What would you recommend to anglers fishing in St. Thomas for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in St. Thomas

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
1 - 30 of 32 answers
customer-avatar
Shannon Cover
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on December 11, 2025
Wear shoes that have good traction, pack non spray sunscreen, and do not forget to drink water. If you are known to get sea sick I recommend taking ginger capsules before you get on the boat to calm your stomach

customer-avatar
Bobby Small
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on August 13, 2025
If youโ€™re fishing with children book a half a day trip take snacks catch a lot of fish. Do you know what youโ€™re doing? Doing all day trip go out and catch some big fish deep water come back in. Do some bottom fishing and get some snapper. Call it a day.

customer-avatar
Jason Smithey
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Drift Charters Fishing - RIPTIDE on June 18, 2025
Pretty rough waters for people who get sea sick easily. We were nearshore, and it was very rough. Can't do anything about that. Must be the waters here in St Thomas. Wished we could have went after bigger fish.

customer-avatar
Trista Nance
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Drift Charters Fishing - KAOS on June 4, 2025
Rough waters for going off shore on day of trip (6- 10 foot swells). Warned ahead of time and we still chose to go. Our family weathered it fine as we are an experienced fishing family. Our youngest is 10 - if rough, NOT advised for anyone younger. We hit the tuna jackpot and had a blast!!! ? worth it!!

customer-avatar
Mark Veilleux
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on October 27, 2024
Know whatโ€™s in season and understand that if youโ€™re going for wahoo or mahi-mahi itโ€™s a lot of trolling and time between bites. If youโ€™re willing to target the species that are around in numbers (tuna, rainbow runners, jacks, etc) you can have non-stop action. Also bring sunscreen, youโ€™ll need it.

customer-avatar
Joseph Loeffelmann
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on May 20, 2024
Go to Captain Eric Anaclerio, by far the best. Thereโ€™s a reason he only has 5 star reviews. I thought it was odd but I totally understand now. Donโ€™t regret it book him for your trip. Great with kids or just adults. The best!!!

customer-avatar
Marc Rortvedt
Lodi, WI
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Ocean Surfari Fishing Charters - St. Thomas on February 24, 2023
Explore, find the fish. Itโ€™s high risk high reward out here if youโ€™re fishing from shore. One spot might be nothing but needlefish (hound fish) the other might have so many 25-40โ€ tarpon youโ€™re guaranteed to find a hungry one. 3 stars because access is tough and from shore the variety is pretty low.

customer-avatar
Donald Hensley
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on June 2, 2026
st. Thomas was the best deep sea fishing that Iโ€™ve had so far, I highly recommend it, especially with Captain Erik

customer-avatar
Taylor Solem
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Drift Charters Fishing - KAOS on January 12, 2026
there is still fish around to catch but what i was told was the bigger game fish run in june-july but for a short trip to st. thomas it was great fishing and catching fish

customer-avatar
Robert Lyle Thompson
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Drift Charters Fishing - KAOS on December 27, 2025
Just be aware that itโ€™s fishing not catching! You never know what you will get. But we got great fish!

customer-avatar
Ty Averett
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Good Times Charters on November 7, 2025
call Captain Brian and be flexible. They know where the Fish is on the bite and where it's not usually.

customer-avatar
Belma Varupa
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Drift Charters Fishing - RIPTIDE on August 4, 2025
Very first time and experienced fisher friendly. You can sit back and enjoy the waters or just fish as soon as they dropped the lines we caught a mahi & barracuda!

customer-avatar
Justin Dutton
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Good Times Charters on August 2, 2025
Three hours with Captain Ron, errrr, Brian will change your life! Booking the Good Times was the best decision ever ?

customer-avatar
Keith Kulacz
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Good Times Charters on April 30, 2025
This is a local trip fishing wrecks and reefs.. Bryan is an excellent captain . The boat is just as described.

customer-avatar
Jason Stratta
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on April 2, 2025
So happy we booked with Captain Eric! We all caught fish (group of 6) and we all had a great time! Captain Eric is an experienced captain and angler, you wonโ€™t regret booking this trip!

customer-avatar
Gavin Claflin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Drift Charters Fishing - RIPTIDE on March 18, 2025
Itโ€™s better later in the season but itโ€™s still a great time and will be catching fish no matter what

customer-avatar
Michael Barrett
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Good Times Charters on March 2, 2025
Bryan is amazing captain. Don't waste your time with someone other than Bryan. We will book with him again

customer-avatar
Craig Laber
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on February 19, 2025
Anytime youโ€™re on the ocean fishing in February is a great day. Mahi mahi are my favorite fish but they werenโ€™t in season. We did catch a bunch of other kinds which was awesome.

customer-avatar
Christina Johnson
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on May 21, 2024
Itโ€™s harder work than u think!! Reeling in a shark or anything takes some arm muscle but the captain Eric helped us when our arms failed.

customer-avatar
Paul Quirk
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on May 14, 2024
A couple fish we caught were out of season. Everything really was great though, weather, sea and wind conditions. We really had a great day!

customer-avatar
Carlos Cardoso
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on April 29, 2024
Take the charter out with Captain Erik. He is amazing and super knowledgeable but also understand that he nor anyone else can predict weather or if the fish are biting.

customer-avatar
Michael Ross
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on January 4, 2024
Exceeded our wildest dreams for our first family experience in guided fishing. It really helps that you are in 1000โ€™ deep water about 30 minutes from shore.

customer-avatar
Aaron Conklin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on May 12, 2026
due to weather, we stayed with the ensure fishing paid off to be a great day with a lot of action

customer-avatar
Ly Foung Vang
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Virgin Islands Sportfishing - St. Thomas on December 9, 2025
Definitely book a trip with Captain Eric if you was the best fishing experience and land fish.

customer-avatar
Jeremy Kerth
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Good Times Charters on November 24, 2025
Have fun and send good vibes to the fishes! You will likely be rewarded with a catch!

customer-avatar
Joe Wozniak
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Good Times Charters on July 30, 2025
Itโ€™s fishing not catching. Go fishing and enjoy the day. Might be lucky and then not so lucky.

customer-avatar
Kimberly Kilpatrick
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Drift Charters Fishing - RIPTIDE on July 27, 2025
Be open to several species being caught. The waters temp is inviting to many types of fish.

customer-avatar
Theodore Chuha
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Drift Charters Fishing - RIPTIDE on July 6, 2025
This was our second fishing trip in St. Thomas. This one was the best by far. Would recommend 1000%

customer-avatar
Crystal Redmon
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Good Times Charters on June 23, 2025
Absolutely! Perfect trip for families, first time fishermen, and experienced alike!

customer-avatar
Deanna Mehlhoff
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Drift Charters Fishing - RIPTIDE on April 7, 2025
Ask for deep water to get big fish. Take Dramamine the night before and day of. Really hydrate!!