What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Algoma, Wisconsin for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Algoma

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
1 - 15 of 15 answers
customer-avatar
John Fink
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Midnight Run Charters on August 9, 2024
Show up and have fun! August is a great time to head out, the big kings are moving in and make for a really fun outing. For us, 6 out of 20 were better than 20#, the rest were really nice too. We’ve got a full freezer!

customer-avatar
Ivan Yastrebov
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Kinn's Sport Fishing - Algoma 38' on July 28, 2024
Make sure you know where to find your boat - call your captain beforehand to figure this out. Be prepared to decent waves - take you dramina before you go - if you need it. Do not take doubting family members with you - they might not like it. Go for earlier trips - like 5am - the fishing is the best before sunrise. Make it clear to the crew if you don’t want you fish cleaned.

customer-avatar
Jim Brant
Hibbing, Minnesota
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Outcast Sport Fishing LLC on September 3, 2022
Make sure to dress and layers and have adequate clothing for the trip from rain gear to sunglasses. If you haven't spent time on big water or have issue with car sickness buy dramamine. Better to be groggy than get sea sick

customer-avatar
Cesar Munoz Jr
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Kinn's Sport Fishing - Algoma 38' on April 12, 2025
Have packed breakfast, or hit up a gas station. No dining options at 5:30am when you have to meet at the docks at 6am.

customer-avatar
Michaelyn Eckhardt
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Michigan Addiction Sport Fishing 38 on September 20, 2024
Take along something to drink as well as hand wipes if you don't like the smell of fish on your hands. Sunscreen might be a consideration as well as a jacket or sweatshirt for a extra covering.

customer-avatar
Jeff Mishler
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Midnight Run Charters on June 22, 2024
Get ready for sore forearms. Jeff will look and search to find fish for you. He works well with other charters to get the right baits and locations.

customer-avatar
Brian Haufe
Stevens Point, WI
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Kinn's Sport Fishing - Algoma 38' on July 28, 2023
fishing was real steady first hour and a half. then slowed down for 2 hours. then caught our 2 biggest kings at the end of our trip. it was what the captain said it would be . great exp

customer-avatar
Lesly Soto
Ashwaubenon, WI
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Kinn's Sport Fishing - Algoma 36' on July 16, 2023
Get more information, it’s not offered so you have to keep asking. Never go on the 10am trip, you would catch almost nothing.

customer-avatar
Gerry Steltenpohl
Stevens Point, WI
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Midnight Run Charters on June 23, 2023
If you dont have a boat and lack the experience, Charter a professional. We went out on Midnight Run Charters; it was excellent, affordable and we caught plenty of fish.

customer-avatar
Joseph Jaffe
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Kinn's Sport Fishing - Algoma 38' on June 9, 2023
I would recommend using this company and crew. They have everything you need laid out for you ready to go. If your looking for a positive fishing experience these are the guys.

customer-avatar
DIANE HARDEE
Lindstrom, MN
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Michigan Addiction Sport Fishing 38 on May 28, 2023
Come at a later date. Captain was not friendly or informative. First mate was nice. We didn't catch any fish

customer-avatar
Charles Howe
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Outcast Sport Fishing LLC on June 30, 2024
Bring a light jacket The lake is still very cold, slight breeze can be chilly...

customer-avatar
Greg Gill
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Michigan Addiction Sport Fishing 38 on May 19, 2024
Bring clothing to handle both warm and slightly colder weather. And bring a good attitude

customer-avatar
Charles Kostka
Rosholt, WI
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Midnight Run Charters on July 27, 2020
just enjoy the area and hope to catch some fish as we all know fishing is fishing