Search
Karl McKenna
Captain

Karl McKenna

Highlands, United States
Federal waters
50+ reviews
Captain Karl McKenna has been fishing all over the Sandy Hook and the Raritan Bay area almost all of his life. He has over 4 decades of experience fishing and diving in the waters of New Jersey. A lifetime of fishing has taught him all the tricks necessary for catching the popular species that stalk these waters. He's also been diving in this area since 1974.
Karl M.
Karl M.
Captain

Charter

Rating

4.9
73 reviews
4.9
Boat & Equipment
5.0
Captain & Crew
5.0
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

96%
Good experience
100%
Friendly captain
100%
Recommend this charter
96%
Appropriate for children
98%
Satisfied with the boat
94%
Caught fish

All reviews (73)

Showing 1 – 5 of 73 reviews
  • Terrence Flint
    Terrence Flint
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Great trip!!!

    7 Hour Trip • 2 adults

    Captain McKenna is an awesome dude. Very knowledgeable, and as excited to see you catch fish as you will be to catch them. Put me and my son right on the fish in a few different spots. Was happy to answer any questions we had and went above and beyond to make sure my son had the best birthday. We will be back to fish with him.

    Response from Captain

    Terrence. thanks for the nice review. I enjoyed having you and the birthday boy on board. the competition was fierce and fun to watch. looking forward to seeing you for the spring Striper run in April.

  • Oleksandr Syroyid
    Oleksandr Syroyid
    Repeat angler
    us
    New York, US
    Member since 2024
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great time on the water.

    5 Hour Trip • 3 adults

    Captain Karl was fantastic! He was friendly, knowledgeable, and worked hard to make sure we had a great time on the water. The boat was clean, everything was well organized, and he knew exactly where to find the fish. Whether you’re a beginner or experienced, I highly recommend booking a trip with Captain Karl. We’ll definitely be back!

    Response from Captain

    thank you Alex for the nice review. I enjoyed having you guys on the boat and hope to see you in the spring for the spring Striper run.

  • Mark Penson
    Mark Penson
    Repeat angler
    us
    New Jersey, US
    Member since 2026
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    great time on choppy seas

    5 Hour Trip • 3 adults • 1 child

    Capt. Karl was cool and patient with children and novice anglers. He got us on fish and was a phenominal teacher showing us the ropes to snag our targeted fish. I’d recommend and I’m looking forward to doing another trip in the future. thanks Capt!

    Reported catch:
    Flounder
    Response from Captain

    Thank you Mark for the nice review I I enjoyed having you guys on the boat and look forward to your next trip.

  • Andy Sprague
    Andy Sprague
    us
    Pennsylvania, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    gteat trip

    7 Hour Trip • 3 adults

    Catain karl was very helpful in al aspects. help us get on board safely told and showed us howcto fisn for best catch. took us to several spots and caugt fish at all areas. 1st time salt water fishing he made it enjoyable.

    Response from Captain

    Andy thanks for the nice review. I enjoyed having you guys on the boat and am looking forward to your next trip. Capt Karl

  • Gregg Roder
    Gregg Roder
    Repeat angler
    us
    Connecticut, US
    Member since 2021
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    A fantastic trip!

    5 Hour Trip • 2 adults

    Karl knows the NJ waters exceptionally well, and we had such a great experience. Caught plenty of flukes, and a nice variety of other fish as well. Thank you!!

    Reported catch:
    Flounder
    Dogfish
    Response from Captain

    Greg. Thank you for the nice review. I enjoyed having you and Anne on the boat and hope to see you for the spring Striper run. Karl

Real catches shared by our community

What's biting with PrimeTime Fishing Charters in Highlands

You'll sense the season coming to an end in Highlands in November. Fewer charters make their way to sea, but there's still plenty of angling left. Go after monster Stripers and tasty Tautog and you won't be disappointed.

Top catches for November

Fishing reports

An angler proudly displaying two Black Sea Bass caught during a fishing trip, showcasing the excitement of a successful day on the water.

Hard-Fought Keepers Today

Oct 2, 2026 • Highlands
Worked hard for these keepers today.
Show more
An angler proudly displaying a caught shark while fishing on a boat, showcasing a successful day on the water.

Slow Day, 4.5 lb Keeper Caught

Sep 18, 2026 • Highlands
Slow day today but a nice 4.5 lbs keeper mafe up for it.
Show more
Angler proudly displaying a Black Sea Bass and a Flounder at the marina after a successful fishing trip.

Fluke and Sea Bass Bite Today

Sep 4, 2026 • Highlands
Fluke and seabass action today.
Show more
An angler proudly displaying a caught flounder while fishing from a boat, showcasing a calm water backdrop.

Plenty of Fluke Action and Keepers

Aug 31, 2026 • Highlands
Nice fluke action today. Lots of action and some nice keepers for dinner.
Show more
Angler reeling in a Bluefish while enjoying a day on the water, showcasing the excitement of fishing.

Tough Day — Kept Seabass Only

Aug 30, 2026 • Highlands
Tough conditions today. Only kept seabass.
Show more
An angler proudly displaying a large Flounder and a smaller fish at the dock, showcasing a successful fishing trip.

6.5 lb Fluke Tops the Catch

Aug 26, 2026 • Highlands
6.5 lbs Fluke was the top catch today.
Show more