
Captain Sean Otis Cralley

Charter
Rating
Anglers' gallery (11)
All reviews (10)
Krista AyersWest Virginia, US•Member since 20265.0VerifiedReady to book again!
5 Hour Trip, • 2 adultsSean with Waymaker was absolutely wonderful to work with! My husband and I had such an amazing experience from start to finish. He was incredibly patient with us and made sure we had a great time the entire trip. We didn’t even make it out of the parking lot before we were already looking at dates to book another trip with him! Sean knew exactly where the best fishing spots were and worked with us around the weather to make sure we had the best experience possible. He also took the time to answer our many questions—not only about fishing, but about the boat and all the fishing terms and vocabulary we weren’t familiar with. He never made us feel rushed or silly for asking questions. What really stood out was how personable he was. We didn’t just feel like customers on a charter—we genuinely enjoyed getting to know him. We spent time talking about our families, hobbies, and jobs, which made the whole trip feel relaxed and enjoyable. It felt more like spending the day fishing with a friend than simply booking a trip. If you’re looking for a knowledgeable, patient captain who truly cares about making your trip memorable, Sean with Waymaker is the one to book. We can’t wait to come back and fish with him again! 🎣
Reported catch:
Kristy PrestonPennsylvania, US•Member since 20265.0Verifiedfirst time on a charter!!
Evening Walleye Trip • 2 adultsI booked this trip as a surprise for my husband for Father’s Day. We had a great time. We caught our limit on Walleye. We couldn’t of asked for a better day! Sean and Rene (1st mate) were fantastic. Did not make it feel like they were running a business. It felt like a group of friends out on the lake. They were so willing to explain everything and how the rigs worked. The fact that we limited out surprised us. Just did not know what to expect. Definitely recommend them if you want to have a great time and feel like your fishing with friends.
Response from CaptainIt was great having you both aboard, and I had a great time getting to know you both, looking forward to your next trip on Waymaker.
Lily OrrPennsylvania, US•Member since 20265.0VerifiedExcellent!!
Morning trip - 10:30 AM • 2 adultsWould 100% recommend. The conditions were choppy with 3-4 ft swells but Sean had us on fish within 10 minutes of the first line in the water. With the help of first mate Rene, we had our 2 man limit within 4 hours. A amazing, affordable, experience with Waymaker Fishing Charters!!
Reported catch:
Response from CaptainIt was great having you both aboard. Looking forward to your next trip on Waymaker Fishing Charter.
John KollingerPennsylvania, US•Member since 20265.0VerifiedGreat Trip!
Morning trip • 2 adultsHad a great day with captain Sean and Renny. Me and a buddy were first timers on Erie. These guys are very talented and friendly too. Will definitely fish with them again. Only way ill look for someone else is if they are unavailable.
Response from CaptainGlad we could make your first trip on Lake Erie a great one. Look forward to having you aboard again.
Adam ProsserRepeat anglerMissouri, US•Member since 2022•3 trips5.0VerifiedBig walleye and great guides!!!!
Morning trip - 10:30 AM • 2 adultsSean and Rene were great. They got us on big walleye and had us a limit in no time. Rene also gave us a history lesson of the light houses around the area. Anybody who wants to catch fish, should book Waymaker Fishing Charter.
Response from CaptainIt was great having you aboard. Great memories and friendships were made. Looking forward to duck season.
Real catches shared by our community
Waymaker Fishing CharterErie, PA
Waymaker Fishing CharterErie, PA
Waymaker Fishing CharterErie, PA
Waymaker Fishing CharterErie, PA
Waymaker Fishing CharterErie, PA
Waymaker Fishing CharterErie, PA
Waymaker Fishing CharterErie, PA
What's biting with Waymaker Fishing Charter in Erie
This is one of the best months to come to Erie and spend a couple of days fishing. You can target Walleye and Steelhead, jumbo Perch, and epic Bass in the bay.








