Larry Wren
Captain

Larry Wren

Islamorada, United States
50+ reviews
Federal waters
My name is Captain Larry Wren and I would like to invite you to fish on the First Choice! My philosophy is simple, to supply the best boat, tackle, and not to sweat the extra expenses in doing this (after all you are worth it!). As a young child I fished Islamorada with Captain Hugh Brown and I was hooked for life. In an eighth grade report I wrote of becoming a charter captain in Islamorada. I have fished the world extensively both fresh and saltwater and have to say the fly rod should get more usage

Charter

Rating

4.8
63 reviews
4.7
Boat & Equipment
5.0
Captain & Crew
5.0
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

100%
Good experience
95%
Friendly captain
98%
Recommend this charter
84%
Appropriate for children
100%
Satisfied with the boat
95%
Caught fish

Reviews (63)

  • Melanie Fey
    Melanie Fey
    us
    Kentucky, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Day on the Water

    3/4 Day Trip on August 4, 2026 • 5 adults

    Had a great day with Captain Larry and First Mate Alicia. Every fisherman knows you can have one of those days but the crew were not going to have us coming back in empty handed. They kept us out longer than paid to make sure of that. We fished the Islamorada hump and got to try an electric reel to bottom fish. Ended up catching mahi mahi and Almaco Jack. Great experience for our first time fishing in the Keys. I would charter with this crew again!

  • Kelly Mallinger
    Kelly Mallinger
    Repeat angler
    us
    Wisconsin, US
    Member since 2023
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    What a Dolphin Dance!!!

    3/4 Day Trip on July 30, 2026 • 4 adults

    Had a great time on the water today! Captain Larry put us in the middle of a Mahi school that was hitting like crazy! And then gave a great recommendation for a restaurant that would cook our catch for us. Such a cool experience for me and my boys. Thanks First Choice!!!

  • Dan Bonner
    Dan Bonner
    us
    New Jersey, US
    Member since 2026
    4.3
    Verified

    First Choice Charters with Capt. Larry

    Half Day Trip on February 26, 2026 • 6 adults

    We had an absolutely fantastic day out on the water, catching 4 Bonita and 10 boat limit) black fin tuna. Captain Larry knew exactly where to go to get the best results and the crewman, Tom, was beyond awesome. Overall, great, great trip! It was the kind of trip that seems to happen to other people and not to me. This time it was me so very thankful for the experience and thanks to First Choice!

  • Kelly Bisignano
    Kelly Bisignano
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    4.7
    Verified

    Great day on the water !!

    Half Day Trip on February 14, 2026 • 6 adults • 2 children

    We enjoyed our half day trip with Captain Larry and Tom! Tom helped us catch a big wahoo ! We would definitely recommend.

  • Bryan Aston
    Bryan Aston
    Repeat angler
    us
    Missouri, US
    Member since 2025
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    King!

    Half Day Trip on January 14, 2025 • 2 adults

    Great morning on the boat with Captain Larry and First Mate Frank. Both guys are very nice and know their fishing. I took the 4 hour offshore excursion and the time flew by. We caught some King Mackerel and a shark. I had a Wahoo on my line but it bit through the leader and got away. I would definitely use First Choice again. When it was over Captain Larry filleted my fish and I took it to Wahoos for lunch and they fried it up for my lunch! Delicious! Thanks guys.

  • Robert  Adair
    Robert Adair
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2026
    4.3
    Verified

    Fishing with Larry

    Full Day – Offshore Deep Droping! on May 11, 2026 • 2 adults
  • Kathy Barbour
    Kathy Barbour
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2023
    4.7
    Verified

    Mahi-arvelous!

    3/4 Day Trip on July 23, 2024 • 6 adults

    Chartered with Captain Larry for a 3/4 day fishing experience for our family and two friends while down in the Keys on vacation. With four teenage boys - our goal was to have a fun experience and catch mahi … and Captain Larry and his first mate made sure we did so! Two of the teens had never been deep sea fishing and happy to report all had fun and we brought home several mahi and even had fun reeling in a large barracuda. Captain Larry and his first mate were excellent on communication and helped us throughout the day. We had a great time - and had fresh mahi for dinner last night. Thank you.

  • R. Christopher Melley
    R. Christopher Melley
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2024
    5.0
    Verified

    Beautiful day on the water and a great crew!

    3/4 Day Trip on July 13, 2025 • 2 adults

    We picked a challenging day because the fish were feeding overnight from a full moon but Capt Larry knows how to find em and what to present for lunch! Calm seas and sunshine only made the trip more memorable but the coolest catch of the day was a message in the bottle sent out by some kids from Georgia.

  • Orlando Jones
    Orlando Jones
    us
    North Carolina, US
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Trip!!!

    3/4 Day Trip on September 5, 2025 • 2 adults

    Our trip was wonderful we had an awesome time. The Captain and his mate were great! His mate was extremely knowledgeable and helpful, the Captain was extremely knowledgeable also, definitely felt safe with this crew. And we caught a ton of fish! 5 stars for sure!!

  • Rob Dowd
    Rob Dowd
    Repeat angler
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2022
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Full day trip with Captain Larry

    Full Day Trip on August 12, 2022 • 4 adults

    Out the door by 630 for 7a departure on offshore fishing charter First Choice by Captain Larry out of Islamorada. On way out to deep sea 20-25 miles out we stopped near Alligator Reef so the first mate (Rick) could cast out for bait. We trolled on our way out to sea and caught a barracuda. Captain Larry spotted some birds congregating about 10 miles further and we found our first bit of Mahi Madness - our boat was hooking them as fast as we could put baited hooks in the water and also grabbed a few jacks and other smaller fish we threw back. Once it slowed down - Captain Larry found another hot spot near a floating plank he rightfully assumed meant bait fish and bigger fish were in the area. Another round of mahi madness ensued. First time my son and nephew got to try offshore fishing and they had a day they’ll never forget.

Real catches shared by our community

  • First Choice Charters
    First Choice ChartersIslamorada, FL
    A group of anglers proudly displaying their catch of Mahi Mahi at the dock after a successful fishing trip.
    Fish 1
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Melanie F.
    Melanie F.
    Had a great day with Captain Larry and First Mate Alicia. Every fisherman knows you can have one of those days but the crew were not going to have us coming back in empty handed. They kept us out longer than paid to make sure of that. We fished the Islamorada hump and got to try an electric reel to bottom fish. Ended up catching mahi mahi and Almaco Jack. Great experience for our first time fishing in the Keys. I would charter with this crew again!
  • First Choice Charters
    First Choice ChartersIslamorada, FL
    Young angler proudly holding a large Mahi Mahi while fishing offshore, showcasing a successful day on the water.
    Fish 1
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Kelly M.
    Kelly M.
    Had a great time on the water today! Captain Larry put us in the middle of a Mahi school that was hitting like crazy! And then gave a great recommendation for a restaurant that would cook our catch for us. Such a cool experience for me and my boys. Thanks First Choice!!!
  • First Choice Charters
    First Choice ChartersIslamorada, FL
    Two anglers proudly displaying their catch of Mahi Mahi and a Snapper in front of the First Choice charter boat at Whale Harbor, Islamorada.
    Fish 1
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Alex K.
    Alex K.
    captain Larry but us on the fish , and kept on all day . great trip
  • First Choice Charters
    First Choice ChartersIslamorada, FL
    A couple poses in front of a catch board displaying several Mahi Mahi at a marina in Islamorada, FL.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Kelly L.
    Kelly L.
  • First Choice Charters
    First Choice ChartersIslamorada, FL
    Angler proudly displaying a large grouper while fishing offshore, showcasing a beautiful day on the water.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +2
    Yellowedge Grouper
    Robert  .
    Robert .
  • First Choice Charters
    First Choice ChartersIslamorada, FL
    A display of freshly caught fish hanging on a board at Whale Harbor in Islamorada, FL, showcasing a successful fishing trip.
    Fish 1
    Little Tunny (False Albacore)
    Dan B.
    Dan B.
    We had an absolutely fantastic day out on the water, catching 4 Bonita and 10 boat limit) black fin tuna. Captain Larry knew exactly where to go to get the best results and the crewman, Tom, was beyond awesome. Overall, great, great trip! It was the kind of trip that seems to happen to other people and not to me. This time it was me so very thankful for the experience and thanks to First Choice!
  • First Choice Charters
    First Choice ChartersIslamorada, FL
    A young angler proudly holding a large Wahoo at the dock after a successful fishing trip.
    Kelly B.
    Kelly B.
    We enjoyed our half day trip with Captain Larry and Tom! Tom helped us catch a big wahoo ! We would definitely recommend.
  • First Choice Charters
    First Choice ChartersIslamorada, FL
    An angler proudly displaying a freshly caught fish while fishing offshore, showcasing a clear blue sky and ocean backdrop.
    Fish 1
    Great Barracuda
    Clark L.
    Clark L.
    Boat was old. Captain and mate became frustrated when no bait was caught for an hour and 15 mins. Only 1 bait fly pole rigged up. When the bait started to bite I suggested the mate rig up another so we could both try. He gave me the bait pole and started to rig another. I immediately caught our third bait but before the second pole was rigged the Captain decided we didn’t need bait and we left immediately. Every time a fish was hooked the mate was trying to adjust the drag while fighting the fish. This slowed the fight down allowing sharks to eat the five solid hook ups we had. Both the Captain and mate were great people, although a negative vibe was the most prevalent part of the trip.
  • First Choice Charters
    First Choice ChartersIslamorada, FL
    Two anglers enjoying a scenic boat ride, with one holding a cup and the other looking towards the shore, showcasing a relaxed fishing environment.
    Emil G.
    Emil G.
    Went to get a sword, had 10ft waves and 20knts of wind. but the captain and crew persisted and we tried the whole day.
  • First Choice Charters
    First Choice ChartersIslamorada, FL
    An angler proudly displaying a vibrant Mahi Mahi while aboard a fishing boat in open waters.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +2
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Orlando J.
    Orlando J.
    Our trip was wonderful we had an awesome time. The Captain and his mate were great! His mate was extremely knowledgeable and helpful, the Captain was extremely knowledgeable also, definitely felt safe with this crew. And we caught a ton of fish! 5 stars for sure!!

What's biting with First Choice Charters in Islamorada

Cobia start to appear, sometimes in big schools. The mullet migration brings Sailfish close to the shore, along with the last of the Blackfin Tuna. This is also a great time for Trout and Redfish in the shallows.

Top catches for November

Fishing reports

A group of anglers proudly posing in front of their catch of Mahi Mahi displayed on a board at Whale Harbor in Islamorada, FL.

Spring fishing 2025

Mar 12, 2025 • Islamorada
As the weathers starting to warm our water thr fishing bas begun to improve! The snapperscwill be gathering for ghe anial spawning ateas and a ravenious bite wil emsure when confitions permit. The sails will be in the arra as they migrate south. Thr mahi woll stary ti shoe up ik april and continue through out the summar months. May first is the opening dsy for groupers snd the derp wayer tile fish. Orobally onr of yhr best eating fish in the srea. Please let is dhoe you a day on hhecwater in islamorada
Show more
Billfish leaping from the open ocean during an offshore fishing trip.

Pre-Thankgiving weekend catchh!

Nov 23, 2024 • Islamorada
Really nice fishing in islamorada the weekend before Thanksgiving black grouper sale Fish some Bonitas mackerel definitely a great day
Show more
Adult angler and young fisherman proudly display a large sailfish aboard a boat offshore.

December fishing!

Dec 6, 2023 • Islamorada
As the water is cool, In The Keys, the winner of species arrive sailfish being the top trophy fish king, mackerel, wahoo, snappers, fishing is very good in the winter
Show more
Group of adult anglers posing on the bow of the First Choice sportfishing boat in Islamorada, Florida.

Tips to Pick a Charter Boat

Sep 9, 2022 • Islamorada
Great offshore charter boats, crewed by dedicated professionals who truly love to take people fishing, exist in just about every corner of the known fishing world. But sometimes signals get crossed, or expectations don’t quite match reality, and things just don’t come together the way they should to ensure that the charter customer has a good experience. 1. Fishing Offshore Half-Day Trips This is one of the biggest decision-making errors, and it happens all over the world: trying to fish a half day instead of a full day or multiple days. There are only a few places where you could even hope to see a billfish in a half day, and even in the hottest of hot spots, you’d have to be incredibly lucky to have any success in such a short amount of time. Take it with a big grain of salt when you hear someone say, “We caught two blues and were back in time for lunch.” Possible? Maybe. Likely? No. Here’s an example of it: The boats that fished a full day yesterday averaged 8 sailfish releases each, but you say, “Why spend all that money for a whole day when we could just go for a half day and catch 4?” It doesn’t work that way. First, those fish may be well out of range for a half-day charter. There may also have been an afternoon bite that takes place long after you’ve packed it in and headed for the dock. Save the half days for fishing inshore. 2. Picking the Cheapest Charter Boat Of course, we all want a good deal on everything we buy, but selecting a charter based solely on price is almost always a bad idea. A low price could mean several things: The boat’s much older or smaller than the others, which means you’ll be more uncomfortable in rough weather; the tackle isn’t properly maintained; the captain and crew are working for less money; or a host of other things, and few of them good. The cheapest price doesn’t always come with the best value. You may think you’ve gotten a great deal and then just end up going for an expensive, slow cruise, with the crew not making any real attempt to catch fish. In regards to the size of the boat’s cockpit or fish fighting area, not all boats are equal in this respect. You are chartering the boat for the day, so bedrooms mean nothing. Look at the boat and visualize your group and a mate in the cockpit area? The larger the boat doesn’t mean a larger cockpit area. 3. Setting Unrealistic Expectations Even in the best fishing holes, the numbers change dramatically from day to day. Even in places like Costa Rica, where the fishing is relatively consistent during the high season, the fleet runs into slow days. That’s why it’s important to set realistic expectations for yourself and your charter group. This is especially true when it comes to bill fishing. If there are four, five, or six people in your charter party, then the chances are good that not everyone will be able to catch a billfish. You should determine ahead of time whose turn it will be when a strike finally does occur so the opportunity’s not missed. Some choose to either rotate time in the chair or assign a rod rotation in order to make it fair for everyone. You may have your heart set on a marlin, but if the Mahi Mahi are chewing the props off the boats a few miles away, then it may be a better option than staring at pretty blue water for six hours waiting for a bite. Be realistic with yourself and your party ahead of time — and be open to suggestions from an experienced pro at the helm — and you can avoid a lot of disappointment at the end of the day. 4. Failing to Prepare for a Day Offshore This one can really kill a good day offshore. A perfect example is seasickness. You may be fishing with people who swear they’ve never been seasick a day in their lives, but then the seas kick up a little, and they’re losing breakfast (and part of last night’s dinner) over the side. It’s a miserable feeling, especially when faced with the prospect of several more long hours of discomfort and no refunds for heading in early. If there’s any doubt, always ask your charter companions to use a seasick-prevention medication at least an hour before getting on the boat in the morning. If all else fails, recommend that your friends have doughnuts or bananas for breakfast since they taste about the same coming back up as they did going down. That swanky air-conditioned cabin is the worst place to be on a boat, enclosed places lead to sea sickness. Stay in the open air and look to the horizon. Don’t forget things like a light jacket, foul-weather gear for rain or rough weather, a hat or visor, sunscreen, a digital camera, and a good pair of polarized sunglasses. Most charters don’t provide lunch, so be sure to pack your own, along with snacks and plenty of drinks, including bottled water. If you want to bring beer, remember that cans are preferred over glass bottles, which can shatter in a cooler, and that hard liquor is almost never welcome on board.
Show more
A majestic Marlin leaps out of the water, showcasing its agility during a thrilling fishing expedition.

Sailfish season!

Oct 16, 2018 • Islamorada
Sailfish are arriving! As summer weather cools down the sails arrive! Huge baitfish schools on the reef and the peligics follow. Larger black fin tunas along with king mackerals to bend the rod.
Show more
Angler actively fishing from a boat with a fish breaking the surface in open blue water.

Sail fish Season

Sep 20, 2018 • Islamorada
Sail fish season is on its way! Summers hot weather is beginning to cool off, the north winds will push the sail fish to our area! Catching a leaping tail walking sail Fish is an anglers dream! The abundance of bait fish in our area brings and holds the sail Fish in Islamorada. Live bait kite-fishing or slow trolling produce a great bite. As the not so cold fronts (70degrees at night on average) arrive the fish move to the areas much closer to land. The bait fish swarm the reef area the pelagic’s come from the deeper waters to feed on the abundant baitfish schools. Catching fresh live bait is a must on every trip! As winter waters can be choppy the Sport-fish boats excel in providing a dry stable platform to fish from. Kite fishing when conditions permit allows you to watch the fish bite. Nothing is more exciting than backing down on a sailfish! Another huge advantage is a tuna tower to sight fish for sail Fish. The sailfish will move into shallower waters feed on baitfish schools. Imagine casting a live bait to a sail Fish within 30 foot of the boat as the fish is chasing bait Fish. The captain riding in the tower spotting the sail and the mate and anglers casting live baits directly to the feeding sail Fish! The most exciting fishing there is! Thank You Very Much, Captain Larry Wren
Show more