
A Fishing Guru





Charters
- IslamoradaInstant ConfirmationTrips fromUS $650
- IslamoradaInstant ConfirmationTrips fromUS $550
Rating
Anglers' gallery (92)
What anglers say
Reviews (74)
Khang NguyenRepeat angler5.0VerifiedJune 2026 fishing trip
Half Day Trip – Reef Fishing (PM) on June 16, 2026 • 6 adults • 2 childrenDylan and his brother Ryan were great and our family really enjoyed them both. Originally we booked for a 4 hour reef fishing but after informing Dylan some of the girls may be prone to getting sea sick he suggested we opt for the offshore- trolling fishing vs sitting at and bottom fishing we did not regret that decision at all. They were more than happy to accommodate the last minute change of plans, the fish were biting and we managed to catch several keepers….blackfin tunas, mahi, and a Almaco jack. They were both helpful and were not afraid to share any valuable fishing knowledge they have, on top of all that their 39’ contender speaks for itself. Plenty of space to move around with a group of 6 and they made us feel at home. Only thing we would do differently is book a full day instead of 4 hours.
Rob YoxthimerRepeat angler5.0VerifiedOffshore trip to remember
6 Hour Trip – Offshore on July 7, 2026 • 2 adultsThis offshore trip with my 16yo son was amazing. Pete and his first mate, Ryan, were helpful and fun to be around. Although we’re expeienced anglers back in the midwest, We learned a lot about unique techniques of deep sea fishing. We caught some amazing blackfin tuna, skipjack tuna, and almaco jack. Ate some here and packing some for home. Pete is super detailed about fishing techniques great at explaining. Thanks for making a fun ans worthwhile day. Rob
Perry Marcin5.0VerifiedThe Fishing Guru Rocks!
Half Day Trip – Reef Fishing (PM) on April 7, 2026 • 4 adults • 2 childrenWe had an amazing experience with The Fishing Guru in Islamorada! Captain Daryl and mate George were incredible from start to finish—friendly, knowledgeable, and great with our kids (ages 13 and 10), who had an absolute blast. We caught 13 yellowtail snapper, including one impressive 23” fish! The action was steady and exciting the whole trip. George made everything easy—walk on, fish, then walk off with all of our catch perfectly filleted and ready to go. Highly recommend this crew if you’re looking for a fun, family-friendly fishing trip in the Keys. We’ll definitely be back! 🎣
Tim Bales5.0VerifiedNEWAn Extreme Pole Bender Good Time!
6 Hour Trip – Backcountry on October 29, 2026 • 4 adultsCaptain Pete found monsters that our biceps will remind us of for days and also the varieties everyone wants for the best catch and cook experiences. The water/currents were a challenge, but he put us on the fish despite tough conditions. We had a great trip!
Daniel Castro5.0VerifiedAmazing Experience!
6 Hour Trip – Backcountry on July 12, 2026 • 3 adultsTalk about someone that knows what they are doing! Captain Peter walked us exactly through what we were going to catch before we even left the dock. He proceeded to deliver on what he promised. Took care of all of us on the boat, a mix of beginner to advanced level, with extraordinary skill and patience. We are already planning to book again with Captain Peter & A Fishing Guru. Highly recommended, book now!
Ish MonterreyRepeat angler5.0VerifiedExceptional Day on the Water with Captain Pete!
4 Hour Trip – Reef Fishing (AM) on July 11, 2026 • 2 adultsWe had the absolute best time fishing with Captain Pete! He put us right on the fish, and we caught our limit of both mangrove snapper and trout. The boat is fantastic—clean, comfortable, and perfect for a great day out. Captain Pete himself is awesome, super fun to be around, and really knows his stuff. If you want an amazing, productive fishing trip, he is definitely your guy. Highly recommend, and we will definitely be back!
Mackenzie Henderson-kellRepeat angler4.7Verifiedmade the best out of the day
4 Hour Trip – Offshore (PM) on August 15, 2026 • 2 adultssounds like we came during a rough part of the year in August. waters are warm and fish are out deep in cooler water. long story short we didn't catch as much fish as I was hoping but pete and Dylan did their absolute best to make the trip as good as possible ended up catching a few snapper that got eaten at the boat by barracudas and caught 2 mahi and even a shark for my fiance. overall would recommend and come back during a better time of year
Kenneth Heller5.0VerifiedEpic fishing trip in back country Florida Bay
4 Hour Trip – Backcountry (AM) on August 19, 2026 • 2 adultsSnappers first, caught limit quickly then on to catch some trout. Petite wife hooked a 200lb Tarpon on 30lb test line as we watched this beautiful fish jump out of water 3 times before breaking line. Wife said “help me, help me” LOL. Captain Pete was awesome, knowledgeable and made trip fun and adventurous.
Thomas RussoRepeat angler5.0VerifiedEvening Tarpon and Shark experience
2 Hour Trip – Sunset Shark/Tarpon on July 16, 2026 • 2 adultsYoung Motivated Captain who knows the water and Channels well. It was the trip we wanted to finally take, and we had a great time. The weather cooperated and we stayed dry and managed to avoid the heat of the day with this evening trip. We look forward to repeating this again in the future. Tight lines everybody!
Robert Riney5.0VerifiedGreat trip
4 Hour Trip – Offshore (PM) on September 2, 2026 • 2 adultsThe trip was a blast, we caught a ton of fish and when they heard we wanted to see some dolphins they found some and got us a close up. We even wanted to see a manatee and they made it happen. They were very polite and frendly and helped us have a great time. 
Real catches shared by our community
A Fishing Guru – Inshore/Offshore/ReefIslamorada, FL
A Fishing Guru – Inshore/Offshore/ReefIslamorada, FL
A Fishing Guru – Inshore/Offshore/ReefIslamorada, FL
A Fishing Guru – Inshore/Offshore/ReefIslamorada, FL
A Fishing Guru – Inshore/Offshore/ReefIslamorada, FL
A Fishing Guru – Inshore/Offshore/ReefIslamorada, FL
A Fishing Guru – Inshore/Offshore/ReefIslamorada, FL
A Fishing Guru – Inshore/Offshore/ReefIslamorada, FL
A Fishing Guru – OffshoreIslamorada, FL
A Fishing Guru – Inshore/Offshore/ReefIslamorada, FL
























