What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Treasure Island, Florida for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Treasure Island

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
1 - 22 of 22 answers
customer-avatar
Michael Szczepanek
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with La Costa Charters on June 22, 2026
Trust the reviews. The good reviews show a captain that has put the work in and knows how to get you on fish and the best bait and fishing techniques. Remember though, he can get you there but it is up to the fish to bite the hook!!!

customer-avatar
Walker McMullin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sea Dawgs Fishing Charters - John's Pass on June 12, 2026
I absolutely recommend this trip to first-timers to Treasure Island! If you focus on quantity over monster sizes like we did, you’re gonna be hauling things up left and right! If you want to know about monster size, too bad, I was too busy catching every fish out of the ocean to care!

customer-avatar
Kim Buszek
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sea Dawgs Fishing Charters - John's Pass on May 5, 2026
Captain Joey and especially his First Mate Linda were phenomenal woth my family. i had 2 teenage boys. we fish in the north often but wanted a unique experience. we definitely got that. they took us all over snd catered the adventure to us ans what we were looking for. Tremendous and highly recommend!!

customer-avatar
Courtney Agness
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sea Dawgs Fishing Charters - John's Pass on August 4, 2025
Night shark fishing not for “children” if they’re trying to reel in something. Teens are great but even that can be challenging for the amateur fisher because you have no idea what is coming on the line.

customer-avatar
Christopher Engleman
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sea Dawgs Fishing Charters - John's Pass on May 23, 2025
For first timers, lots of sun protection. Maybe YouTube how to use open face reel, set the hook, and keep line tension so you not using your charter to learn the basics as a couple in our group needed to. It’s not difficult, but it is a little different than the freshwater fish like bass we were used to.

customer-avatar
Ray Abruzzi
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with La Costa Charters on April 24, 2024
Check what kind of fishing you’ll be doing (trolling, spinning, bottom fishing) with the captain. A lot of boats list all fishing techniques like my charter did, but all we did was trolling even though we asked to change it up. Conditions, time of year etc I know are all factors in what’s working so good to check!

customer-avatar
Michael Hardy
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jake Nickol's Fishing Charters on June 2, 2026
I absolutely recommend Captain Jake. Hes an amazing professional who knows how an where to harvest fish.

customer-avatar
Mark Rundle
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Skirtchaser Charters – 36’ Yellowfin on April 24, 2026
Do a full do so you can go a little further out. we did the 4 hour trip and it was fun but would have rather had more time fishing.

customer-avatar
Curtis Freeberg
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jake Nickol's Fishing Charters on February 9, 2026
The water temperature was on the cooler side. Fish activity was slow warmer. Water temperatures would have been better.

customer-avatar
Russell Rogers
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jake Nickol's Fishing Charters on September 14, 2025
Hire Capt Jake. He knows the area and can put you on fish faster than you can figure it out on your own.

customer-avatar
Chris Zaremba
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with La Costa Charters on May 23, 2025
Bring lots of water and lotion sunscreen. Not the spray sunscreen. Pack a lunch. Plan on a long boat ride out to sea for an all day trip.

customer-avatar
Michelle Pitcher
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sea Dawgs Fishing Charters - John's Pass on May 3, 2025
Bring your sunscreen and a cooler because the sun is blazing and the Captain will definitely put you on the fish you want to catch! It’s great fun

customer-avatar
Jade Sherwin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jake Nickol's Fishing Charters on April 15, 2025
Remember, it’s called fishing, not catching. You won’t always reel in a trophy fish, but don’t let that dampen your spirits. Just enjoy the time you spend on the water!

customer-avatar
Jay Wollschlager
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with La Costa Charters on February 7, 2024
No heavy drinking the night before. We did the half day which would be fine for kids, probably not a full day trip. We are novice fisherman and had a great time.

customer-avatar
Larry Denney
Tampa, FL
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with La Costa Charters on May 30, 2019
Reminder that red snapper season opens in June so all red snapper you catch will be released. Still May is great month for fishing here.

customer-avatar
Dan Gage
Tampa, Florida
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with La Costa Charters on February 16, 2019
If you pick one of the charters out of John's Pass, you can spend some time on the boardwalk before or after your trip. Highly recommend La Costa Charters and Capt Patrick.

customer-avatar
Matthew Walsh
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with La Costa Charters on April 6, 2026
Be open for all types of off-shore fishing: trolling, bottom fishing, cast and reel.

customer-avatar
John Penberthy
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sea Dawgs Fishing Charters - John's Pass on July 24, 2025
Lots of places to fish, make sure you have good weather to avoid rough waters on a boat!

customer-avatar
Jerry Stucker
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sea Dawgs Fishing Charters - John's Pass on April 26, 2025
Go out with Joey and Linda very knowledgeable , don’t think just listen and you will catch fish

customer-avatar
Toby Chenoweth
Port Byron, IL
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with La Costa Charters on June 26, 2023
The heat is intense so dress appropriately and drink plenty of water. The fishing is excellent.

customer-avatar
Paula Atteberry
Springfield, IL
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with La Costa Charters on June 8, 2023
Fish with La Costa Charters and take plenty of water and sunscreen and have a great time.

customer-avatar
Holly Gamblin
Hyattsville, MD
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with La Costa Charters on April 23, 2019
book a full day; our half day experience was great but we all could have stayed out longer