Tonya, we appreciate you coming out with us and we’re glad you found the captain and crew helpful.

That said, what you described is exactly the trip we advertise. We operate a party boat, which means fishing alongside other guests, not a private charter with unlimited space. It’s designed to be accessible, affordable, and enjoyable for a wide range of people, including beginners and families.

We’re also very upfront that this is fishing, not catching, and that depth and conditions vary depending on where the bite is that day. Our trips target reef species in the depths you mentioned, which is standard for this style of fishing in Key West.

For guests looking for more space, deeper water, or a more specialized experience, a private charter is typically the better fit.

We understand it wasn’t what you were expecting, but we do make every effort to clearly set those expectations ahead of time.

Tonya, we appreciate you coming out with us and we’re glad you found the captain and crew helpful. That said, what you described is exactly the trip we advertise. We operate a party boat, which means fishing alongside other guests, not a private charter with unlimited space. It’s designed to be accessible, affordable, and enjoyable for a wide range of people, including beginners and families. We’re also very upfront that this is fishing, not catching, and that depth and conditions... More