Fishing with Randy

All reviews (170)

Showing 1 – 5 of 170 reviews

Walt Oldenburg
Repeat angler
New York, US
Member since 2025
3 trips
5.0
Verified
Landon our captain was terrific!
6 hour offshore on August 21, 2026 • 3 adults • 1 child
We set out on a beautiful August morning. Landon took us out to about 55 ft of water where we dropped down and caught four groupers a red snapper, some sea bass and a grunt. It was the wrong season to keep three of the groupers and red snapper. The wind started picking up making it difficult to stay on point so we made our way back into the harbor. There we trolled and caught a whole bunch of bunch of Spanish mackerel and a baby shark! What a great experience. My 12-year-old grandson will never forget it.
Reported Catch
Robert Stanger
Repeat angler
Ohio, US
Member since 2024
2 trips
5.0
Verified
NEW
I had a very good trip.
1/2 day on September 25, 2026 • 1 adult
the captian and mate were very helpful and patient with me. I was hoping to learn how to fish for flounder and they were great.
Michael Maliniak
Vermont, US
Member since 2026
4.3
Verified
Another great on the water
8 Hour Trip – Bottom Fishing on May 18, 2026 • 4 adults
The weather was perfect and so were the captain and crew. We were actually luck to have 2 captains work the boat, Lucas and Dalton. Both very experienced, informative, and a pleasure to fish with always right there when you needed them. We caught a good deal of fish on an 8 hour trip because every tip the bite stopped we were quickly off to a new spot. Highly recommend these captains
Response from Charter operator
May 24, 2026
We had a blast. Hope we can do it again.
Matt Ostwalt
Repeat angler
North Carolina, US
Member since 2025
2 trips
4.3
Verified
Inshore Half Day
6 hour offshore on July 25, 2026 • 5 adults • 1 child
Enjoyed a good inshore trip w/Capt. Landon. Unfortunately, the weather dictated more of our trip than we would have liked; but, Capt. Landon made the best of it for us and put us on the fish. Good conversation and high service kept us having fun the full time even when the lines weren’t tight. Highly recommend Careyon for a great experience on the water.
Reported Catch
Chang Yeh
Virginia, US
Member since 2026
4.7
Verified
Great time with Captain Tyler
1/2 day on July 29, 2026 • 4 adults
Captain Tyler was amazing and very knowledgeable about the waters and fish when we were out. He helped us with anything we needed help with and went above and beyond.