Jonathan Loomis
Jonathan Loomis
us
Oregon, US
•
Member since 2019
1.3
Verified

Day trip with Captain John

Full Day Trip - Deep Dropping6 adults

What a terrible experience with Captain John. I’ve fished all over the world and have never experienced such a poorly run fishing guide. We paid top dollar for it too. First off, we were taken out in a non compliant boat which I learned after boating around for 45min trying to find extra oil to comply with state regulations, which we didn’t find. Couldn’t the boat have been prepared in advance? After trolling for hours and not catching anything, we had two line hang ups and was asked to real in one of them because they thought they had a fish on. We fished for hours with no action. Captain John said we would get live bait and try that method but he never did anything, no bait, no alternate fishing methods to get us into anything. He wasn’t prepared at all. He decided to pull the lines and take us spear fishing, I was excited to do it. We dropped anchor and jumped in near the coast, as he was handing me the spear he said that what we were doing was illegal so to not let any other boats see us. Are you kidding me? Next thing I noticed was that the snorkel mask and breathing tub had been completely drenched in gasoline. Yes, gasoline. Every mask had this issue, it was insane. We left the area and went to lunch on a small island, food was good and the locals were really nice. Captain John and his crew member said we would tour the castle and maybe fish off the shore of this area knowing we hadn’t caught anything yet, but they had no interest in taking us there. He instead boated us up to one of his personal properties to show us the progress he was making on his new restaurant. He was more interested in talking to his contractors than helping us catch anything. We waisted time there when we should have been fishing. All of this was on top of his racist jokes, yes, legitimate horrible racist jokes aimed at the people of Colombia. Do not give your money to this guy.

Response from Charter operator

Unfortunately the fishing conditions wernt in our favor and we opt to try something different for you guys seeing that one of the guys joing you didnt have much experience offshore. The diving masks were cleaned with rubbing alcohol after speaking to my mate duny they could have been cleaned out properly. Spearfishing close to shore is frowned upon by the locals not illegal. Knowing that we try to limit our spearfishing close to shore. When leaving the boat we offered to take you guys out on a clammer day on the house. We also paid for your guys lunch at the beach due to the poor fishing conditions. The beach message seemed to be the highlight for the day. Sorry to see your bad review and wish you could have spoke to me direct before hand. Everyone has different expectations. We run into different problems operationg in a third world country and its a bit different for some people. Our reputation is great and we want to keep it that way. Again sorry and message us direct to come to a agreement if you desire.

Cartagena Fishing
Cartagena de Indias
Instant Confirmation
Free cancellation
Trips from
US $635

Compare similar fishing charters

Current
Cartagena Fishing
4.1
(55)
38 ft
Group size 1 - 8
1 - 8
Fish 1
Fish 2
+8
4 hour trip • 8 persons
US $635

Rating

4.1
55 reviews
4.2
Boat & Equipment
4.1
Captain & Crew
4.0
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

  • 73%
    Great experience
  • 76%
    Family friendly
  • 87%
    Friendly captain
  • 89%
    Good boat
  • 73%
    Recommended
  • 72%
    Caught fish

All reviews (55)

Showing 1 – 5 of 55 reviews
  • Sandeep Upadhyay
    Sandeep Upadhyay
    Member since 2026
    5.0

    FULLDAY FUNFISHING EXPERIENCE

    Full Day Trip - Family Fun

    Outstanding Fishing Experience with a True Fishing Expert Captain’s Experience: The captain mike and edber bring years of hands-on fishing experience and knows these waters better than anyone. There ability to read tides, currents, and fish behavior makes a huge difference in the success of the trip. Fishing Skill: This is not just a boat ride — it’s real fishing. The captains consistently put us on fish by choosing the right locations, bait, and techniques for the conditions. Knowledge of the Area: deep knowledge of the local waters, reefs, channels, and fishing grounds ensures you’re always in the best spots. Understanding where fish move throughout the day and adjusts accordingly. The boat is best in class in Cartagena. Professionalism & Safety: Everything is run in a safe, organized, and professional way. The equipment is well maintained and the captain takes great care of everyone on board. Playlist of music was blasting all day. Great for Beginners & Experts: Whether it’s your first time fishing or you’re Memorable Experience: This trip isn’t just about catching fish — it’s about learning, enjoying the water, and having an unforgettable day with a true fishing professional. Highly recommended for anyone

    Reported Catch
    Cubera Snapper
  • Pankaj Kumar
    Pankaj Kumar
    Member since 2026
    5.0

    Well organized fishing charter.

    Full Day Trip - Deep Dropping

    We had an absolutely outstanding full-day fishing trip with this boat. From the moment we left the dock, the captain made our entire family feel safe, comfortable, and excited for the day ahead — especially our kids. We spent the day exploring beautiful islands, fishing in different spots, and learning about the area. The captain’s knowledge of the waters was incredible — he always knew exactly where to go, and it showed. Before we knew it, we had a cooler full of fish, which made the experience even more exciting for the kids. What really made this trip special was how patient and friendly the captain was. He took time to help the children with their rods, explain what was happening, and celebrate every catch. It wasn’t just a fishing trip — it was a real family adventure. This was hands-down one of the best experiences of our vacation in Cartagena. We left with amazing memories, great photos, and more fish than we could believe. We highly recommend this company to anyone looking for a fun, safe, and successful fishing trip for the whole family

    Reported Catch
    Cobia
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Blue Marlin
    Cubera Snapper
  • Manish Kumar
    Manish Kumar
    Member since 2026
    5.0

    Blue sky and smooth Sailing.

    Full Day Trip - Offshore Special

    Whether it’s your first time fishing or you’re an experienced angler, Capt mike is patient, helpful, and eager to share his expertise. IT SHOWS. Memorable Experience: This trip wasnt just about catching fish — it’s about learning, enjoying the water, and having an unforgettable day with a true fishing professional. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a top-tier fishing charter led by a captain who truly knows these waters. 🎣

    Reported Catch
    Cubera Snapper
    Gag Grouper
  • Derek Sanders
    Derek Sanders
    us
    California, US
    •
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Cartagena fishing

    Half Day Expedition • 2 adults

    Had a great experience with Celle and Mike. Had a great time fishing and caught a couple fish. Would love to go back out with them on my next trip to Cartagena

  • James Mcgrath
    James Mcgrath
    Repeat angler
    us
    California, US
    •
    Member since 2025
    •
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    My nephew caught 4 tuna one one line

    Special 4 hours trip for James Mcgrath • 4 adults

    Skipper got us to the fish pretty fast and we all caught at least one fish; assortment of yellow and blue tuna, mackerel and bonito!

    Reported Catch
    Bigeye Tuna
    Blackfin Tuna