his job as well as his passion. It all began more than five decades ago, when he had the chance to share his passion for fishing Walleye with family and friends. Captain Jim and his team will teach you their fishing tricks, such as what bait works the best, or how deep you should target feeding fish. They will take you to the best spots and will make sure you have the very best experience. And that's what people love the most about Jim's business. Their passion for fishing as well as making their clients have a wonderful time on the water.

The fish you can target

White Bass
White Bass
White Perch
White Perch
Yellow Perch
Yellow Perch
Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)
Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)
Walleye
Walleye
White Bass
White Bass
White Perch
White Perch
Yellow Perch
Yellow Perch
Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)
Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)
Walleye
Walleye

Real catches by this captain

  • A group of anglers proudly displaying their catch of Walleye on a catch board at Conneaut, Ohio, showcasing a successful fishing trip.
    Matt C.
    Matt C.
    Everyone caught their limits. Friendly captain and crew. They bent over backwards to make it a great trip.
  • An angler proudly displaying a freshly caught fish while aboard a fishing boat during a sunset outing.
    Fish 1
    Flathead
    Justin N.
    Justin N.
    We decided to do a trip with Captain Jim. I have went out on his boat 5 other times. When I had a few guys that wanted to go this year I couldn't think of anyone better to go with that Makin Memories! The knowledge Captain Jim has of the lake and the fish is outstanding. This crew will go above and beyond the get you the fish you deserve! Went out this past Saturday and had an amazing time! We couldn't ask for better weather, more fish, or a better crew to guide us on this fishing trip! If your looking to go and want a charter group that makes your trip a priority and has the knowledge to go along with thier skills Makin Memories is who you want!
  • Two anglers display a pair of walleye catches aboard a fishing boat offshore, with rods and marine equipment visible.
    Anna N.
    Anna N.
    Captain Jim and First Mate Mariah were great. This was the first experience on such a trip for a couple of us. The Captain explained our options to us regarding the weather, the waves and any seasickness. He was very patient and accommodating. Captain Jim is a seasoned Captain who clearly knows what he is doing. He also worked hard to be sure we caught all the fish we could, even turning to go back out so we could fish longer in deeper water to catch more fish. We had a good day on the lake, caught our limit of walleye and enjoyed the experience. Will definitely use Making Memories again if we do another fishing trip. You will not regret going with this Charter.
  • A group of anglers proudly posing in front of a catch board displaying a variety of fish, including several large Walleye, after a successful fishing trip.
    Andy L.
    Andy L.
  • A young boy is learning to fish with the help of an adult on a boat, showcasing a family-friendly fishing experience.
    Fish 1
    Striped Bass
    Brock S.
    Brock S.
    It was an off day, nobody on the lake was catching anything but Jim and Mario still made it a memorable trip. Cranked in some big ones, had fun and learned a lot about catching walleyes. We'll be back!
  • A group of anglers proudly posing in front of a catch board displaying multiple fish, including several Walleye, after a successful fishing trip.
    Holly H.
    Holly H.
    Captain Jim and his First Mate Mariah were wonderful. Mother Nature was a bit to be reckoned with as far as catching our limit this day. However, they were an awesome crew, taught us a lot, and they were friendly and cordial the entire time. I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a Lake Erie charter. The boat is easy to find, it's simple to park, and there was more than enough room for our group.
  • A group of anglers proudly posing in front of a catch board displaying an impressive haul of Walleye after a successful fishing trip.
    Greg S.
    Greg S.
  • Group of anglers proudly displaying their catch of Walleye on a board after a successful fishing trip.
    Greg S.
    Greg S.
  • Two anglers proudly posing beside a catch board displaying multiple Walleye after a successful fishing trip.
    Theresa  .
    Theresa .
    Awesome trip maxed out in two hours
  • Group posing beside a large catch board filled with multiple fish outside Makin Memories Fishing Charters.
    Fish 1
    Yellow Perch
    Teddy R.
    Teddy R.
    Great sailor whom was professional and objective. Caught some beautiful fish and observed Jim navigate with the rules of the road in mind. Can say that with 27 years experience as a Navy veteran. Solid boat with plenty of leg room that is indeed blue water capable. We will return for a follow up fishing trip. There is no need or desire to call someone else to get the job done.

What is the boat like?

Boat image
Boat category
Sportfishing boats
Capacity
6 persons
Boat length
30 ft
Year built
1989
Boat manufacturer
Cherokee
Boat type
Sportfishing
Engine model
Chevrolet Crusader
Powered by
2 x 230HP
Max cruising speed
35 knots

What kind of fishing will you do?

Lake Fishing

Which fishing techniques you can try

Light Tackle
Heavy Tackle
Bottom Fishing
Trolling

Which amenities are available onboard

Toilet
GPS
Fishfinder
Radar

What's included in the trip price

Rods, reels & tackle
Live bait
Lures
First mate

How cancellations work

Free cancellation up to 3 days prior to trip
You can cancel or modify your booking up to 3 days before the trip date, free of charge. If you cancel or modify your booking later, or fail to show up, you'll forfeit 100% of what you've paid.
More details

What the listing policies are

Pickup not included
Transfer to/from departure site is not included in trip rates.
Child friendly
You keep catch

How you can pay

Book with 10% deposit, pay rest to captain
When the captain confirms your trip, FishingBooker charges your credit card a 10% deposit to guarantee your reservation.
The remaining balance is to be paid directly to the charter operator on or prior to your trip date in one of the following payment methods:
 Cash
 Visa
 Mastercard
 American Express
 PayPal
 Checks
When paying the remaining balance with a credit card, an additional 4% charge will apply.

What’s biting in Conneaut right now

Perch (Yellow)Perch (Yellow)
Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)Rainbow Trout (Steelhead)
WalleyeWalleye

Compare similar fishing charters

Current
Makin' Memories Fishing Charter
Makin' Memories Fishing Charter
4.9
(37)
30 ft
Group size 1 - 6
1 - 6
Fish 1
Fish 2
+3
4 hour trip • 6 persons
US $440