Over The Rail Sportfishing – Ice Fishing
5.0/5 (10 reviews)
Bridge Street 112, Sylvan Beach, NY 13157, United States–
Over The Rail Sportfishing – Ice Fishing
5.0/5 (10 reviews)
Bridge Street 112
Sylvan Beach, NY, United States
OTR Sportfishing is located on Lake Ontario and offers to show you a memorable time in these waters. You'll have a great experience ice fishing on various bodies of water throughout New York State. Come enjoy a day in heated shanties while using various methods including tip-ups and jig lines to ice your limit of various species of fish!
Capt. Justin will do his best to make sure you have a fun day full of fishing. This involves 6 to 8-hour trips, mainly fishing for Perch, Lake Trout, Pike, Crappie, and Walleye, depending on the season and conditions on the day. On these trips, you can expect to use techniques such as light tackle, handline, ice fishing, and jigging. Up to 8 anglers can come on a trip. There will be a porta-potty toilet for you to use if needed. There will also be cooking equipment available upon request as well to provide a hot meal throughout the trip.
All tackle, equipment, gear, and bait are included in the trip, so you can focus on what really matters, fishing. Please make sure to buy a valid fishing license ahead of time. Also, contact the captain to determine what bodies of water are fishable due to varying ice conditions throughout the season.
OTR Sportfishing will fully customize its trips to suit you best, come try it out and ice your limit today!
Rating
5.0
10 reviews
5
10
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
0
5.0
Boat & equipment
5.0
Captain & crew
5.0
Fishing Experience
Anglers' gallery (17)
+11
All reviews (10)
Filter
Filter
Sort by: Featured
Featured
Showing 1 – 5 of 10 reviews
Dan Zugale
5.0
Verified
New
Great time on the ice!
6 Hour Trip on February 17, 2026 • 2 adults
Great day on Oneida with Justin! It was our first time ice fishing and we caught some beautiful walleye and perch. Justin was informative, patient, and made the whole experience fun. Would recommend!
Reported catch:
0
Marshall Zhang
5.0
Verified
Very Knowledgeable guide
6 Hour Trip on February 3, 2026 • 2 adults • 1 child
Will recommend Justin for your next trip guide, very hard working and knowledgeable guide in the area.
0
Jason Zhuang
5.0
Verified
Justin is a great guy
6 Hour Trip on January 17, 2026 • 4 adults
very diligent and friendly
Reported catch:
0
Robert Myrick
5.0
Verified
Excellent Trip & Excellent Guide
8 Hour Trip on January 27, 2024 • 2 adults
Our Ice Fishing Trip with Captain Justin was an excellent experience. It was our first time ice fishing and he took the time to explain each step of the process, make recommendations for gear and supplies, and explain every method of ice fishing. He provided many tips and tricks for tip up fishing, dead sticking, and jigging, including demonstrating how to jig with the help of a fish finder. He and the assistant guide set up many tip ups and checked them often to make sure they were still baited. When the fish stopped biting at our first location he offered to switch us to a new location where we caught over a dozen fish, which he filleted for us. Throughout the trip he checked in often to make sure we were comfortable and warm, and had a heated shanty set up for us to take breaks in. I strongly recommend booking a trip through Over the Rail Sportfishing.
Response from Captain
February 10, 2024
Thank you Robert, it was a pleasure fishing with you! Look forward to the next trip!
1
Rich Coulton
5.0
Verified
Perfect day of fishing
4 Hour Trip on February 8, 2025 • 2 adults
This was my second time ice fishing with Justin. Everything was ready to go when we arrived. He is extremely knowledgeable and ready to give you help or suggestions if you need it. We will be booking again.
0
Trip availability and prices
Trip Date:
Days:
Group Size:
Select date to see availability
March 2026
| Su | Mo | Tu | We | Th | Fr | Sa | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Loading...
Number of days
1
Almost there...
6 Hour Trip
FREE Cancellation 7 days notice
6 Hour Trip
starts at 6:00 AM
Seasonal trip
Dec 20 - Mar 15
US $300
Private tour: up to 3 people
US $300
Private tour: up to 3 people
8 Hour Trip
FREE Cancellation 7 days notice
8 Hour Trip
starts at 6:00 AM
Seasonal trip
Dec 20 - Mar 15
US $500
Private tour: up to 3 people
US $500
Private tour: up to 3 people
Rating
5.0
10 reviews
5
10
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
0
5.0
Boat & equipment
5.0
Captain & crew
5.0
Fishing Experience
Anglers' gallery (17)
+11
All reviews (10)
Filter
Filter
Sort by: Featured
Featured
Showing 1 – 5 of 10 reviews
Dan Zugale
5.0
Verified
New
Great time on the ice!
6 Hour Trip on February 17, 2026 • 2 adults
Great day on Oneida with Justin! It was our first time ice fishing and we caught some beautiful walleye and perch. Justin was informative, patient, and made the whole experience fun. Would recommend!
Reported catch:
0
Marshall Zhang
5.0
Verified
Very Knowledgeable guide
6 Hour Trip on February 3, 2026 • 2 adults • 1 child
Will recommend Justin for your next trip guide, very hard working and knowledgeable guide in the area.
0
Jason Zhuang
5.0
Verified
Justin is a great guy
6 Hour Trip on January 17, 2026 • 4 adults
very diligent and friendly
Reported catch:
0
Robert Myrick
5.0
Verified
Excellent Trip & Excellent Guide
8 Hour Trip on January 27, 2024 • 2 adults
Our Ice Fishing Trip with Captain Justin was an excellent experience. It was our first time ice fishing and he took the time to explain each step of the process, make recommendations for gear and supplies, and explain every method of ice fishing. He provided many tips and tricks for tip up fishing, dead sticking, and jigging, including demonstrating how to jig with the help of a fish finder. He and the assistant guide set up many tip ups and checked them often to make sure they were still baited. When the fish stopped biting at our first location he offered to switch us to a new location where we caught over a dozen fish, which he filleted for us. Throughout the trip he checked in often to make sure we were comfortable and warm, and had a heated shanty set up for us to take breaks in. I strongly recommend booking a trip through Over the Rail Sportfishing.
Response from Captain
February 10, 2024
Thank you Robert, it was a pleasure fishing with you! Look forward to the next trip!
1
Rich Coulton
5.0
Verified
Perfect day of fishing
4 Hour Trip on February 8, 2025 • 2 adults
This was my second time ice fishing with Justin. Everything was ready to go when we arrived. He is extremely knowledgeable and ready to give you help or suggestions if you need it. We will be booking again.
0