Our trip was originally scheduled for Tuesday, but the weather had other plans—too rough to head out. The captain from Secret Cays Charter in Nassau, Bahamas recommended we try again Thursday, and that turned out to be the best decision we could’ve made.

My wife and I booked a private trip, and before we even left, he told us the bite had been extremely tough—several boats were out and only one fish had been caught all day.

But he didn’t just take us fishing—he went to work.

He put in the effort, kept us moving, and never gave up. And because of that, he got us on not one, but TWO incredible Mahi Mahi—a cow and a bull, both around 5 feet long. The cow came in at 40 lbs, and the bull was pushing 50 lbs.

In conditions where almost no one else was catching anything, he delivered an unforgettable experience.

If you’re booking a fishing trip in Nassau, Bahamas—Secret Cays Charter is hands down the one you want. Hardworking, determined, and knows how to get it done.

One word. Awesome! Great boat and crew and we had a splendid time. Pet pugs filliwed by snorkle followed by carching 2 barracuda and one tuna. definately going back with captain J!

Captain put us on an early winter Wahoo in Jan.  easy trolling and relaxed atmosphere.  checked all the boxes.  thanks!

great trip,great csptain well worth the morning

Captain and first mate tried very hard but we did not get a single bite.  It’s called fishing not catching for a reason.  It was super disappointing but ultimately if you can’t deal with that, you shouldn’t go fishing.  They tried switching up the approach a few different times to try to get us a bite.  I should also mention the water was pretty rough.  The crew was super friendly and we just had bad luck.