Ben Geroy
Captain

Ben Geroy

Naples, United States
Angler's choice
100+ reviews
I was born and raised in Naples, FL, and have been exploring and fishing the backwaters since I could hold a fishing rod. My father has also been a full-time fishing guide in Naples for almost 40 years. In a way, you can say I was 'born into the business'.

Charter

Rating

5.0
138 reviews
4.9
Boat & Equipment
5.0
Captain & Crew
5.0
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

98%
Good experience
100%
Friendly captain
100%
Recommend this charter
98%
Appropriate for children
100%
Satisfied with the boat
98%
Caught fish

All reviews (138)

Showing 1 – 5 of 138 reviews
  • William Pardi
    William Pardi
    Repeat angler
    us
    Washington State, US
    Member since 2025
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Excellent charter, highly recommend

    Half Day Trip (AM) • 2 adults

    We had an absolutely fantastic day out on the water with captain Ben. I hooked and landed an 80 lb Tarpon, which as a complete novice I attribute solely to Ben's ability to coach me through the process. He provided me with the necessary equipment and advice to bring it in, keeping things low stress despite the size and aggressiveness of the fish I had on the line. Highly recommend this charter whether you're experienced or totally new to fishing.

    Response from Captain

    Thank you for the stellar review!

  • Malorie Johnson
    Malorie Johnson
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Fishing Day with Capt. Ben!

    Morning 3 Hour • 2 adults

    He definitely knows where the fish go, we were catching fish as soon as we were throwing the reels in. Very helpful throughout the trip with baiting and unhooking the fish ( for those who want to fish without the work of fishing lol) Would recommend him to anyone looking for a local charter in Naples.

    Response from Captain

    Thank you gor the review, Malorie!

  • Gregg Robert Huettl Huettl
    Gregg Robert Huettl Huettl
    us
    Wisconsin, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified
    NEW

    Fishing with Ben

    Half Day Trip (AM) • 1 adult

    Captain was very personable and knowledgeable. Had a great time.

    Reported catch:
    Jack Crevalle
    Response from Captain

    Thanks for the 5 star review Gregg!

  • Alyssa Tejeda
    Alyssa Tejeda
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    super cool trip!

    Morning 3 Hour • 2 adults

    we had a lot of fun on captain bens boat. it was my first time catching a fish and im completely satisfied! we caught plenty and definitely would book again :)

    Response from Captain

    thanks for the great review Alyssa!

  • Beth Shaw
    Beth Shaw
    Repeat angler
    us
    Virginia, US
    Member since 2022
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Fantastic morning out on the water

    Morning 3 Hour • 2 adults

    My son and I really enjoyed our trip woth Captain Ben and would highly recommend this trip. Caught a snook and lots of fairly decent sized Jack fish. Nice easy trip and lots of fun. Also saw a dolphin and lots of heron, eagle, osprey, and some other wildlife including a wild boar and swimming racoons.

    Response from Captain

    Thanks for the review Beth, glad you two had fun!

Real catches shared by our community

  • Captain Ben Charters
    Captain Ben ChartersNaples, FL
    Great Fishing Day with Capt. Ben!
    Malorie J.
    Malorie J.
  • Captain Ben Charters
    Captain Ben ChartersNaples, FL
    Fun morning!
    Joyce K.
    Joyce K.
  • Captain Ben Charters
    Captain Ben ChartersNaples, FL
    great day!
    Mike S.
    Mike S.
  • Captain Ben Charters
    Captain Ben ChartersNaples, FL
    super cool trip!
    Alyssa T.
    Alyssa T.
  • Captain Ben Charters
    Captain Ben ChartersNaples, FL
    A sucsesful trip
    Ron H.
    Ron H.
  • Captain Ben Charters
    Captain Ben ChartersNaples, FL
    Great Fishing Trip!
    Amanda L.
    Amanda L.
  • Captain Ben Charters
    Captain Ben ChartersNaples, FL
    Captain knows Best !
    Scott M.
    Scott M.
  • Captain Ben Charters
    Captain Ben ChartersNaples, FL
    Fantastic morning out on the water
    Beth S.
    Beth S.
  • Captain Ben Charters
    Captain Ben ChartersNaples, FL
    Great trip
    Nicki N.
    Nicki N.
  • Captain Ben Charters
    Captain Ben ChartersNaples, FL
    Big Redfish!
    Shauna C.
    Shauna C.

What's biting with Captain Ben Charters in Naples

Water temperatures cool considerably, making the all-day bite better than it was in previous months. Fish start to move into the back bays and passes. The Redfish bite is on fire in October.

Top catches for October

Fishing reports

Two anglers proudly displaying their Redfish catch while enjoying a sunny day on the water.

Breaking in the NEW BOAT!

Sep 18, 2023 • Naples
The last couple months of fishing have had good days and bad. I've been breaking in a brand new boat since June, which takes getting used to, but the platform is much more roomy and comfortable for clients and myself! It's been one of the hottest summers, with record breaking water temperatures, which has rendered a lot of our back bay areas almost unfishable. I believe the fish that didn't move out of these areas are just plain too hot to eat aggressively. Temps have declined a little, and fishing action has definitely improved, but we are still primarily fishing closer to the outside passes and beaches, where fish seem to be happier and more plentiful. I expect as we get further into fall and temps drop a little more, fish will start to flood the back country and be very hungry! Here are some notable summer catches aboard the new boat!
Show more
A young angler proudly displaying a large Tarpon while fishing in a mangrove area.

Post Hurricane Ian Action!

Nov 17, 2022 • Naples
We are about 6 weeks after hurricane Ian, the most devastating storm we've had in arguably the last 100 years. Many coastal neighborhoods from Marco Island to Sarasota experienced storm surge like never before. With that said, the Naples and Marco are fared considerably better than other towns to the north. Many of the businesses in town that were flooded are already open for business, including us! Fishing after the storm has been very interesting. For the first couple weeks, the water was very stirred up and dirty, and it seemed every fish was near the outside, along the passes. We had a few great days catching countless snook and redfish in a very small fishing area. As more time went by, the waters cleaned back up a bit, and the fish started to spread back out into the backwater bays and channels. The better days, with good current, snook, redfish, jacks, and seatrout are fairly active
Show more
An angler proudly displaying a large Goliath Grouper while fishing in a mangrove area, showcasing the thrill of inshore fishing.

Winter Time Variety!

Jan 26, 2022 • Naples
It's been quite a busy holiday season and first month of the New Year! While the weather and temperatures have been on a bit of a roller coaster ride, we're still managing to stay on the fish pretty well. The last month of so has produced some of the best sea trout fishing I've seen in the area in years, a great thing to see! We're also seeing a wide variety of species coming to the boat, as we typically do in the winter. Sometimes we will catch as many as 12+ species in a half day trip. Cheers to another fishy year!
Show more
A young angler proudly displaying a large Jack Crevalle while fishing in calm waters, showcasing a successful day on the boat.

Hard Fighting Fall Fish!

Nov 9, 2021 • Naples
Whenever people ask when the best fishing is in Naples, usually September and October are in the conversation. Late summer, and through the fall, sometimes all the way through the new year if it stays warm, can be the best fishing you can get in Southwest Florida. It seems that everything is happening in these last couple months before the cold fronts start coming. This year has been no exception, redfish, snook, jacks, and sharks have all been punishing baits in the backwaters the last month or so! Another great part about the fall is there's usually no shortage of baitfish around, making the morning bait run quick and easy, more time for fishing!
Show more
A young angler proudly displaying a large Snook while standing in shallow waters, with a boat visible in the background.

HOT Summer Action!

Aug 18, 2021 • Naples
We've had a quite a busy season this year, a welcomed bounce back from the shutdowns that caused us to fish quite a bit less last spring and summer. I can't remember a year I've been so busy through July! Generally, mid summer is our slowest time of year, air and waters reach their warmest temps, and fishing action is best near dawn and dusk. We are doing almost exclusively 4 or 6 hour morning trips right now to stay in the action, avoid the heat, and potentially dangerous afternoon thunderstorms. Baitfish can be found all over the inlets and beaches right now, making bait catching a breeze, and allowing us to get fishing by 7-7:30am. Snook fishing has been an absolute blast this summer, with tons of action on the "cookie cutter" 18-20 inch fish, and a few big ones in the mix. Aside from the snook, mangrove snapper have been quite aggressive as well. While they are smaller fish, snappers are one of the few inshore species we are able to keep at the moment, so they're great to see! Redfish have been making appearances more and more also, and the average size is getting close to 25 inches or more, which is close to what it was before the big red tide event a few years ago. Other recent catches include goliath grouper, barracudas, tarpon, sharks, and jack crevalle.
Show more
Two anglers proudly displaying their catches, a Redfish and a Black Drum, while enjoying a sunny day on the water.

Early Spring Fishing ACTION!

Mar 6, 2021 • Naples
It's been a busy start to the season this year, and anglers have been catching a wide variety of fish! For the last three weeks or so, the weather has been warm, allowing the water to warm up to spring like tempuratures. With that warm water we have been fishing with live bait fish. On the days with better tides, fish are chomping up the baits happily! Common catches recently have been snook, jack crevalle, and mangrove snappers, but we are catching some seatrout, redfish, small tarpon, and others in the mix as well!
Show more