Captain Tyler was very patient and very knowledgeable about the local reefs and best places to catch fish. He was so good that on his “demonstration cast” he hooked up immediately and my son reeled in his first ever shark! We had three other sharks to follow that and an over four foot barracuda! It was truly the trip of a lifetime! We had several yellow tail and some snapper immediately after that. Trying to find some calmer waters for us Ohioans we ended up hooking up to another barracuda... More

We booked a 6 hour fishing charter with them. Our captain Nathan was one of a kind. He gave us a rundown before we started the trip. I am very experienced with deep sea fishing having maybe 15 charters under my belt, whereas it was my newly wed wife’s first trip out on the water. We first went near a marina and he tossed a net catching a ton of chum fish. Then we headed out on the water. Overall caught 17 Mahi that we kept, countless others thrown back. Also a few jacks and barracuda. He was... More

My wife and I booked an all day trip while on a week long vacation. Double header was very responsive to messages confirming the booking and where to go day of. Upon arrival we met Nathan, who was extremely friendly immediately welcoming us to the island and asked what we wanted to target and immediately was able to give us a layout of what we could expect throughout the day. Within 30 minutes of hitting our fishing area we already had one of the target fish (mahi mahi) on board. We had an amazing... More

Our group of 4 took the half day morning trip. Within 10 minutes of the trip we were already reeling them in! Our captain knew what he was doing and worked his tail off to make sure we were in a great location. Everyone in our group caught multiple fish (Mahi)!

Matt did a great job getting us on the fish within seconds of our first spot. In total, we caught nearly 40 fish of a variety of species. Matt was patient and helped get some of the first-timers in our group comfortable with the process. He cleaned our keepers and pointed us in the right direction where we had our catch cooked for lunch. Would highly recommend Double Header and Matt!