Nicholaus Moore
Nicholaus Moore
us
Illinois, US
•
Member since 2025
2.3
Verified

A huge disappointment of a fishing trip.

3 / 4 Day Fishing Inshore / Offshor5 adults3 children

This was the one excursion we were looking forward to during our cruise vacation and to say it was the worst excursion is an understatement. It felt like the captain and his other guy took us hostage for 5 hours while they tried to fish. They barely talked to us at all. I tried to get them to cut the trip short at 3 hours in when we hadn't caught any fish yet and they said they wanted to try a few more spots. 2 hours later and still not even a nibble on any of the lines. Not one of us in my family of 5 even touched a fishing pole. I began following Itzu Sport Fishing Charters on Facebook after booking and it seemed like they were posting multiple groups were cathing all sorts of fish leading up to our trip including Tuna, Rooster fish, Mahi, and even a huge Black Marlin. We did not experience any of that. Communication from Jordan prior to the trip and when I booked was very good but he was not even on the boat. His driver, Allen was right where we expected him to be and right on time. They had a cooler on the boat with ice and some water bottles. Overall, it was a pretty disappointing excursion for my family. My daughter actually started crying on the way back because we didn't catch anything and wasted our whole day on the boat sitting in the sun. I get that it's not guaranteed to catch fish but they didn't even let us try to catch a fish or even switch to bottom fishing. I would not recommend this fishing charter.

Response from Captain

Dear Nicholaus, Thank you very much for taking the time to share your experience with us. We are truly sorry to hear that your trip did not meet your expectations and that your family left disappointed. We understand how important it is to create lasting memories and regret that this was not the case for you. While fishing can never be fully guaranteed, our goal is always to provide our guests with the best possible opportunity to enjoy the day, On the day of your excursion, the water was durty due to the storm and that afect the fishing conditions. Because of this, our crew suggested trying to move to other areas in hopes of finding better conditions and giving your family a chance to catch a fish and experience reeling it in. We sincerely apologize if this did not feel clear or sufficient during your trip. Regarding my absence, I was unable to be present on the boat due to an emergency; however, I was personally coordinating everything online the entire time to make sure your service went smoothly. This included ensuring that our driver, Alan, was on time to meet you, and also with the rest of our crew members. We greatly appreciate your comments and will use them to keep improving our service. We truly hope you might consider giving us another opportunity in the future to provide you and your family with a much better experience on the water. Warm regards, Cap. Jordan Itzu Sport Fishing & Tours

Compare similar fishing charters

Current
Itzu Sport Fishing & Tours
4.7
(66)
30 ft
Group size 1 - 6
1 - 6
Fish 1
Fish 2
+10
4 hour trip • 6 persons
US $367

Rating

4.7
66 reviews
4.8
Boat & Equipment
4.7
Captain & Crew
4.6
Fishing Experience

What anglers say

  • 93%
    Great experience
  • 95%
    Family friendly
  • 98%
    Friendly captain
  • 100%
    Good boat
  • 89%
    Recommended
  • 91%
    Caught fish

All reviews (66)

Showing 1 – 5 of 66 reviews
  • Mitch Vanden Berge
    Mitch Vanden Berge
    us
    South Dakota, US
    •
    Member since 2026
    5.0
    Verified

    5 hour PV fishing.

    5 Hours Fishing Inshore/ Nearshore • 4 adults

    We did the 5 hour tour just hoping to catch whatever. The boat was easy to find and the captain wasn’t there but pointed us to his crew. Irvin and Chino were very good guys and tried extremely hard to get us on the fish. The bite was slow at first but they kept trying and we eventually caught some skipjack tunas late in the day. They cut up one and made some delicious ceviche on board which was great and we all enjoyed. They then were nice enough to drop us off at a marina closer to our hotel so we didn’t have to taxi as far back which was so nice of them and they didn’t have to do it! All in all would have loved to catch a few more desirable fish species but they definitely tried and they just weren’t biting. Glad to have at least caught something and the crew, boat, and day out of the water was great! Thank you!

    Reported Catch
    Skipjack Tuna
    Response from Captain

    Thank you so much for your detailed review, Mitch! We really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with us. We’re glad to hear that Irvin and Chino took great care of you and kept working hard to get you on the fish, even with a slow bite—that’s fishing sometimes, but we never stop trying! Awesome that you were able to land some skipjack tuna and enjoy fresh ceviche right on board, that’s always a highlight. We’re also happy you appreciated the extra effort to drop you off closer to your hotel—that’s the kind of service we always aim to provide. Next time, we’ll do our best to get you on some of those bigger, more desirable species! Thanks again for trusting us and we hope to have you back out on the water soon. Tight lines! 🎣

  • Tim Fafard
    Tim Fafard
    Repeat angler
    ca
    Alberta, Canada
    •
    Member since 2018
    •
    3 trips
    5.0
    Verified

    Yelapa beach and fishing!

    Yelapa Combo Tour Fishing, Snorkel. • 6 adults

    We had an excellent day with the crew of the Itzu today! We booked a combo 8hr fishing/Yelapa trip. We were 3 adults and our day consisted of fishing in the morning, going to Yelapa - waterfall hike (easy), drinks at the waterfall and then to the beach for lunch and relaxation. We choose not to snorkel and instead used that time to fish a little more in the a.m. Our Captain, Tuky and the first mate, Chuy were excellent hosts and guides. We managed to catch quite a few slip jacks and a Benito during our fishing portion ( we kept 2 that they filleted for us) and had an amazing whale watching experience that was incredible! The Itzu is very well equipped and in tip-top shape. Our visit to Yelapa was lots of fun and the meals we had at the beach restaurant were fantastic (one of our better meals in PV!) We would highly recommend this trip as it was laid back and well worth it!

    Response from Captain

    Hi Tim, Thank you so much for your amazing review! It truly means a lot to us that you trusted us with your day on the water 🙌 We’re very happy to hear you enjoyed the full experience — from the morning fishing to exploring beautiful Yelapa, the waterfall, beach time, and even the whale watching! That’s exactly the kind of relaxed but adventure-filled day we love creating for our guests here in Puerto Vallarta. I’ll make sure Tuky and Chuy see your kind words — they’ll be proud to know they helped make your trip special. It was a pleasure having you onboard Itzu, and we hope to fish with you again in the future! Tight lines 🎣 — Jordan & Team Itzu Sport Fishing and Tours

  • Matt Winger
    Matt Winger
    us
    Oregon, US
    •
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Epic Adventure

    5 Hours Fishing Inshore/ Nearshore • 4 adults • 1 child

    We are from salem Oregon and have never been to Mexico before. Jordan was an amazing and professional blessing! He took the best care of us in what could have been stressful and unknown. Alberto and Chino were the best people to be around and the 3 of us that went with them had the best time ever! the boat was amazing, the atmosphere was incredible and while the fishing was slow on our day, we still did much better than other boats. we did a 5 hour trip and still hooked 3 mahi mahi and lots of Bonita, I cannot wait to book my next trip! Thank you Itzu Fishing!

    Reported Catch
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Skipjack Tuna
    Response from Captain

    Thank you so much, Matt! It was truly a pleasure having you and your group on board. We’re so glad you enjoyed the experience and had a great time with Alberto and Chino. Catching those mahi mahi and bonita made it even better! We really appreciate your kind words and can’t wait to see you again for your next adventure in Puerto Vallarta. 🎣 – Jordan Amaral, Itzu Sport Fishing & Tours

  • Sherri Kruger
    Sherri Kruger
    ca
    Manitoba, Canada
    •
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Such a great trip!

    3 / 4 Day Fishing Inshore / Offshor • 4 adults

    Jordan’s nephews took us (a group of 4) out on a 6hr fishing trip in the bay. We left the marina at 7AM and fished the bay for 6 hours. We caught a small grouper, a small tuna and 5 mahi mahi!!! SO much fun to fight and reel in! The crew were obviously very experienced, knowledgable and fun. They filleted the mahi mahi for us and made ceviche on board - so fresh and delicious!! The boat was also immaculate! They even arranged for sea tutrles and whales to show up - a great touch ;) It really was a wonderful day, thank you all so much!

    Reported Catch
    Dolphin (Mahi Mahi)
    Skipjack Tuna
    Response from Captain

    Thank you so much, Sherri, for taking the time to share such a wonderful review! 🌊🎣 We’re truly happy to hear you had such a great day on the water with us. It means a lot to know you enjoyed the fishing, the crew, and the overall experience. Catching mahi mahi, tuna, and grouper in the bay makes for an unforgettable trip, and we’re glad the ceviche on board was a highlight as well! My nephews and the entire crew always do their best to provide a fun, safe, and memorable experience, so your kind words really motivate us. We’re also glad you got to enjoy seeing turtles and whales—those moments are always special. Thank you again for choosing Itzu Sport Fishing & Tours. We hope to welcome you back for another adventure in Puerto Vallarta very soon! Warm regards, Jordan Amaral Owner – Itzu Sport Fishing & Tours

  • Robert Poveromo
    Robert Poveromo
    us
    California, US
    •
    Member since 2022
    5.0
    Verified

    Bendo!

    Half Day Inshore/Nearshore Trip • 2 adults

    Communication was on point from the time of booking. Arrived at the Marina and the captain was there to greet us. Beautiful clean boat, plenty of room to relax and enjoy a beer. Crevalle Jack were on the chew! Hard hitting fish that will send your reel screaming!! There was a flurry of small bonito too,but the jacks won the day. Also enjoyed the company of a variety of sea birds, whales and and a ocean sea turtle. Great for a buddies trip or the whole family!!

    Response from Captain

    Thank you so much, Robert! 🙌🎣 We really appreciate you taking the time to leave such a detailed review. It was a pleasure having you with us, and we’re stoked to hear you enjoyed the communication, the boat, and the overall experience. Those crevalle jacks definitely know how to make a reel scream! 💪🐟 Seeing whales, sea birds, and even a sea turtle is always a bonus, and we’re glad it made your trip even more special. Thanks again for choosing Itzu Sport Fishing & Tours—we’d love to have you back anytime, whether it’s another buddies trip or a family adventure. Tight lines and cold beers! 🍻🌊 Captain Jordan Amaral Owner – Itzu Sport Fishing & Tours