This was our family’s first big fishing trip. We were very impressed with the boat and equipment. Edgar was not able to join us on the trip, but his crew was professional and attentive and took care of absolutely everything. Unfotunately, the waters were quite rough (completely out of the crews control, of course), and the motion sickness medicine we took was no match for it. Realizing the rough waters and motion sickness would keep us from enjoying the trip, the crew got in touch with Edgar. Edgar and I spoke and decided to cut the trip short. He was so gracious about it and in the end did not charge us the remaining fee (we did tip the crew for their time). Even though we had to cut the trip short, I’m leaving a 5 star review becaus Edgar and his crew handled the situation with such professionalism and kindness. We would definitely charter with Edgar again.

We chose Tease Me Sportfishing because of the number of reviews and the 5 star rating.  They definitely stand up to the reviews we read.  We were out with Juan and Jose, both are very knowledgeable about the ocean and fishing.  We saw 2 whales jumping and my wife caught a barracuda.  We had a huge number of bite offs, and the crew would quickly change the bait.  We went out fishing for 4 hours and I am planning to do a complete day on our next vacation here.  I would definitely recommend this private charter service!  This was well worth the money and they are true professionals!  Thank you for an awesome experience!

From start to finish, this charter trip was a class act. Captain Edgar and his team were incredibly professional, knowledgable, and kind to our family. Our guide worked so hard the entire trip to ensure we had a successful excursion. True to Captain Edgar’s word, we were picked up on time at our resort, provided water/beverages, lunch, and a great experience. We did suffer from motion sickness but that’s par for the course with deep sea fishing; what impressed me was the kindness they showed us throughout it all. The 7’2” white marlin and tuna cured any discomfort. Thank you for an incredible experience, and remember to visit us in Green Bay!

I had been following the Tease me Sportfishing boat on Facebook and Instagram and thought wow I need to go out with them. Edgar responded back right away and kept me informed of the trip! Edgar is an awesome person to talk to in person.  He had transportation pick us up and take us back from our hotel in a fancy car and they arrived on time and were waiting for us when we got off the boat. My dream was to catch a Marlin and they made my dream happen thank you both so much. Jose and the captain were amazing they did everything to get us on fish. Jose was the fastest mate I have ever seen! He was always checking the lines and putting fresh bait on and had time to make sandwiches. My husband and I were very impressed by the teamwork the mate and the captain had together. My husband enjoyed talking to Jose about his life and learning new things about fishing. It was very nice getting to know the crew such sweet people. When I come back I will definitely book them again. Hands down best fishing trip I have ever been on! Don’t book anyone but Tease me Sportfishing!

This review was from feb 1st 2019. Originally booked an 8 hour trip. After talking with captain, decided on 10 hour trip. The 10 hour trip , you are heading to the Atlantic ocean, where big blue marlin are mating and feeding. This was once in life time trip with my stepson and future son in law. Captain Edgar contacted me at my resort day before leaving, after I emailed him on concerns of the rough ocean. In a different country, unsure of what to expect. ie too rough to fish, but take you out anyway. Captain Edgar assured me he would not take any customer out in unfishable waters, and to trust your captain. he said I will be straight with you, it is going to be rough in morning because the Caribean waters and Atlantic waters meet while tide is out. He assured me when we get to atlantic waters it will be calm enough to fish. He told me this is perfect marlin weather. They like it on rough side instead of flat. He recommended we take damamine night before, and morning of. We were under half power part way and then just as he said , we got into Atlantic waters boat was able to go full throttle for remainder of ride, which took total of 1 hour 25 minutes. We started trolling and crew went to work, setting teasers and baited lines. Eveybody new their jobs and worked as a well organized team. In less than an hour the action started with first hook up a blue marlin. The action continued all day long. By the end of day around 4 pm, we were getting ready to leave, reeling in lines when captain Edgar yelled a bill fish was coming to last bait out. It turned out to be a sail fish. That gave us the acclaimed grand slam of bill fish. 3 blue marlin, 1 white marlin and a sail fish. We also boated 18 mai- mai, 1 wahoo and a huge barracuda!!!! I never imagined we could actually get the grand slam, but after watching the close attention the crew , kept on keeping things going, when it would slow up, in came baits and new baits went out. they were meticulous on how baits tied on, detail means everything. Captain Edgar kept us in the fish. This is how a team works. Pilot at the wheel is a seasoned 30 year fisherman. Captain Edgar was born in North Carolina and grew up in the Dominican republic so he can talk to you like your talking to your neighbor, and he speaks Spanish like the locals. The crew could speak English good, and were willing to answer any questions I had, which was a lot.The crew worked their tails off to get us fish and deserved and got a nice tip. If your thinking of going out for marlin, take the 10 hour Atlantic trip, trust your captain, do what they are telling you to do. I would also recommend working on your upper body strength, Marlin are strong, you will think your arms are going to fall off after a 30 minute fight. I RECOMEND TEASE ME SPORTFISHING TO EVERYONE!!!!! The phrase I remember most captain Edgar said and was so true ” you cant improvise experience”  Scott upper Michigan USA…..