What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Cape May, New Jersey for the first time?
Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Cape May
Showing:
1 - 20 of 20 answers
1 - 20 of 20 answers

Jenna Perry
Nesquehoning, PA
It’s an awesome time to go in July with the exception if there is any type of turbulence in the atmosphere such as what was encountered by us, some Highwinds thunder and lightning I would recommend exactly what our captain recommended. Wait an extra day if need be, and I have an amazing day the next, when things are calm, it’s the best experience ever hands-down.

Kym Richert
If you might get sea sick take some Dramamime about an hour before you go. Make sure to wear sun screen and bring water to drink and some hand wash or wipes if you like to hold your own fish for pictures. ;o)

Dana Smith
Use squid and once you feel a pattern change on the rod firmly set the hook and reel in a firm cycle

Brandon Courtney
Manage your expectations. If you are going out for a 4 hour trip don’t expect to be pulling in a marlin. However Captain Mac got on fish immediately and we were catching fish the whole time.

Cathy Castillo
This experience was perfect for first timers and novelists. They took great care of everyone and helped out everyone.

Christine Wiedemer
State College, PA
Bring a cooler and ice to bring your fish home! Cash or credit card only. Checks not really accepted.

Damon Carpitella
Chadds Ford, PA
Inshore fishing expect: flounder, sea bass, blue fish, croaker, Mahi Mahi, and ocean trigger fish.
Offshore fishing expect: yellowfin tuna, big eye tuna, blue and white marlin, Mahi Mahi, and shark

Stephen Wagner
Mont Clare, PA
Take motion sickness medicine ahead of time. Wear sneakers and sunscreen. Bring a sweatshirt and towel incase you get wet. Bring a cooler to take home the fish !

John Chagares
Malvern, PA
Be open minded to the fish you catch but with a great caption, you will have a great time and get lots of action!

Jason Clark
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
They do provide bait and buckets. They can fillet and ice fish. Bring a cooler, snacks and drinks with you.

Alexander Sokolof
Katonah, NY
Go far offshore if you can. May be spotty close to the reef at this time of year. Better to spend 2x and go big than 1x and go home unsatisfied.

Tish Carpinelli
Cape May Court House, NJ
If the west wind is blowing, make sure you bring fly spray, or clothing to cover your legs. They find you, even miles offshore!

George Lysenko
Summers can be tough for fishing, we opted to try for sharks and had a blast. What a workout !

Jackson Pulliam
Great captain. Very patient with my son and very knowledgeable on all matters that involve fishing.

David Ciaglia
Rockaway, NJ
Know before you go. Research your charter and have an idea what you want out of the trip.

Paul Schultz
Lysander, NY
Ask to see what is in season and target that. Work the location in with the targeted fish as well.

Linda Danner
Sewell, NJ
Captain Mac was a good boating experience, we did catch fish, but I was hoping for flounder.

G Mark Blaschak
Cape May, New Jersey
Captain was great put us on the fish catching amber jack, blues and one nice king mackerel.