Search
David Mulhollen
David Mulhollen
us
Georgia, US
•
Member since 2024
5.0
Verified

Good experience 3/4 day offshore

3/4 day2 adults

A friend and I went fishing from Herradura with Capt Randy and David. Although the fish were not biting much, they did their best to chase the tuna reports and try to get us on some fish. We saw thousands of tuna in the schools jumping and feeding but they would not hit our live bait or artificial bait. They worked super hard and even extended our time to get us on the fish. We did catch a sailfish and some rainbow runners (which were the best fish I have ever eaten surprisingly). We also hooked a blue marlin which spit the hook early in the fight. Both Randy and David were great guys and I recommend going out with them 100%. We will definitely return next year!

Fishing Herradura

Fishing Herradura

Playa Herradura
Instant Confirmation
Free cancellation
Trips from
US $800

Compare similar fishing charters

Current
Fishing Herradura
Fishing Herradura
4.8
(299)
32 ft
Group size 1 - 5
1 - 5
Fish 1
Fish 2
+10
5 hour trip • 5 persons
US $800

Rating

4.8
299 reviews
4.8
Boat & Equipment
4.9
Captain & Crew
4.8
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

  • 93%
    Great experience
  • 94%
    Family friendly
  • 99%
    Friendly captain
  • 98%
    Good boat
  • 95%
    Recommended
  • 91%
    Caught fish

All reviews (299)

Showing 1 – 5 of 299 reviews
  • Jim Renaldo
    Jim Renaldo
    us
    Ohio, US
    •
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Slow Fishing But Great Captain and Crew

    Full Day Trip - Offshore • 4 adults

    Not many boats out today. We fished offshore all day with little success trolling for the big fish we were hoping for.we caught 4 black tuna. One was bog and the rest were pretty small Beautiful weather. Boat was immaculate and David was very friendly and always busy. Captain Randy asked if we minded bottom fishing for a while so we could catch some fish. We pulled a 20+ pound yellow tail tuna, 2 nice grouper and 2 tile fish. Since we now had plenty of meat, we decided to try for some game fish. David cut up a delicious plate of fresh caught tuna. We didn’t have any more luck so headed in. Awesome day. Awesome of Randy to at least put some fish in the boat. Great crew to enjoy a day on the water with.

    Reported Catch
    Yellowfin Tuna
    Cubera Snapper
  • Melissa Gery
    Melissa Gery
    us
    Virginia, US
    •
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    Wonderful day fishing

    Full Day Trip - Offshore • 4 adults

    We booked an all day trip with Captain Randy and 1st mate David. They were fabulous! Captain Randy was very interactive with us as most captains that we’ve gone out with before on different trips rarely even spoke to us! Their friendliness, knowledge, and work effort gave us a great trip. We caught 6 yelllow fin tuna in the morning, and in the afternoon, very briefly hooked a sailfish but it got away quickly, and we almost had a mahi mahi in the boat but at the last second it spit the hook out. Randy had a great musical playlist which was wonderful to listen to. I was confused about the meeting area but just go to Playa Herradura and you’ll see the huge sign for water taxi. At the shoreline tell the water taxis you’re fishing with Randy or Los Cielos and they’ll take you right out to his boat. 1st mate David made fresh ceviche for us, plenty of cold water, sodas, and beer (if you like), great pineapple snack and sandwiches for lunch. There was a sun shade on the boat along with a toilet. 1st mate David filleted our catch and bagged it up for us. We got off the boat and took it to Coco’s restaurant right in the beach and they cooked it up for us! Delicious! We will definately book with Captain Randy again!

    Reported Catch
    Yellowfin Tuna
  • Freddy Morales
    Freddy Morales
    Repeat angler
    es
    Spain
    •
    Member since 2020
    •
    2 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Fish on indeed

    Full Day Trip - Offshore • 4 adults

    I’ve been fishing several times but never had this much success (and fun!) catching fish. Once we got out to depth, we were consistently on fish, sometimes with two reels at the same time. In the end, We caught several mahi mahi, yellowfin tuna, and a couple of trophy sized snappers. One was about 40 lbs and the other was 25 or so. We even hooked a shark that was at least 100 lbs and fought with it for 45 minutes be fore it broke the reel just as we got it right up along side the boat. The captain that day (no Randy) and First mate David worked their tails off and were really cool to talk to. I appreciate them making this our best fishing experience

    Reported Catch
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Red Snapper
    Yellowfin Tuna
  • Stephanie Jordan
    Stephanie Jordan
    Repeat angler
    us
    Colorado, US
    •
    Member since 2025
    •
    4 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Memorable and Productive Day on the Water

    Half Day Trip (AM) • 3 adults

    Captain Randy and his crew were friendly, professional and the best at what they do! We had a great time on their clean and comfortable boat! They were determined to make our entire trip successful and fun and they achieved that and then some! They took the utmost care in catching and cleaning the fish and were cautious when releasing the ones we couldn't keep. Lunch was simple and delicious, too! Some of the fish we caught on our 5 hour trip were Mahi Mahi (various sizes), Spanish Mackerel, Sailfish, Black Tuna.

    Reported Catch
    Spanish Mackerel
  • John Thompson
    John Thompson
    us
    Florida, US
    •
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    ROOOSTER FISH BABY !

    Half Day Trip (AM) • 1 adult

    I was super impressed by the Captain. We had an incredible day. I hired at the night before and explained to him. I wanted to catch some rooster fish. When we got on board, he explained to me what we were going to do and that was our target and we ended up packing our car. It was an incredible time super knowledgeable. I would recommend to anyone they fit me give me beers, water and sandwich sandwiches. It was just a great overall experience. I will definitely be back Captain Randy and his mate.

    Reported Catch
    Roosterfish