What would you recommend to anglers fishing in St. Thomas for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in St. Thomas

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
1 - 15 of 15 answers
customer-avatar
Mark Veilleux
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on October 27, 2024
Know what’s in season and understand that if you’re going for wahoo or mahi-mahi it’s a lot of trolling and time between bites. If you’re willing to target the species that are around in numbers (tuna, rainbow runners, jacks, etc) you can have non-stop action. Also bring sunscreen, you’ll need it.

customer-avatar
Joseph Loeffelmann
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on May 20, 2024
Go to Captain Eric Anaclerio, by far the best. There’s a reason he only has 5 star reviews. I thought it was odd but I totally understand now. Don’t regret it book him for your trip. Great with kids or just adults. The best!!!

customer-avatar
Marc Rortvedt
Lodi, WI
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Ocean Surfari Fishing Charters - St. Thomas on February 24, 2023
Explore, find the fish. It’s high risk high reward out here if you’re fishing from shore. One spot might be nothing but needlefish (hound fish) the other might have so many 25-40” tarpon you’re guaranteed to find a hungry one. 3 stars because access is tough and from shore the variety is pretty low.

customer-avatar
Keith Kulacz
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Good Times Charters on April 30, 2025
This is a local trip fishing wrecks and reefs.. Bryan is an excellent captain . The boat is just as described.

customer-avatar
Jason Stratta
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on April 2, 2025
So happy we booked with Captain Eric! We all caught fish (group of 6) and we all had a great time! Captain Eric is an experienced captain and angler, you won’t regret booking this trip!

customer-avatar
Gavin Claflin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Drift Charters Fishing - RIPTIDE on March 18, 2025
It’s better later in the season but it’s still a great time and will be catching fish no matter what

customer-avatar
Deanna Mehlhoff
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Drift Charters Fishing - RIPTIDE on April 7, 2025
Ask for deep water to get big fish. Take Dramamine the night before and day of. Really hydrate!!

customer-avatar
Michael Barrett
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Good Times Charters on March 2, 2025
Bryan is amazing captain. Don't waste your time with someone other than Bryan. We will book with him again

customer-avatar
Craig Laber
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on February 19, 2025
Anytime you’re on the ocean fishing in February is a great day. Mahi mahi are my favorite fish but they weren’t in season. We did catch a bunch of other kinds which was awesome.

customer-avatar
Christina Johnson
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on May 21, 2024
It’s harder work than u think!! Reeling in a shark or anything takes some arm muscle but the captain Eric helped us when our arms failed.

customer-avatar
Paul Quirk
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on May 14, 2024
A couple fish we caught were out of season. Everything really was great though, weather, sea and wind conditions. We really had a great day!

customer-avatar
Carlos Cardoso
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on April 29, 2024
Take the charter out with Captain Erik. He is amazing and super knowledgeable but also understand that he nor anyone else can predict weather or if the fish are biting.

customer-avatar
Michael Ross
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on January 4, 2024
Exceeded our wildest dreams for our first family experience in guided fishing. It really helps that you are in 1000’ deep water about 30 minutes from shore.

customer-avatar
Kristin Chase
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Good Times Charters on February 24, 2025
Wear sneakers or deck shoes and bring plenty of sunscreen. Everything else you need is provided ?

customer-avatar
Devin Clawson
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on September 25, 2024
It was beautiful, the water was surprisingly calm. And most importantly, the fish like to bite.