First Choice Charters 

4.8
(63 reviews)
 
Federally permitted
 83413 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States–

First Choice Charters 

Islamorada, FL, United States
–
37 ft
6
4.8
(63 reviews)

Booked with us before? You may qualify for a Loyalty Discount. Sign in to check.

Islamorada has a fish with your name on it, so let First Choice Charters help you catch it! Having logged many hours on these tides, Captain Larry knows them forwards and back.

These waters are known for Great Barracuda, Amberjack, Cobia, Dolphin (Mahi Mahi), King Mackerel (Kingfish), Sailfish, Swordfish, Wahoo, and more – with any luck, it won't take long to hook into some.

Depending on the species you’re after, you may find yourself spinning, trolling, bottom fishing, or maybe something more specialized in this area. Capt. Larry can also show you kite fishing.

Any fish within the legal limit are yours to keep. Plus, you can have your catch cleaned. Talk about bang for your buck!

Families who love fishing together will be glad to know that kids are welcome aboard! If you don't have a child-sized life vest of your own, be sure to ask if there's one on board. Snacks are permitted onboard — bring your favorites to maintain your energy throughout the trip!

You'll step aboard a 37' Sportfishing with room for 6 passengers. It has outriggers, a fighting chair, everything you need for a productive day on the water. There's a toilet on board for your convenience.

You'll find rods, reels, and tackle waiting for you, along with lures. Live bait is on offer, but you should ask the captain whether you'll be catching it yourself.

You'll have the help of a First Mate to put you on fish. A 10–20% tip is customary to show your appreciation for their hard work.

Your fishing license for the day is covered by the charter boat, just show up ready for some fishing! Be mindful that some species may have special rules or limited seasons. Your captain will help you follow regulations while you fish.

Don't leave home without bottled water, sunscreen (non-spray), and sunglasses. If you'd like to bring other drinks, just ask. Alcohol is allowed in moderation, just be sure to avoid hard liquor as well as glass bottles.

If you have any questions about fishing with First Choice Charters, feel free to send Capt. Larry a message down below.

Islamorada has a fish with your name on it, so let First Choice Charters help you catch it! Having logged many hours on these tides, Captain Larry knows them forwards and back.

These waters are known for Great Barracuda, Amberjack, Cobia, Dolphin (Mahi Mahi), King Mackerel (Kingfish), Sailfish, Swordfish, Wahoo, and more – with any luck, it won't take long to hook into some.

Depending on the species you’re after, you may find yourself spinning, trolling, bottom fishing, or maybe something more specialized in this area. Capt. Larry can also show you kite fishing.

Any fish within the legal limit are yours to keep. Plus, you can have your catch cleaned. Talk about bang for your buck!

Families who love fishing together will be glad to know that kids are welcome aboard! If you don't have a child-sized life vest of your own, be sure to ask if there's one on board. Snacks are permitted onboard — bring your favorites to maintain your energy throughout the trip!

You'll step aboard a 37' Sportfishing with room for 6 passengers. It has outriggers, a fighting chair, everything you need for a productive day on the water. There's a toilet on board for your convenience.

You'll find rods, reels, and tackle waiting for you, along with lures. Live bait is on offer, but you should ask the captain whether you'll be catching it yourself.

You'll have the help of a First Mate to put you on fish. A 10–20% tip is customary to show your appreciation for their hard work.

Your fishing license for the day is covered by the charter boat, just show up ready for some fishing! Be mindful that some species may have special rules or limited seasons. Your captain will help you follow regulations while you fish.

Don't leave home without bottled water, sunscreen (non-spray), and sunglasses. If you'd like to bring other drinks, just ask. Alcohol is allowed in moderation, just be sure to avoid hard liquor as well as glass bottles.

If you have any questions about fishing with First Choice Charters, feel free to send Capt. Larry a message down below.

Larry Wren
Captain
Larry Wren
22 years of experience
ID & credentials verified
responds within an hour

Select date to see availability

Trip date:
Group Size:
November 2026
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
Group Size
2 adults • 0 children
Change
Half Day Trip
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
4 hour trip starts at 8:00 AM
Barracuda (Great)
Amberjack
Cobia
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
+2
US $1,130
Entire boat: up to 6 people
3/4 Day Trip
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
6 hour trip multiple starting times (7:00 AM, 8:00 AM)
Barracuda (Great)
Amberjack
Cobia
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
+3
US $1,480
Entire boat: up to 6 people
Full Day Trip
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
8 hour trip starts at 8:00 AM
Barracuda (Great)
Amberjack
Cobia
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
+4
US $1,680
Entire boat: up to 6 people
Full Day Fish – Kite Fishing
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
8 hour trip starts at 7:00 AM
Seasonal trip
Nov 1 - Apr 1
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
King Mackerel (Kingfish)
Sailfish
Wahoo
+3
US $1,995
Entire boat: up to 6 people
Full Day – Offshore Deep Droping!
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
8 hour trip starts at 8:00 AM
Seasonal trip
May 1 - Sep 1
Tilefish
Grouper (Scamp)
Grouper (Snowy)
US $1,995
Entire boat: up to 6 people
Extended Swordfishing Trip
FREE Cancellation 3 days notice
12 hour trip starts at 7:00 AM
Barracuda (Great)
Amberjack
Cobia
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
+4
US $2,500
Entire boat: up to 6 people

Customer reviews

4.8
63 reviews
4.7
Boat & equipment
5.0
Captain & crew
5.0
Fishing Experience

Anglers' gallery (110)

What anglers say

100%
Great experience
84%
Family friendly
95%
Friendly captain
100%
Good boat
98%
Recommended
95%
Caught fish

Reviews (63)

  • Melanie Fey
    Melanie Fey
    us
    Kentucky, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Day on the Water

    3/4 Day Trip on August 4, 2026 • 5 adults

    Had a great day with Captain Larry and First Mate Alicia. Every fisherman knows you can have one of those days but the crew were not going to have us coming back in empty handed. They kept us out longer than paid to make sure of that. We fished the Islamorada hump and got to try an electric reel to bottom fish. Ended up catching mahi mahi and Almaco Jack. Great experience for our first time fishing in the Keys. I would charter with this crew again!

  • Kelly Mallinger
    Kelly Mallinger
    Repeat angler
    us
    Wisconsin, US
    Member since 2023
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    What a Dolphin Dance!!!

    3/4 Day Trip on July 30, 2026 • 4 adults

    Had a great time on the water today! Captain Larry put us in the middle of a Mahi school that was hitting like crazy! And then gave a great recommendation for a restaurant that would cook our catch for us. Such a cool experience for me and my boys. Thanks First Choice!!!

  • Dan Bonner
    Dan Bonner
    us
    New Jersey, US
    Member since 2026
    4.3
    Verified

    First Choice Charters with Capt. Larry

    Half Day Trip on February 26, 2026 • 6 adults

    We had an absolutely fantastic day out on the water, catching 4 Bonita and 10 boat limit) black fin tuna. Captain Larry knew exactly where to go to get the best results and the crewman, Tom, was beyond awesome. Overall, great, great trip! It was the kind of trip that seems to happen to other people and not to me. This time it was me so very thankful for the experience and thanks to First Choice!

  • Kelly Bisignano
    Kelly Bisignano
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    4.7
    Verified

    Great day on the water !!

    Half Day Trip on February 14, 2026 • 6 adults • 2 children

    We enjoyed our half day trip with Captain Larry and Tom! Tom helped us catch a big wahoo ! We would definitely recommend.

  • Bryan Aston
    Bryan Aston
    Repeat angler
    us
    Missouri, US
    Member since 2025
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    King!

    Half Day Trip on January 14, 2025 • 2 adults

    Great morning on the boat with Captain Larry and First Mate Frank. Both guys are very nice and know their fishing. I took the 4 hour offshore excursion and the time flew by. We caught some King Mackerel and a shark. I had a Wahoo on my line but it bit through the leader and got away. I would definitely use First Choice again. When it was over Captain Larry filleted my fish and I took it to Wahoos for lunch and they fried it up for my lunch! Delicious! Thanks guys.

  • Robert  Adair
    Robert Adair
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2026
    4.3
    Verified

    Fishing with Larry

    Full Day – Offshore Deep Droping! on May 11, 2026 • 2 adults
  • Kathy Barbour
    Kathy Barbour
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2023
    4.7
    Verified

    Mahi-arvelous!

    3/4 Day Trip on July 23, 2024 • 6 adults

    Chartered with Captain Larry for a 3/4 day fishing experience for our family and two friends while down in the Keys on vacation. With four teenage boys - our goal was to have a fun experience and catch mahi … and Captain Larry and his first mate made sure we did so! Two of the teens had never been deep sea fishing and happy to report all had fun and we brought home several mahi and even had fun reeling in a large barracuda. Captain Larry and his first mate were excellent on communication and helped us throughout the day. We had a great time - and had fresh mahi for dinner last night. Thank you.

  • R. Christopher Melley
    R. Christopher Melley
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2024
    5.0
    Verified

    Beautiful day on the water and a great crew!

    3/4 Day Trip on July 13, 2025 • 2 adults

    We picked a challenging day because the fish were feeding overnight from a full moon but Capt Larry knows how to find em and what to present for lunch! Calm seas and sunshine only made the trip more memorable but the coolest catch of the day was a message in the bottle sent out by some kids from Georgia.

  • Orlando Jones
    Orlando Jones
    us
    North Carolina, US
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Trip!!!

    3/4 Day Trip on September 5, 2025 • 2 adults

    Our trip was wonderful we had an awesome time. The Captain and his mate were great! His mate was extremely knowledgeable and helpful, the Captain was extremely knowledgeable also, definitely felt safe with this crew. And we caught a ton of fish! 5 stars for sure!!

  • Rob Dowd
    Rob Dowd
    Repeat angler
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2022
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Full day trip with Captain Larry

    Full Day Trip on August 12, 2022 • 4 adults

    Out the door by 630 for 7a departure on offshore fishing charter First Choice by Captain Larry out of Islamorada. On way out to deep sea 20-25 miles out we stopped near Alligator Reef so the first mate (Rick) could cast out for bait. We trolled on our way out to sea and caught a barracuda. Captain Larry spotted some birds congregating about 10 miles further and we found our first bit of Mahi Madness - our boat was hooking them as fast as we could put baited hooks in the water and also grabbed a few jacks and other smaller fish we threw back. Once it slowed down - Captain Larry found another hot spot near a floating plank he rightfully assumed meant bait fish and bigger fish were in the area. Another round of mahi madness ensued. First time my son and nephew got to try offshore fishing and they had a day they’ll never forget.

FAQs about First Choice Charters

First Choice Charters offers the following trips to customers:
  • US $1,130 per group - Half Day Trip (4 hours)
  • US $1,480 per group - 3/4 Day Trip (6 hours)
  • US $1,480 per group - 3/4 Day Trip - 8:00 AM (6 hours)
  • US $1,680 per group - Full Day Trip (8 hours)
  • US $1,995 per group - Full Day – Offshore Deep Droping! (8 hours)
  • US $1,995 per group - Full Day Fish – Kite Fishing (8 hours)
  • US $2,500 per group - Extended Swordfishing Trip (12 hours)
When you book a trip with First Choice Charters, you can expect the following amenities onboard:
  • Toilet Full-head and sink
  • Fighting chair
  • GPS
  • Fishfinder
  • Flybridge With tuna tower
  • Live bait well
  • Outriggers
  • Radio
  • Sonar
Trips booked with First Choice Charters include:
  • Rods, reels & tackle (Troolling, sprnnong, kites, electric deep drop)
  • Live bait (Prepared before except during winter – its caught)
  • Lures
  • Catch cleaning & filleting (We will fly in bag, all edible species for you that are within legal limits caught on the charter)
  • First mate (20%)
  • Fishing license (The boat carries a Florida fishing license for any passengers on board)
First Choice Charters offers the following types of fishing:
  • Nearshore fishing
  • Offshore fishing (e exclusively fish, the Florida Keys Atlantic offshore Waters anywhere from 3 to 30 miles offshore come fish with us and see why we are blue star rated Experience by the National Marine Sanctury Blue Starr)
  • Reef fishing
  • Wreck fishing
First Choice Charters offers the following fishing techniques:
  • Light tackle
  • Heavy tackle
  • Bottom fishing
  • Trolling
  • Spinning
  • Fly fishing
  • Kite fishing
  • Deep sea fishing
Top targeted fish species with First Choice Charters include:
  • Amberjack
  • Barracuda (Great)
  • Cobia
  • Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
  • King Mackerel (Kingfish)
  • Sailfish
  • Swordfish
  • Wahoo

Your captain

Larry Wren
Larry Wren
Islamorada, Florida, United States
11 Fishing Reports
ID & license verified
63 Customer reviews
Typical response within an hour
Member since October 2014
My name is Captain Larry Wren and I would like to invite you to fish on the First Choice! My philosophy is simple, to supply the best boat, tackle, and not to sweat the extra expenses in doing this (after all you are worth it!). As a young child I fished Islamorada with Captain Hugh Brown and I was hooked for life. In an eighth grade report I wrote of becoming a charter captain in Islamorada. I have fished the world extensively both fresh and saltwater and have to say the fly rod should get more usage
Larry Wren
Larry Wren
Fully verified
11
reports
63
reviews
2014
member since
~1h
response
My name is Captain Larry Wren and I would like to invite you to fish on the First Choice! My philosophy is simple, to supply the best boat, tackle, and not to sweat the extra expenses in doing this (after all you are worth it!). As a young child I fished Islamorada with Captain Hugh Brown and I was hooked for life. In an eighth grade report I wrote of becoming a charter captain in Islamorada. I have fished the world extensively both fresh and saltwater and have to say the fly rod should get more usage

The fish you can target

Amberjack
Amberjack
Great Barracuda
Great Barracuda
Cobia
Cobia
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
King Mackerel (Kingfish)
King Mackerel (Kingfish)
Sailfish
Sailfish
Swordfish
Swordfish
Wahoo
Wahoo
Amberjack
Amberjack
Great Barracuda
Great Barracuda
Cobia
Cobia
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
King Mackerel (Kingfish)
King Mackerel (Kingfish)

Real catches by this captain

  • A group of anglers proudly displaying their catch of Mahi Mahi at the dock after a successful fishing trip.
    Fish 1
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Melanie F.
    Melanie F.
    Had a great day with Captain Larry and First Mate Alicia. Every fisherman knows you can have one of those days but the crew were not going to have us coming back in empty handed. They kept us out longer than paid to make sure of that. We fished the Islamorada hump and got to try an electric reel to bottom fish. Ended up catching mahi mahi and Almaco Jack. Great experience for our first time fishing in the Keys. I would charter with this crew again!
  • Young angler proudly holding a large Mahi Mahi while fishing offshore, showcasing a successful day on the water.
    Fish 1
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Kelly M.
    Kelly M.
    Had a great time on the water today! Captain Larry put us in the middle of a Mahi school that was hitting like crazy! And then gave a great recommendation for a restaurant that would cook our catch for us. Such a cool experience for me and my boys. Thanks First Choice!!!
  • Two anglers proudly displaying their catch of Mahi Mahi and a Snapper in front of the First Choice charter boat at Whale Harbor, Islamorada.
    Fish 1
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Alex K.
    Alex K.
    captain Larry but us on the fish , and kept on all day . great trip
  • A couple poses in front of a catch board displaying several Mahi Mahi at a marina in Islamorada, FL.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Kelly L.
    Kelly L.
  • Angler proudly displaying a large grouper while fishing offshore, showcasing a beautiful day on the water.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +2
    Yellowedge Grouper
    Robert  .
    Robert .
  • A display of freshly caught fish hanging on a board at Whale Harbor in Islamorada, FL, showcasing a successful fishing trip.
    Fish 1
    Little Tunny (False Albacore)
    Dan B.
    Dan B.
    We had an absolutely fantastic day out on the water, catching 4 Bonita and 10 boat limit) black fin tuna. Captain Larry knew exactly where to go to get the best results and the crewman, Tom, was beyond awesome. Overall, great, great trip! It was the kind of trip that seems to happen to other people and not to me. This time it was me so very thankful for the experience and thanks to First Choice!
  • A young angler proudly holding a large Wahoo at the dock after a successful fishing trip.
    Kelly B.
    Kelly B.
    We enjoyed our half day trip with Captain Larry and Tom! Tom helped us catch a big wahoo ! We would definitely recommend.
  • An angler proudly displaying a freshly caught fish while fishing offshore, showcasing a clear blue sky and ocean backdrop.
    Fish 1
    Great Barracuda
    Clark L.
    Clark L.
    Boat was old. Captain and mate became frustrated when no bait was caught for an hour and 15 mins. Only 1 bait fly pole rigged up. When the bait started to bite I suggested the mate rig up another so we could both try. He gave me the bait pole and started to rig another. I immediately caught our third bait but before the second pole was rigged the Captain decided we didn’t need bait and we left immediately. Every time a fish was hooked the mate was trying to adjust the drag while fighting the fish. This slowed the fight down allowing sharks to eat the five solid hook ups we had. Both the Captain and mate were great people, although a negative vibe was the most prevalent part of the trip.
  • Two anglers enjoying a scenic boat ride, with one holding a cup and the other looking towards the shore, showcasing a relaxed fishing environment.
    Emil G.
    Emil G.
    Went to get a sword, had 10ft waves and 20knts of wind. but the captain and crew persisted and we tried the whole day.
  • An angler proudly displaying a vibrant Mahi Mahi while aboard a fishing boat in open waters.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +2
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Orlando J.
    Orlando J.
    Our trip was wonderful we had an awesome time. The Captain and his mate were great! His mate was extremely knowledgeable and helpful, the Captain was extremely knowledgeable also, definitely felt safe with this crew. And we caught a ton of fish! 5 stars for sure!!

What is the boat like?

Boat image
Boat category
Sportfishing boats
Capacity
6 persons
Boat length
37 ft
Year built
1958
Restored in
2011
Boat manufacturer
Merritt
Boat type
Sportfishing
Engine model
Cummins
Powered by
2 x 355HP
Max cruising speed
28 knots

What kind of fishing will you do?

Nearshore Fishing
Offshore Fishing
Reef Fishing
Wreck Fishing

Which fishing techniques you can try

Light Tackle
Heavy Tackle
Bottom Fishing
Trolling
Spinning
Fly Fishing
Kite Fishing
Deep Sea Fishing

Which amenities are available onboard

Toilet
Full-head and sink
Fighting chair
GPS
Fishfinder
Flybridge
With tuna tower
Live bait well
Outriggers
Radio
Sonar

What's included in the trip price

Rods, reels & tackle
Troolling, sprnnong, kites, electric deep drop
Live bait
Prepared before except during winter – its caught
Lures
Catch cleaning & filleting
We will fly in bag, all edible species for you that are within legal limits caught on the charter
First mate
20%
Fishing license
The boat carries a Florida fishing license for any passengers on board

How cancellations work

Free cancellation up to 3 days prior to trip
You can cancel or modify your booking up to 3 days before the trip date, free of charge. If you cancel or modify your booking later, or fail to show up, you'll forfeit 100% of what you've paid.
More details

What the listing policies are

Pickup not included
Transfer to/from departure site is not included in trip rates.
Child friendly
Min. age required 6+, vests available for 6+
You keep catch
Catch and release allowed

How you can pay

Pay online in full
Pay online in full through FishingBooker and save on credit card fees at the dock.
No additional fees.
Book with 20% deposit, pay rest to captain
When the captain confirms your trip, FishingBooker charges your credit card a 20% deposit to guarantee your reservation.
The remaining balance is to be paid directly to the charter operator on or prior to your trip date in one of the following payment methods:
 Cash
 Visa
 Mastercard
 American Express
When paying the remaining balance with a credit card, an additional 4% charge will apply.

What’s biting in Islamorada right now

AmberjackAmberjack
Barracuda (Great)Barracuda (Great)
CobiaCobia
Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
King Mackerel (Kingfish)King Mackerel (Kingfish)
SailfishSailfish
SwordfishSwordfish
WahooWahoo

Compare similar fishing charters

Current
First Choice Charters
First Choice Charters
Federally permitted
4.8
(63)
37 ft
Group size 1 - 6
1 - 6
Fish 1
Fish 2
+6
4 hour trip • 6 persons
US $1,130