Captain

Jeffrey Nagler

Languages: English
Experience: 35 years

Verifications

Email Address

Verified

Phone Number

XXX-XXX-X576

Captain
Jeffrey Nagler

Member since March 2017 New York City, United States

Background: Captain Jeffrey has 40 years of fishing experience and operating vessels of all kinds. He is a fun person who loves to connect with his guests, both return and new. He operates the charter out of a great love and passion for fishing and works with a hard-working crew of mates. Captain Jeffrey and his crew will always give their best to making your day on the water a productive and positive experience.

Hey, I'm Captain Jeffrey Nagler

New York City, United States

Background: Captain Jeffrey has 40 years of fishing experience and operating vessels of all kinds. He is a fun person who loves to connect with his guests, both return and new. He operates the charter out of a great love and passion for fishing and works with a hard-working crew of mates. Captain Jeffrey and his crew will always give their best to making your day on the water a productive and positive experience.

181

Reviews

Fishing Reports

My Charter Listings

Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star

4.6 / 5

(165 reviews)

4.6 / 5

(165 reviews)

New York City • 70 ft • 63 persons

Last booking: 1 hour ago

Instant Confirmation

Trips from US $65

Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion

4.6 / 5

(16 reviews)

4.6 / 5

(16 reviews)

New York City • 65 ft • 70 persons

Last booking: 2 days ago

Instant Confirmation

Trips from US $74

Fishing Reports

6/15 Night Trip

Jun 16, 2025 New York City

Pictures speak for themselves. Rain or Shine, we are sailing every night except Wednesday this week. We are currently using our boat the Capt Jeff Express for all our trips. Book your tickets here, online at midnight **hidden content**, or call Captian Jeff himself. Keep on the lookout on our facebook and instagram @Midnightfleet

Buckets of porgies!

Jul 6, 2019 New York City

Porgies are coming in. It was a slow start in the morning, but we caught em' this afternoon. Many went home with full buckets.

What's better than porgies?

Jun 20, 2019 New York City

More Porgies! Captain Jeff had the guys on a great wreck with porgies! Current was strong, but they caught a few. Join us this weekend for fluke and porgies!

Lots of Action

Jun 19, 2019 New York City

Fluking has been great the past few rainy days. Lots of action and plenty of keepers on the boat!!!

Killin' the Gators!

Jun 2, 2019 New York City

Tonight's fishing was excellent. We were catching the jumbo blues up to 15lbs.

Fluke Bite Is On!

May 31, 2019 New York City

Excellent showing of keepers. Franco caught his limit, Melk had a few and there were plenty more come up today. Join us at 8:30 am or 5:00 PM at Pier 1 on the Midnight Star.

Customer reviews

Rating summary

4.6 / 5

out of 5 stars from 181 reviews

See details

Boat

4.6 / 5

Crew

4.8 / 5

Experience

4.6 / 5

Photos & videos by reviewers (120)

+117

Angler rating

5 stars		138
4 stars		24
3 stars		8
2 stars		1
1 star		4

Anglers claimed

Good experience
	89%
Friendly captain
	97%
Recommend this charter
	90%
Appropriate for children
	84%
Satisfied with the boat
	94%
Caught fish
	79%

Appropriate for children
	84%
Satisfied with the boat
	94%
Caught fish
	79%

Sort by:

Sort by: Featured

Showing:

5 of 181 reviews

Showing 166 - 170 of 181 reviews

Edward B.

The Bronx, NY

3.7 / 5

Experience:

4.0 / 5

Boat

4.0 / 5

Crew

3.0 / 5

Overall

Fishing with Jeffrey

VERIFIED Full Day Trip – Shared on June 18, 2020

Edward B.

The Bronx, NY

3.7 / 5

Jun 18, 2020

Full Day Trip – Shared

Fishing with Jeffrey

VERIFIED

I was misled to believe that we would be targeting bass,blues, fluke other by what I saw on the website of the star. Ling ,cod really not overall exciting very disappointing.

I was misled to believe that we would be targeting bass,blues, fluke other by what I saw on the website of the star....

Edward B. does not recommend Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star

Mark review as helpful

Jeffrey Nagler (The Captain)

Replied on June 20, 2020

MY NAME Mr.Book we are not in the business of misleading pple .Upon purchasing a tkt ou for website never mentions we are top water fishing for bass or blues or fluke.We are bottom fishing ling ,cod, porgies which we did fish for.Porgies did not bight we left to go to jersey and caught ling.One man in the stern corner had over 40 fish.Again no where does it state that on the website. Thk you Capt.Jeff

Jeffrey Nagler (The Captain)

Replied on June 20, 2020

MY NAME

Mr.Book we are not in the business of misleading pple .Upon purchasing a tkt ou for website never mentions we are top water fishing for bass or blues or fluke.We are bottom fishing ling ,cod, porgies which we did fish for.Porgies did not bight we left to go to jersey and caught ling.One man in the stern corner had over 40 fish.Again no where does it state that on the website.

Thk you
Capt.Jeff

Captain replied

Virginia P.

Fort Lee, NJ

4.0 / 5

Experience:

3.0 / 5

Boat

4.0 / 5

Crew

5.0 / 5

Overall

Fishing with Jeffrey

VERIFIED Full Day Trip – Shared on August 26, 2018

Virginia P.

Fort Lee, NJ

4.0 / 5

Aug 26, 2018

Full Day Trip – Shared

Fishing with Jeffrey

VERIFIED

It was fun day and the fish were great

Virginia P. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star

Mark review as helpful

Virginia P. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star

Mark review as helpful

George F.

The Bronx, NY

3.3 / 5

Experience:

3.0 / 5

Boat

4.0 / 5

Crew

3.0 / 5

Overall

Fishing with Jeffrey

VERIFIED Full Day Trip – Shared on August 30, 2019

George F.

The Bronx, NY

3.3 / 5

Aug 30, 2019

Full Day Trip – Shared

Fishing with Jeffrey

VERIFIED

George F. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star

Mark review as helpful

George F. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star

Mark review as helpful

Pascual B.

The Bronx, New York

4.3 / 5

Experience:

4.0 / 5

Boat

5.0 / 5

Crew

4.0 / 5

Overall

Half Day Trip - Shared - PM

VERIFIED Half Day Trip – Shared on July 7, 2017

Pascual B.

The Bronx, New York

4.3 / 5

Jul 7, 2017

Half Day Trip – Shared

Half Day Trip - Shared - PM

VERIFIED

Pascual B. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star

Mark review as helpful

Pascual B. recommends Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star

Mark review as helpful

Amerigo R.

The captain canceled

VERIFIED Trip was supposed to happen on July 26, 2022

Amerigo R.

Jul 26, 2022

The captain canceled

VERIFIED

The charter operator canceled on trip date. This is an automated posting.

Mark review as helpful

2 persons find this review helpful

Mark review as helpful

2 persons find this review helpful

...

Settings

Email Address

Phone Number

Captain
Jeffrey Nagler

Hey, I'm Captain Jeffrey Nagler

My Charter Listings

Midnight Fleet - Midnight Star

Capt. Jeff's Fishing Excursion

Fishing Reports

Fishing Reports

Customer reviews

Fishing with Jeffrey

Fishing with Jeffrey

Fishing with Jeffrey

Fishing with Jeffrey

Fishing with Jeffrey

Fishing with Jeffrey

Half Day Trip - Shared - PM

Half Day Trip - Shared - PM

The captain canceled

The captain canceled

About FishingBooker

Discover

Sitemap

Support