Confusion Charters
Charter operator

Confusion Charters

Madeira Beach, United States
50+ reviews
Federal waters
"I have run charter boats on Lake Michigan and the Gulf of Mexico for over 40 years." Captain Bob Poteshman has also worked aboard other boats for even longer. His extensive knowledge of the water and the local area is impressive. One of his preferred fishing techniques is bottom fishing, both at anchor and while drifting. He operates a clean boat with a comfortable pilot house.

Charters

Rating

4.8
76 reviews
4.9
Boat & Equipment
4.8
Captain & Crew
4.8
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

91%
Good experience
91%
Friendly captain
94%
Recommend this charter
90%
Appropriate for children
100%
Satisfied with the boat
97%
Caught fish

Reviews (76)

  • John Moren
    John Moren
    Repeat angler
    us
    Oklahoma, US
    Member since 2025
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Great day today!

    10 Hour – Summer Offshore Mixed on July 2, 2026 • 6 adults

    Our group of 6 enjoyed Captain Bob and Deckhand Shane today! We booked a 12 hour trip and would book again. We talked about booking another trip while waiting for the restaurant to cook up our catch. Don’t hesitate and book one for yourself. We packed water and shouldn’t have. Captain Bob had that covered…. Recommend food and sunscreen. Everything else was covered.

  • Miles Manthey
    Miles Manthey
    us
    Illinois, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Great Time Fishing

    5 Hour – Summer Fishing Trip on July 7, 2026 • 3 adults

    Took my two teenage sons our with Captain Bob and Shane and had a great time. The crew was great, boat was very spacious and nice, and equipment was great. We caught fish and had a blast. Thanks Captain Bob and Shane for a great time. Will definitely be making charters with them a part of our annual trips to Treasure Island!

  • Sandra Bothia
    Sandra Bothia
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Nice experience in Madeira!

    5 Hour – Summer Fishing Trip on June 29, 2026 • 2 adults

    First time deep-sea fishing and we had an amazing time! I was worried about getting seasick, but the boat was so comfortable that I felt great the whole trip. We celebrated my husband's birthday, saw dolphins, caught a baby shark and a couple of red groupers (all released). Great experience and great crew. We'd definitely do it again!

  • Robert Tuszynski
    Robert Tuszynski
    us
    Illinois, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Amazing charter experience!

    6 1/2 Hour Trip DELUXE (AM) on August 21, 2026 • 7 adults

    Captain Bob and Kyle run a great tight ship, easily coordinating 9 of us on the charter. And WOW did they ever put us on fish, not just in numbers but in size with several huge lake trout and some nice salmon and steelhead to boot! Highly recommend Massive Confusion for your charter!

  • Josephine Sandoval
    Josephine Sandoval
    us
    Illinois, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Will remember this trip forever!

    4 1/2 Hour (PM) Shoreline Fishing on June 21, 2026 • 7 adults

    The captain & his crew man were so very patient with all 6 of us that caught fish. Only one of us have experienced this type of fishing before but all of us felt confident with this crew on board. This will be a memorable experience forever. Side note: do not take bananas or sunflower seeds 😄

  • Cindy Biggs
    Cindy Biggs
    us
    Florida, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    June fishing trip

    5 Hour – Summer Fishing Trip on June 26, 2026 • 6 adults

    I took my grand kids out on a 6 hour trip… Capt’n Bob was flying solo and didn’t miss a beat! we caugth a Hogfish and several Grunt. W also caught a baby grouper and a toadfish! we had a blast! Highly recommend !!

  • Brandon Smith
    Brandon Smith
    us
    Utah, US
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Superb fishing trip

    5 Hour – Fishing Trip on April 5, 2026 • 3 adults

    we scheduled a last minute morning fishing trip with Capt Bob and his first mate Shane. we easily scored over 60 fish off 4 different reefs. then we took our fresh catch to a local recommended place to cook it up fir lunch. whst an amazing experience. would book this crew again amd highky recommend tjem for yiur trip too. Thank you for and amazing easter experience.

  • Shawn Dunbar
    Shawn Dunbar
    Repeat angler
    us
    Illinois, US
    Member since 2026
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    100% Awesomeness

    6 1/2 Hour Trip DELUXE (PM) on September 25, 2026 • 14 adults

    Capt. Bob and Kyle were absolutely great to fish with. They were very professional and we caught a bucket load of fish. Highly recommended them will be going out with them in the future.

  • Diana Hicks
    Diana Hicks
    Repeat angler
    us
    Virginia, US
    Member since 2017
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Fantastic day of fishing!

    5 Hour – Fishing Trip on March 1, 2026 • 5 adults

    Captain Bob did an excellent job, putting us on the fish in a number of locations. First mate Shane was knowledgeable, courteous and helpful. Together, they were motivated and kept 5 anglers busy all day!

  • Marcus Henthorn
    Marcus Henthorn
    Repeat angler
    us
    Iowa, US
    Member since 2025
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Perfect day

    6 1/2 Hour Trip DELUXE (PM) on August 27, 2026 • 8 adults

    Best captain in chicago!

Real catches shared by our community

  • Four anglers proudly displaying their catch of Lake Trout on the deck of a fishing boat.
    Fish 1
    Lake Trout
    Shawn D.
    Shawn D.
    Capt. Bob and Kyle were absolutely great to fish with. They were very professional and we caught a bucket load of fish. Highly recommended them will be going out with them in the future.
  • A collection of freshly caught Lake Trout stored in a cooler, showcasing the successful fishing trip.
    Fish 1
    Lake Trout
    Marcus H.
    Marcus H.
    Best captain in chicago!
  • A group of anglers proudly displaying their catch of multiple fish, including large groupers, on the deck of a sportfishing boat.
    Robert T.
    Robert T.
    Captain Bob and Kyle run a great tight ship, easily coordinating 9 of us on the charter. And WOW did they ever put us on fish, not just in numbers but in size with several huge lake trout and some nice salmon and steelhead to boot! Highly recommend Massive Confusion for your charter!
  • Salty Confusion Charters
    Salty Confusion ChartersMadeira Beach, FL
    A family poses proudly beside a catch of multiple fish on a boat after a successful fishing trip.
    Fish 1
    Mutton Snapper
    Miles M.
    Miles M.
    Took my two teenage sons our with Captain Bob and Shane and had a great time. The crew was great, boat was very spacious and nice, and equipment was great. We caught fish and had a blast. Thanks Captain Bob and Shane for a great time. Will definitely be making charters with them a part of our annual trips to Treasure Island!
  • Salty Confusion Charters
    Salty Confusion ChartersMadeira Beach, FL
    A group of three anglers proudly posing with a large catch of various fish displayed on a board aboard a fishing charter.
    Fish 1
    Lane Snapper
    Alex N.
    Alex N.
  • Salty Confusion Charters
    Salty Confusion ChartersMadeira Beach, FL
    A family group proudly displaying their catch of Red Snapper aboard the Salty Confusion II after a successful fishing trip in Madeira Beach, FL.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    Red Snapper
    John M.
    John M.
    Our group of 6 enjoyed Captain Bob and Deckhand Shane today! We booked a 12 hour trip and would book again. We talked about booking another trip while waiting for the restaurant to cook up our catch. Don’t hesitate and book one for yourself. We packed water and shouldn’t have. Captain Bob had that covered…. Recommend food and sunscreen. Everything else was covered.
  • Salty Confusion Charters
    Salty Confusion ChartersMadeira Beach, FL
    A variety of colorful fish, including Snapper and Grunt, neatly arranged on a cleaning table at the dock after a successful fishing trip.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +2
    Lane Snapper
    Sandra B.
    Sandra B.
    First time deep-sea fishing and we had an amazing time! I was worried about getting seasick, but the boat was so comfortable that I felt great the whole trip. We celebrated my husband's birthday, saw dolphins, caught a baby shark and a couple of red groupers (all released). Great experience and great crew. We'd definitely do it again!
  • Salty Confusion Charters
    Salty Confusion ChartersMadeira Beach, FL
    Young angler proudly holding a colorful Grouper while fishing on a boat in open waters.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +2
    Red Grouper
    Cindy B.
    Cindy B.
    I took my grand kids out on a 6 hour trip… Capt’n Bob was flying solo and didn’t miss a beat! we caugth a Hogfish and several Grunt. W also caught a baby grouper and a toadfish! we had a blast! Highly recommend !!
  • A group of anglers proudly posing on the boat with a successful catch of multiple fish, showcasing their day on the water.
    Fish 1
    Spanish Mackerel
    Josephine S.
    Josephine S.
    The captain & his crew man were so very patient with all 6 of us that caught fish. Only one of us have experienced this type of fishing before but all of us felt confident with this crew on board. This will be a memorable experience forever. Side note: do not take bananas or sunflower seeds 😄
  • Salty Confusion Charters
    Salty Confusion ChartersMadeira Beach, FL
    A young angler proudly displaying a freshly caught Grouper while fishing on a boat in open waters.
    Fish 1
    Fish 2
    +3
    Red Grouper
    Brandon S.
    Brandon S.
    we scheduled a last minute morning fishing trip with Capt Bob and his first mate Shane. we easily scored over 60 fish off 4 different reefs. then we took our fresh catch to a local recommended place to cook it up fir lunch. whst an amazing experience. would book this crew again amd highky recommend tjem for yiur trip too. Thank you for and amazing easter experience.

Our Fishing Locations

What's biting with Salty Confusion Charters in Madeira Beach

Missed your chance to be the crowned King of the Beach in the spring? No worries! The tournament comes back in November, as do the huge King and Spanish Mackerel during their migration.

Top catches for November