Hero banner

Simpson Bay Fishing Charters

The best out of 7 charter fishing deals in Simpson Bay - enter dates to check availability

Simpson Bay Fishing Charters

Compare 7 captains, read reviews, and book in minutes

Trip date
banner
Loading...

Top Fishing Charters in Simpson Bay

Simpson Bay: 7 fishing charters available

Showing 1 - 10
 Show on map
Angler's Choice
Listing image
33 ft
Up to 6 people
Timeless Fishing Charters
4.9
/5
(21 reviews)
Cole Bay (33 min drive from Simpson Bay)
Come on down and join us for a fun-filled memorable fishing adventure on board a Boston Whaler 32 Outrage, which is not only an ultimate fishing machine, but also kid friendly, family oriented and guaranteed to keep you safe and secured, all while in the

"All our expectations were met.  We said we wanted to catch something we could cook that night, we said we wanted to have a variety of fishing experiences (trolling and bottom), and we said we would have a mix of experienced and first time anglers." —⁠ Natalie,
trips from
US $900
Angler's Choice
Listing image
28 ft
Up to 6 people
Papa Smurf Charters
4.8
/5
(171 reviews)
Simpson Bay
Fishing with Captain Anthony Wescot and First Mate Mike is never a dull moment! They make sure their clients are comfortable, happy, and, at the end of the day, satisfied with their catch! Depending on the season, you might hook into Grunt, Great Barracud

"This was a great trip of inshore fishing. We caught 8 different type of fish." —⁠ Anthony,
trips from
US $660
Listing image
33 ft
Up to 5 people
Offshore Boats Charter SXM
5.0
/5
(2 reviews)
Cole Bay (16 min drive from Simpson Bay)
Make unforgettable memories in St. Maarten and experience real offshore fishing with Offshore Boats Charter SXM.

"Tony has a beautiful fishing boat and is definitely knowledgeable on where the local sites are to try and catch fish." —⁠ Kathryn,
trips from
US $1,080
Listing image
35 ft
Up to 8 people
Cristal Fishing Charters
4.5
/5
(92 reviews)
Simpson Bay
Explore the crystal clear waters of Sint Maarten with Cristal Fishing Charters! Join Our Experienced Captain who's been fishing in the area most of he's life and knows every trick from the book.

"My two boys and I took a 4hr trip out of Simpson Bay with Daniel and Ashton." —⁠ Mike,
trips from
US $965
Listing image
34 ft
Up to 6 people
2 Brothers Fishing
4.5
/5
(41 reviews)
Philipsburg (26 min drive from Simpson Bay)
Based out of Philipsburg, 2 Brothers Fishing is your ticket to a memorable time on the water. Your Captain is here to get you on some fish, and to make sure you have fun doing it.

"My wife and i took the Two Brothers out for a fishing 🎣 trip." —⁠ Bob,
trips from
US $1,250
Listing image
38 ft
Up to 8 people
Coconut Reef Fishing St Maarten
4.7
/5
(103 reviews)
Cole Bay (14 min drive from Simpson Bay)
Join Coconut Reef Powerboat Tours and explore the beautiful blue Caribbean waters off the coast of Sint Maarten! The charter is operated by Captain Craig Nicholls.

"These guys did everything to take care of us, start to finish!" —⁠ Angie,
trips from
US $965
Listing image
31 ft
Up to 8 people
Reel Charters
3.8
/5
(4 reviews)
Philipsburg (5.0 miles from Simpson Bay)
Book your next trip with Reel Charters and find out what keeps anglers coming back to Philipsburg for more. With Captain Ronn at the helm, you'll have a knowledgeable and experienced guide.

"We had a great time fishing with Capt. Ronn, he was an excellent source of information and experience." —⁠ Jeromy,
trips from
US $1,200
View all fishing charters
See all 7 fishing charters in Simpson Bay

Real catches shared by our community in Simpson Bay

  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf ChartersSimpson Bay
    Absolutely incredible first deep-sea fishing experience with Papa Smurf Charters in Sint Maarten!
    Ty H.
    Ty H.
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf ChartersSimpson Bay
    Captain & Michael
    Anne P.
    Anne P.
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf ChartersSimpson Bay
    Great charter!
    Meredith D.
    Meredith D.
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf ChartersSimpson Bay
    Great Crew, Great Fishing, Great Day
    J S.
    J S.
  • Cristal Fishing Charters
    Cristal Fishing ChartersSimpson Bay
    Really excellent trip
    Don H.
    Don H.
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf ChartersSimpson Bay
    Memories made
    William D.
    William D.
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf ChartersSimpson Bay
    Best fishing day ever!
    Nahla K.
    Nahla K.
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf ChartersSimpson Bay
    Great day on the water!
    Tray S.
    Tray S.
  • Cristal Fishing Charters
    Cristal Fishing ChartersSimpson Bay
    Amazing Trip - Biggest Fish Ever
    Josh S.
    Josh S.
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf ChartersSimpson Bay
    Deep Sea Fishing Trip with Papa Smurf
    Frank C.
    Frank C.

Top Types of Fishing in Simpson Bay

Frequently Asked Questions about Fishing Charters in Simpson Bay

According to customer reviews, some of the most popular fishing charters in Simpson Bay are:
Full list of top fishing charters in Simpson Bay
According to customer reviews, some of the most popular fishing charters in Simpson Bay are:
Full list of top fishing charters in Simpson Bay
The average price for a private 4 hour Simpson Bay fishing trip is US $830, while an 8 hour private trip will cost you US $1,215 based on prices on FishingBooker.com.
The average price for a private 4 hour Simpson Bay fishing trip is US $830, while an 8 hour private trip will cost you US $1,215 based on prices on FishingBooker.com.
Fishing charters in Simpson Bay that received great reviews from families are:
Fishing charters in Simpson Bay that received great reviews from families are:
The top 3 fish species targeted on guided fishing trips in Simpson Bay are:
The top 3 fish species targeted on guided fishing trips in Simpson Bay are:
The top 3 fishing techniques in Simpson Bay are:
The top 3 fishing techniques in Simpson Bay are:
The top 3 types of fishing in Simpson Bay are:
The top 3 types of fishing in Simpson Bay are:
Many fishing charters in Simpson Bay provide rods, reels and tackle. Some of the top rated are:
Many fishing charters in Simpson Bay provide rods, reels and tackle. Some of the top rated are:
According to customer reviews on FishingBooker.com, some of the best rated charter captains in Simpson Bay are:
According to customer reviews on FishingBooker.com, some of the best rated charter captains in Simpson Bay are:
Who is the top awarded captain in Simpson Bay?
Who is the top awarded captain in Simpson Bay?
Some of the fishing trips offered by fishing charters in Simpson Bay are:
  • 4-hour fishing trips – US $802
  • 6-hour fishing trips – US $1,140
  • 8-hour fishing trips – US $1,200
Some of the fishing trips offered by fishing charters in Simpson Bay are:
  • 4-hour fishing trips – US $802
  • 6-hour fishing trips – US $1,140
  • 8-hour fishing trips – US $1,200
Powered by AI

Fishing in Simpson Bay

Simpson Bay in Sint Maarten stands as a premier Caribbean fishing destination, renowned for its abundant marine life and expert-led charters. The nutrient-rich waters attract game fish year-round, including Wahoo, Mahi Mahi, Sailfish, Yellowfin Tuna, and Barracuda. Anglers can experience diverse techniques like deep-sea trolling for pelagics or bottom fishing near reefs for Snapper and Grouper.

Local captains combine decades of expertise with intimate knowledge of prime fishing grounds, from coastal drop-offs to offshore currents. Charters offer tailored experiences, ranging from 3-hour express trips to full-day expeditions, using well-equipped boats with advanced gear. The backdrop of turquoise waters and Sint Maarten's coastline enhances every adventure, whether seeking trophy catches or family-friendly outings.

Simpson Bay fishing charters prioritize both excitement and sustainability, blending thrilling battles with respect for marine ecosystems. This destination delivers unforgettable moments, from battling acrobatic Sailfish to savoring the day's fresh catch—all set against the Caribbean's iconic vistas.

Simpson Bay

4.7
/5
Based on 31,687 reviews by FishingBooker anglers

What anglers said about fishing in Simpson Bay

  • 4.7
    /5
    (3/4 Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Wahoo!!!! Fish on!!!

    Bring long sleeve sun protection! The Caribbean sun can be tough on the water!
    Karen F.
    Karen F.
    Reviewed on March 27, 2026
  • 5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Excellent fishing trip!

    There is a big underwater ledge about a mile offshore that the boats troll along. Expect a little choppiness as you get out to the ledge .
    Samantha H.
    Samantha H.
    Reviewed on October 1, 2025
  • 5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip (AM))

    My 2 Grandsons caught a 3 foot Mahi Mahi

    Even though it's off fishing season, we hooked three nice fish and were able to land one.
    Greg O.
    Greg O.
    Reviewed on July 15, 2025
  • 5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip (AM))

    A great afternoon

    We don't catch much but that's fishing. You can't make the fish bite.
    Matt C.
    Matt C.
    Reviewed on March 11, 2025
  • 5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Great Choice

    Captain Anthony did a good job manueving around large swells and finally got us on fish.
    David R.
    David R.
    Reviewed on July 24, 2024
  • 5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Bottom Fishing)

    We caught a ton!!!!

    If you're looking to catch a bunch of species then this is the trip for you! We were only off about 2-3 miles from shore the entire time and fished between 70 and 110 feet deep. I wanted to make sure everyone caught something which is why we picked this trip and they put us all over tons of small fish. We even had a few get taken from us by larger fish. We had a chance at huge ones. Great experience
    Drew B.
    Drew B.
    Reviewed on July 10, 2024
  • 5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Great trip

    Its fishing, i hit it on a rough day on the water and we had some nasty rain that pushed the fish down but just last week they were hitting some 40-80lb wahoo and mahi, my trip was mostly barracuda and we threw them back since they are a risky meal.
    David K.
    David K.
    Reviewed on June 20, 2024
  • 4.7
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Bottom Fishing)

    Caught the mother lode!

    Bottom fishing for a guaranteed catch. This trip exceeded our expectations. Lots of fish... so fun. These guys are the best. Snacks, drinks were provided. Fishing was all within sight of the island. This is a "must do" from now on, every time we come to the island!
    Larry E.
    Larry E.
    Reviewed on February 1, 2024

How did anglers rate fishing charters in Simpson Bay?

  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Captain & Michael

    …were beyond gracious & adamant to find us fish! And, we did! Barracuda, tuna and a huge, slick wahoo that got away!
    Anne P.
    Anne P.
    Reviewed on Aug 26, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Bottom Fishing)

    Great charter!

    We caught mahi mahi, grouper, snapper and a couple doctor fish. My husband got to fight with a shark on the retrieve too. Super exciting! Friendly and knowledgeable crew. Thank you Anthony and Mike for a great trip!
    Meredith D.
    Meredith D.
    Reviewed on Aug 18, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Full Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Memories made

    Captain Anthony and Mike made this trip one we wont forget. They were great to interact with, and they went above and beyond for my nephew. Don't think twice if you are considering Papa Smurf charters. you wont rgret it. Thanks for fantastic trip andlasting memories. Bill
    William D.
    William D.
    Reviewed on Aug 6, 2026
  • Cristal Fishing Charters
    Cristal Fishing Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip (AM))

    Really excellent trip

    The Capt and crew were very knowledgeable & accommodating. Really went the extra mile to make our trip enjoyable.
    Don H.
    Don H.
    Reviewed on Aug 8, 2026
  • Cristal Fishing Charters
    Cristal Fishing Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip (AM))

    Great 1/2 day trip, exceded expectations!!!

    Great company to fish with! We fished half day and landed two Mahi. The crew put a lot of effort in to get us on fish. i would definitely fish with them again!!!
    Josh G.
    Josh G.
    Reviewed on Jul 31, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Not biting but we tried!

    Captian and Magic Mike were awesome and tried very hard to get them to bite, the fish just weren’t having it today! We got a keeper Mahi so our lunch and dinner was covered at least!
    Jeremy M.
    Jeremy M.
    Reviewed on Jul 27, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Full Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Perfect day on the water

    We had a very good day on the water. Everything what you need is on board. Captain and crewmember willing to do everything for a good catch. Good equipment and Knowledge. Catching Mahi Mahi, Tuna and Barracudas. Cleaning of the fish on the dock, perfect service.
    Chris R.
    Chris R.
    Reviewed on Jul 28, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Papa Smuf da BEST

    First fishing trip ever for myself and our boys. Rouhh seas and Papa even called ahead and wanted to see if we wanted to cancel because his morning trip cut their trip short becuase if the rockin and rolling. we went in our journey and sure enough landed 2 barracuda and a coiple other fish o. the line but dis nit make it on the boat, maybe next time!
    Derek W.
    Derek W.
    Reviewed on Jul 2, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Great day on the water!

    Anthony and Mike got us into some Baracuda and Mahi's. We took our Mahi's to Charlie's where they cooked them several different ways for us to sample. Will be back.
    Tray S.
    Tray S.
    Reviewed on Jun 30, 2026
  • Cristal Fishing Charters
    Cristal Fishing Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip (AM))

    Great Trip

    Everything was well organized. Caught 4 fish. Good fighters all. We will go again
    Paul M.
    Paul M.
    Reviewed on Jul 10, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Deep Sea Fishing Trip with Papa Smurf

    The captain Papa Smurf and first mate Mike were great. We caught 8 Mahi Mahi and ended up eating at Charlie's which was recommended by Papa Smurf. We invited them to join us to eat our fish and Papa Smurf and his nephew joined us. This is the most fun fishing trip I have had and totally because of Papa Smurf and Mike. If we visit St. Maarten again I will definitely go fishing with them. Very clean and well kept boat.
    Frank C.
    Frank C.
    Reviewed on Jun 21, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    sooo fun!

    we caught massive mahis and got them cooked fresh at a local spot recommended by the captain 10/10 would do this again
    Claudia A.
    Claudia A.
    Reviewed on Jun 12, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Bottom Fishing)

    June fishing trip

    We went bottom fishing we caught probably 5 different kinds of fish one was a beautiful queen trigger fish. They was great with my grand kids ages 7 and 8 we had a great time.
    Jed M.
    Jed M.
    Reviewed on Jun 20, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    Great trip with my Grandson

    We had a great time with the captain and crew and they worked hard to get us some fish. I would highly recommend Papa Smurfs
    Richard Q.
    Richard Q.
    Reviewed on Jun 8, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Bottom Fishing)

    Great times with Captain Andrew and Mike

    There's guys had good gear and were considerate with my family. We enjoyed out time together.
    Derek M.
    Derek M.
    Reviewed on May 28, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Bottom Fishing)

    Amazing Trip!

    The Papa Smurf crew is exceptionally knowledgable and sociable. As a crew of primarily novice anglers we managed to catch plenty of fish with their guidance. We had an amazing time!
    Krystian C.
    Krystian C.
    Reviewed on May 29, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Bottom Fishing)

    Great morning!

    Short visit for the weekend from Canada! Had a great time with Captain Anthony & Magic Mike, who did not give up until we caught ourselves some lunch and dinner. Highlight of our trip!
    Sarah R.
    Sarah R.
    Reviewed on May 10, 2026
  • Cristal Fishing Charters
    Cristal Fishing Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip (AM))

    Good time

    The captain and crew were very accommodating. The boat was impeccable. Snacks , beer and drinks were plentiful. We did not catch a lot but landed a nice Wahoo.
    Steven M.
    Steven M.
    Reviewed on May 1, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Full Day Trip – Deep Sea Fishing)

    A fun fishing experience

    Captain Anthony and "Magic" Mike were wonderful. The time flew by—it didn't feel like 8 hours at all. Mike was constantly working the reels and helping reel in the fish. You'll be very happy booking with Papa Smurf. Also, like the captain will tell you, don't bring bananas or eat them within 24 hours of the trip. 😄
    Jaison K.
    Jaison K.
    Reviewed on May 1, 2026
  • Papa Smurf Charters
    Papa Smurf Charters
    Fishing charter in Simpson Bay
    5.0
    /5
    (Half Day Trip – Bottom Fishing)

    Papa Smurf fishing was outstanding

    Anthony and mate were great. Put us on Fish even under not so good conditions would recommend anybody trying to have a good time fishing. Cheers thank you.
    Dan K.
    Dan K.
    Reviewed on Apr 18, 2026