Fishing with Cole

Anglers' gallery (55)

What anglers say

• 

  Mark Mueller

  

  Ohio, US

  •

  Member since 2026

  0

  5.0

  Verified

  excellent trip

  6 Hour Trip (AM) on May 22, 2026 • 2 adults

  captain cole and crew jess are the perfect crew, explain everything thats happening and why, and the enthusiasm they have makes everything better. it also doesn’t hurt that captain Cole sees and knows everyrhing!!! We were treated very well before, during and after the trip, cannot recommend them enough. Absolutely incredible experience with Renegade Fishing Charters out of Islamorada! Captain Cole and the crew were professional, knowledgeable, and worked nonstop to put us on fish all day. The boat was clean, comfortable, and fully equipped, and the crew made us feel welcome from the moment we stepped aboard. We caught some amazing fish, had a blast the entire trip, and learned a ton along the way. You can tell these guys truly love what they do and care about making sure everyone has a great time. Whether you’re an experienced angler or going offshore for the first time, I highly recommend booking with Renegade.

  Reported Catch

  

  

  

  

  Response from Captain

  May 27, 2026

  Mark we really appreciate this review and we absolutely loved your guys company for the day! We are happy you enjoyed your time!! Thank you again and we cant wait to see you again!!

• 

  Gadiel Alvarado

  Repeat angler

  

  Florida, US

  •

  Member since 2020

  •

  5 trips

  0

  5.0

  Verified

  “Best charter on the water — Captain Cole & Terry are the real dea

  3 Hour Trip – Shark/Tarpon on May 28, 2026 • 2 adults

  Cannot recommend Captain Cole and first mate Terry highly enough! From start to finish, they were professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about what they do. We landed a tarpon — an absolute thrill — and my 14-year-old son had the time of his life. You can tell these guys take real pride in their work and customer service. If you’re looking for a top-notch fishing charter, look no further. We’ll definitely be back!

  • 

  Reported Catch

  
• 

  Michael Lindahl

  

  Minnesota, US

  •

  Member since 2026

  0

  5.0

  Verified

  Great Day Out!

  6 Hour Trip (AM) on March 23, 2026 • 3 adults

  The most important part for us was that Captain Colt actually included us in the decision making process. He asked what we wanted out of our trip and acted on it. He also didn’t hesitate to move after a spot wasn’t providing results. Once we got enough for a few dinners, he asked whether we wanted to stay or go after trophy fish. We went after the trophy fish. Didn’t end up catching any, but it wasn’t from lack of effort. We watched several big ones chase our baitfish, just couldn’t force them to bite. Also, First Mate Jessica was not only really helpful with getting us set up all day, but my daughter, wife, and I all agreed that she was just super cool to learn from and talk to. Not sure when we’ll be back to Islamorada, but we will definitely look this boat up again when we do!

  • 

  

  Response from Captain

  March 25, 2026

  thank you michael! you guys were a pleasure to have aboard! thank you for a great review and a great day on the water! we hope to see you guys again!

• 

  Joseph Johnson

  Repeat angler

  

  Florida, US

  •

  Member since 2022

  •

  2 trips

  1

  5.0

  Verified

  BEST CHARTER EVER!

  4 Hour Trip (AM) on January 10, 2026 • 4 adults

  Captain Cole and Jessica...the absolute best. My family has been on several fishing charters in this area over the past year. The Renegade crew by far, provided the best charter my family has gone on. Captain Cole and Jessica were incredible at finding the "it" location to catch, catch, and catch some more. They taught us how to reel and catch the fish correctly without injury to the fish and to be able to ensure the fish got into the boat. If you are looking for a charter were you catch a lot of fish with an outstanding crew....Captain Cole and Jessica on The Renegade is the charter for you!!!!!

  • 
  • 
  • 

  Reported Catch

  

  

  

  Response from Captain

  January 13, 2026

  you guys are awesome! thank you very much! cant wait to see you guys again!!

• 

  Paul Marsh

  Repeat angler

  

  San Antonio, TX, US

  •

  Member since 2019

  •

  15 trips

  1

  5.0

  Verified

  Made my dreams come true

  8 Hour Trip on November 11, 2025 • 1 adult

  I told the charter I wanted to go specifically for sailfish and I couldn’t have chosen a better day despite the wind and temp fighting against me hahaha . Bite was slow in the beginning but Jessica the mate is a machine constantly back and forth making sure all the lines were good to go . Captain was also a hero on this trip cuz it was windy and cold and he didn’t have any protection against wind or splashing water but he kept his eyes on the water looking for signs of sailfish . Ended up catching not one but 2 sailfish , 1 tuna , 1 cobia , and a needlefish. These guys are awesome , knowledgeable, and professional and made me feel like family . Definitely recommend

  • 
  • 
  • 
  • 
  • 
  • 

  Reported Catch