My 9 year old son and I did a 4 hr trip. The captain and crew member treated us great. They were quick to get 6 fishing poles in the water at different levels.  Top water trolling and 25 ft off the bottom.  They constantly changed colors of baits to see what they were going to bite at. After 2 hours of no bites we finally landed a 53lb Wahoo!! We had 2 other bites but lost them both. One bite was a Blue Marlin that jumped out of the water. Very cool experience for me and my son. The crew cleaned the fish at the dock and we had a couple lbs of fresh fish for dinner.  Definitely recommend this company for fishing!

Easy to find the dock and a short walk from the cruise terminal.  Great trip with really excellent crew.  We caught one tuna which was filleted and brought to the Mexican restaurant next to the dock.  Our days catch was turned into really good blackened fish tacos.  The restaurant did charge $15 per person (just FYI).
The boat felt safe, the crew knowledgeable/friendly and we would use them again in a heartbeat.
Some things to consider: There is a yeti cooler on board with soda and water, there is room to bring your own beer or beverages on board and put them in the cooler.
Bring your own snacks, no big deal but just a reminder on half day trips that’s on you. 
There is a lot of sun exposure during the trip unless you want to sit inside.  Sunscreen, hats and sun-shirts felt like must haves. Sitting inside is pretty warm, it’s a nice break from the sun but then you lose the breeze and like I said-pretty warm.
Bathroom was great. 
Absolutely zero complaints.

We had a great time bottom fishing with Captain Roberto and First Mate Jerry on the Dorothy. Caught some nice strawberry grouper, yellow tail, and grunt fish. Captain Roberto cleaned our catch which our resort grilled for a tasty dinner that evening. Thank you Captain Roberto and First Mate Jerry for making our fishing a fabulous experience! Safe sailing!

Fishing trip started exactly at 7:30 am. The guy got the reels ready and then it was a waiting game. The guy said he’s been doing it for about 30 years now. About an hour later we get our first action, I start reeling it in when another hooks. We get both our and one more hooks. Three Mahi Mahi in a row in a matter of seconds! A minute later my dad catches a Bonito. The cherry on top was catching a Wahoo on the way back. Memories made for life!

Great boat, fun crew, and a great Captain. 

There are many fishing charters you can go on, and I wager that a great many of them are just as great as the Dorothy.  So, I will break this down:
The Vessel: She’s very seaworthy, she’s an older boat, but a wonderfully comfortable ride.  We did hit some chop, so she was rocking and rolling.  but we were comfortable in the two fighting chairs that we used as seats and one sitting on the cooler.  The head was exceptionally clean and if you are going #1 (he he he) you’ll be just fine…I cannot speak on #two…i wouldn’t recommend it on any fishing vessel, but it’s there if you need it. The port side outrigger was unable to lower, but the deck hand was still able to rig the line to it for a proper fishing line spread. 
Gear: The rods and reels are old…but still in incredibly good condition.  They could upgrade their gear, but you know the old saying, “If it isn’t broken, why fix it?”  The Main Fighting Chair (I am adding this to the “Gear” section because it was part of the reeling in the fish part.  The Main Fighting Chair is comfortable and gives you great leverage when fighting that trophy Billfish. 
The Crew: The Captain and the deck hand were friendly, and knowledgeable.  Our bait was ready, on a leader so when you got that fish off the line, he was swapping out the old leader with a fresh one ready to get back in the water.  They would offer us water, soda, and local fishing knowledge so we knew what fish species were in these waters, as well as tips from fishing from the shore.
Our Experience: our trip was to start at 7:30, but we showed up early at 7:00 with our coffee and our sea legs.  They had the gear ready, and the bait rigged so we cast off all lines and were underway by 7:15, and our first fishing lines were in the water by 7:30.  The owner of the boat was there to see us off, (and to take the rest of our payment) Speaking of the residual payment, cash is ok, but they also accept credit cards. There was an issue with the card reader, so he just said, “Go fishing, and you can pay when you get back” No time wasted at all.  They really want us to have the best experience there is to be had. Once we were pier side again, he was there to accept our payment. We caught a total of three fish.  We were targeting Mahi-Mahi, Kingfish Mackerel, Wahoo, Barracuda, and whatever else would bite.  We caught two Kingfish and a Wahoo. 
On request, they took measurements and weighed the fish, gave plenty of time for personal photos, and then they got to work cleaning the fish.  A few times a day a representative from local restaurants swings by to collect the fish fillets and steaks so you can enjoy your catch prepared at a nice restaurant, we chose Driftwood. And the crew happily made all the reservations and accommodations for us to enjoy our meal.
It is proper to tip the Capt., and crew.  PLEASE REMEMBER, it is not their fault if you don’t catch any fish, giving the fact that they do their part in getting you to the spots, rigging the bait, and setting up the rods (which they will do professionally) but how was their customer service, friendliness, helpfulness, plus they clean the fish and got us on the water fast.  In our case, the total service was EXCEPTIONAL! 
Pro Tip: Bring your own Balashi beer.  They provide soft drinks and water, that’s all.
Sunscreen, you’re going to need it.
Bring Snacks if you want them on the boat.  But I recommend having some food in your belly before the ride to avoid any sea sickness issues.