Hailey Singh-tuttle

Orlando, FL, US

•

Member since 2024

5.0

Verified

Pretty nice guy

Half Day Trip (AM) on March 18, 20252 adults

My husband and I booked a trip with Captain Jeff to go lobster diving and fishing. He was super knowledgeable and very accommodating. “Nice guy” charters is an appropriate name lol. We didn’t get any lobsters but we went home with some fish and great memories! When we visit The Keys again, we’ll definitely be reaching out.

Reported Catch

Response from Captain

March 21, 2025

Thanks Hailey. I'll be seeing you when it gets warmer!

Nice Guy Charters

Stock Island

Instant Confirmation

Free cancellation

Trips from

US $600

Compare similar fishing charters

Current

Nice Guy Charters

State licensed

4.8

(199)

24 ft

Group size 1 - 6

1 - 6

+10

4 hour trip • 5 persons

US $700

Reel Smoker
State licensed
4.9
(100)
26 ft
Group size 1 - 6
1 - 6
+9
4 hour trip • 4 persons
US $750
Salty Soul Charters
State licensed
4.9
(23)
21 ft
Group size 1 - 6
1 - 6
+6
4 hour trip • 6 persons
US $799
24/7 Sportfishing
State licensed
4.9
(142)
25 ft
Group size 1 - 5
1 - 5
+10
4 hour trip • 4 persons
US $800
II Easy Charters
State licensed
4.8
(13)
26 ft
Group size 1 - 4
1 - 4
+9
4 hour trip • 4 persons
US $750

Rating

4.8

199 reviews

4.7

Boat & Equipment

4.9

Captain & Crew

4.8

Fishing Experience

Anglers' gallery (180)

What anglers say

92%
Great experience
96%
Family friendly
98%
Friendly captain
96%
Good boat
95%
Recommended
91%
Caught fish

All reviews (199)

Showing 1 – 5 of 199 reviews

Caroline Craven
North Carolina, US
•
Member since 2026
5.0
Verified
Great Trip!!
Half Day Trip (AM) on July 19, 2026 • 6 adults • 3 children
We took our 9 year old twins out with Jeff and we told him we wanted to make sure the boys were reeling in a lot. He took us to the first spot and they were catching snapper and grunt with every cast. Then we moved out to deeper water and started catching grouper, yellowtail, parrot fish and even trigger fish! He was so kind and great with our boys. They have not stopped talking about our trip, we are so grateful!!
Response from Captain
August 3, 2026
I love it! That's awesome they had such a good time!
Brandon Harshman
Member since 2026
5.0
Fishing with Jeff
Half Day Trip (AM) on May 30, 2026
Jeff is an amazing fisherman, very knowledgeable, has a nice boat, and knows the best spots to fish. Treated my family with the upmost respect. We also caught this 50lb King fish which was crazy. I would highly recommend Nice Guy Charters. And Jeff is a ginger so that’s a bonus. Thanks Jeff
Reported Catch
Response from Captain
August 25, 2026
Thanks Brandon had fun with you guys. That was a nice king! -capt Red Beard
Greg Brown
Oklahoma, US
•
Member since 2026
5.0
Verified
The sharks were an awesome catch!!!
Half Day Trip (AM) on July 1, 2026 • 5 adults
We started out at the reefs fishing for mangrove snapper and yellowtail snapper. We caught a few but it was kinda slow. Capt. Jeff suggested we make a move and go target sharks. What an awesome experience. We caught several Lemon Sharks in the 4-7’ range. It was a blast!!!
Response from Captain
July 6, 2026
It was a blast!
Michael Minnig
Repeat angler
Pennsylvania, US
•
Member since 2026
•
2 trips
5.0
Verified
Jeff was Great!
Sunset 4-8 on July 15, 2026 • 2 adults
Jeff took us from catching bait fish to hooking three sharks! Excellent evening spent on the water and came back with great memories with my son. Would highly recommend.
Reported Catch
Response from Captain
July 22, 2026
That makes my day that you two will remember your time fishing together and I helped facilitate that!
Kim Hughes
Texas, US
•
Member since 2026
5.0
Verified
Great Fishing Trip
Half Day Trip (AM) on May 7, 2026 • 5 adults
Jeff was great, put us on fish with first stop. We fished several different ways and caught different species. It was a great day on the water. We definitely recommend Jeff!!
Reported Catch
Response from Captain
May 13, 2026
Thanks Kirk!