
Justin Irving
Charters
- PulaskiInstant ConfirmationTrips fromUS $650
- Sylvan BeachInstant ConfirmationTrips fromUS $300
Rating
Anglers' gallery (235)
What anglers say
Reviews (131)
Mark Reppert5.0VerifiedOutstanding Fishing Trip with Captain Justin
4 Hour Trip Salmon / Trout (PM) on September 5, 2026 • 6 adults • 3 childrenWe had an absolutely fantastic fishing trip with Captain Justin! From the moment we got on the boat, it was clear that he was extremely knowledgeable and experienced. He worked incredibly hard to put us on fish and was constantly adjusting rod setups, changing techniques, and making adjustments to give us the best chance at a successful day. We had three boys, all around 10 years old, with us, and they had an absolute blast reeling in King Salmon. Captain Justin was patient, friendly, and made sure everyone had a great experience. Seeing the boys’ excitement as they fought those big salmon was definitely the highlight of the trip! You can tell Captain Justin genuinely cares about his customers having a successful and memorable day on the water. He was knowledgeable, hardworking, friendly, and determined to put us on fish. We would highly recommend Captain Justin to anyone looking for a great fishing experience on Lake Ontario. We will definitely be fishing with him again!
Ken CarlsonRepeat angler5.0VerifiedTop-Notch Charter Experience
8 Hour Trip Salmon / Trout on June 24, 2026 • 5 adultsWe booked both a half-day and a full-day trip with Captain Justin at Over the Rail Sportsfishing, and I can’t recommend him highly enough. The half-day trip was a little slow, but that’s fishing, not the captain. What impressed us was that Justin never stopped working. Then on our full-day trip, we absolutely slammed the Lake Trout, and it was obvious why. I’ve never met a captain who knows the water, the fish, and their patterns as well as Justin. His work ethic is incredible. He was constantly adjusting, changing tactics, and doing whatever it took to keep us on fish. Watching him expertly manage 12 lines in the water for our group of five guys was impressive in itself. His skill, speed, professionalism, courtesy, and knowledge are second to none. He works incredibly hard from start to finish and genuinely wants his clients to have the best possible experience. Every one of us came away saying the same thing: if you’re looking for a charter captain who will outwork just about anyone and put you in the best position to catch fish, book Captain Justin. We all highly recommend him, and we’ll definitely be back!
Brandon Shea5.0VerifiedGreat Experience!
4 Hour Trip Salmon / Trout (PM) on May 23, 2026 • 6 adultsWe had an excellent experience with Over the Rails! Due to weather conditions, Justin actually recommended that we come early and head out on a different boat with a partner captain. He was very accommodating, helped us get the most out of the day before high winds and rain. The captain was very knowledgeable and put our entire party onto fish. Highly recommend, would definitely book again!
Loren Hersey5.0VerifiedAMAZING!!!
8 Hour Trip Salmon / Trout on May 23, 2026 • 4 adultsJustin made our trip the trip of a lifetime. Timely, organized, sociable, knowledgeable, honorable are just a few of the words to describe him. His fishing experience was incredible and his ability to explain what he’s doing to put our group on the fish. Amazing captain, fisherman, and gentleman. Our group is going to make this a yearly trip with Over The Rail charter. Thank you again sir.
Dan ToscanoRepeat angler4.7Verifiedyou have to do!
6 Hour Trip Salmon / Trout (PM) on July 24, 2026 • 3 adultsJustin and staff were unbelievable. Justin made it happen. Full boat of fish for two days straight. Very pleasurable including captain Mike. I am from south Forida and an advid fisherman for 50 plus years. The knowlege these two have for guiding was unsurpassable. Proven with 50 to 60 lbs of cleaned filets. Fantastic and highly recommend the both captians for beginners to experts. total 10 out of 10 score.
David DipaoloRepeat angler5.0Verifiedgreat trip
8 Hour Trip Salmon / Trout on August 20, 2026 • 4 adults • 2 childrengreat trip. caught kings, browns, and one atlantic salmon. cap justin is knowlegeable and hard working. trolling 8/9 lines at once without a mate is pretty impressive. our boat was limit out this time before noon. thanks
Doreen Bowles5.0VerifiedAwesome trip!
6 Hour Trip Salmon / Trout (AM) on July 11, 2026 • 4 adultsGreat day! We all caught fish. The captain was very knowledgeable. We had a great trip. We will definitely book again.
Dan ZugaleRepeat angler5.0VerifiedGreat time on the ice!
6 Hour Trip on February 17, 2026 • 2 adultsGreat day on Oneida with Justin! It was our first time ice fishing and we caught some beautiful walleye and perch. Justin was informative, patient, and made the whole experience fun. Would recommend!
Trevor HoltRepeat angler5.0VerifiedAugust fishing trip
8 Hour Trip Salmon / Trout on August 30, 2026 • 4 adultssmart guy well rounded!!
Donna Fuller5.0VerifiedFishing with Justin
6 Hour Trip Salmon / Trout (PM) on August 17, 2026 • 2 adults
Real catches shared by our community
Over The Rail SportfishingPulaski, NY
Over The Rail SportfishingPulaski, NY
Over The Rail SportfishingPulaski, NY
Over The Rail SportfishingPulaski, NY
Over The Rail SportfishingPulaski, NY
Over The Rail SportfishingPulaski, NY
Over The Rail SportfishingPulaski, NY
Over The Rail SportfishingPulaski, NY
Over The Rail SportfishingPulaski, NY
Over The Rail SportfishingPulaski, NY

















