What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Belmar, New Jersey for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Belmar

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
1 - 11 of 11 answers
customer-avatar
Sasha Ibanez
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Cal 2–Open Boat 7:30am-3:00 on April 20, 2024
Make sure to get a patch or something if you’re not sure you get seasick, bring water the crew told us it helped with it. And just come in and have a great time they told us to “make ourselves at home” don’t be afraid of asking questions they’ll help you out

customer-avatar
Morris Malka
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Chasing Tails Charters LLC on August 17, 2025
The inland waters in these parts hold a lot fluke and it never gets rough so if you want a chill day but full of action then this is it with this captain it’s perfect for two people.

customer-avatar
Jared Hulse
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Celtic Stoirm Charters on August 7, 2025
Understand the open water can change in a moments notice and plans may need to be altered.

customer-avatar
George Hindman
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Ruthless C's Charters on July 8, 2025
Look for maybe early June. It was very hot, and with a young kid, it wore on them very fast.

customer-avatar
Cathy Czerwinski Butler
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Ocean Explorer Fishing on December 31, 2024
Bring snacks, maybe hand soap or sanitizer (man’s room had no soap). If cold and choppy I recommend boots or waders, but in warm or calm days they’re not needed.

customer-avatar
Tim Hewitt
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Canyon Eagle 1 Fishing Charters 42' on July 10, 2024
Great fishing spot just have to hit the waters at the perfect times of the year to get into the big stuff.

customer-avatar
Victor Ciesiun
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Cal 2–Open Boat 7:30am-3:00 on May 28, 2023
Clam or squid as bait on a hook that’s not too big but not to small with a 6 or more oz sinker at the bottom of your rig

customer-avatar
Daniel Young
UPR MARLBORO, MD
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with 30 Line Sportfishing on May 19, 2022
The capt has his spots where the fish are. I went the weather was rainy and cold. Sea was choppy. People in my group was sea sick. Can't really give a honest recommendation

customer-avatar
Aristide Carousso
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Ocean Explorer Fishing on November 9, 2024
Bring gloves, dressing warm, wearing boots , and Bring a Smile. Oh, ... slow lift to set. Lol.

customer-avatar
Jason Cosulich
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Canyon Eagle 1 Fishing Charters 42' on October 26, 2024
Check the timing of the migration which changes slightly year to year. Hope for good weather

customer-avatar
Peter Laskovski
Colonia, New Jersey
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Canyon Eagle 1 Fishing Charters 42' on April 8, 2023
Very nice place, my first time there and liked the setup. Lots of parking but get there early