Charters from US $600

View details

Birthday Fishes Come True!

VERIFIED 6 Hour Trip – Nearshore/Offshore on May 31, 2024

Krystal R.

5.0 / 5

Birthday Fishes Come True!

VERIFIED

Krystal R.

5.0 / 5

Experience:

5.0 / 5

Boat

5.0 / 5

Crew

5.0 / 5

Overall

Captain George was an amazing fishing Captain! He made sure to make my son’s birthday wish of catching a hammerhead come true! And he added a ton of other fish too including a stingray! We had the absolute best trip and will definitely use Catain George again! Thanks for a wonderful day of fishing!

Captain George was an amazing fishing Captain! He made sure to make my son’s birthday wish of catching a hammerhead come...

Krystal R. recommends Keep It Tight Fishing Charters

Mark review as helpful

Reviews by other customers

Rating summary

5.0 / 5

out of 5 stars from 48 reviews

See details

Boat

5.0 / 5

Crew

5.0 / 5

Experience

4.9 / 5

Photos & videos by reviewers (55)

+52

Angler rating

5 stars		42
4 stars		1
3 stars		0
2 stars		0
1 star		0

Anglers claimed

Good experience
	92%
Friendly captain
	100%
Recommend this charter
	90%
Appropriate for children
	96%
Satisfied with the boat
	100%
Caught fish
	88%

Appropriate for children
	96%
Satisfied with the boat
	100%
Caught fish
	88%

Sort by:

Sort by: Featured

Showing:

5 of 48 reviews

Showing 1 - 5 of 48 reviews

Saravana K. T.

5.0 / 5

Experience:

5.0 / 5

Boat

5.0 / 5

Crew

5.0 / 5

Overall

An Epic Catch on a Special Day

VERIFIED 8Hr - Giant Blue Fin Tuna midshore on July 5, 2025

Saravana K. T.

5.0 / 5

Jul 5, 2025

8Hr - Giant Blue Fin Tuna midshore

An Epic Catch on a Special Day

VERIFIED

We had an unforgettable fishing trip on July 5th, which was my son’s 10th birthday! The captain and his team went above and beyond to make it a special day. Despite the initial challenges, they persisted and tried multiple spots, ultimately leading to a great catch! My kids had an absolute blast fighting with the fish, and the team’s enthusiasm and expertise made the experience truly unforgettable. Kudos to the captain and the entire team for their dedication and efforts. We can’t wait to... More

We had an unforgettable fishing trip on July 5th, which was my son’s 10th birthday! The captain and his team went above and...

Saravana K. T. recommends Keep It Tight Fishing Charters

Mark review as helpful

Max M.

5.0 / 5

Experience:

5.0 / 5

Boat

5.0 / 5

Crew

5.0 / 5

Overall

June fishing trip

VERIFIED NEW 6 Hour Trip – Nearshore/Offshore on June 7, 2026

Max M.

5.0 / 5

Jun 7, 2026

6 Hour Trip – Nearshore/Offshore

June fishing trip

VERIFIED NEW

Max M. recommends Keep It Tight Fishing Charters

Mark review as helpful

Max M. recommends Keep It Tight Fishing Charters

Mark review as helpful

Sandra D.

5.0 / 5

Experience:

5.0 / 5

Boat

5.0 / 5

Crew

5.0 / 5

Overall

Great Time

VERIFIED 6 Hour Trip - Stripped Bass on May 16, 2026

Sandra D.

5.0 / 5

May 16, 2026

6 Hour Trip - Stripped Bass

Great Time

VERIFIED

Despite it being a slow day, it was still a great time. We managed to secure a slot striper, and the Captain did his best to try to get some more fish for us.

Despite it being a slow day, it was still a great time. We managed to secure a slot striper, and the Captain did his best to...

Sandra D. recommends Keep It Tight Fishing Charters

Mark review as helpful

Amanda Rodriguez De Carvalho

5.0 / 5

Experience:

5.0 / 5

Boat

5.0 / 5

Crew

5.0 / 5

Overall

Loved our experience!

VERIFIED 4 Hour Trip – Bottom Fishing on August 23, 2025

Amanda Rodriguez De Carvalho

5.0 / 5

Aug 23, 2025

4 Hour Trip – Bottom Fishing

Loved our experience!

VERIFIED

George was so fun and literally did everything so that we could catch some fish! It was my brother’s birthday and we booked this as a gift for him and he absolutely loved it. Would do it again!!

George was so fun and literally did everything so that we could catch some fish! It was my brother’s birthday and we booked...

Amanda Rodriguez De Carvalho recommends Keep It Tight Fishing Charters

Mark review as helpful

Michael P.

5.0 / 5

Experience:

5.0 / 5

Boat

5.0 / 5

Crew

5.0 / 5

Overall

Fishing with George

VERIFIED 6 Hour Trip - Stripped Bass on August 24, 2025

Michael P.

5.0 / 5

Aug 24, 2025

6 Hour Trip - Stripped Bass

Fishing with George

VERIFIED

Even though the bite was tough due to bad weather cptn. George tried his best to get us on some fish and it paid off we started hauling them in towards the end great trip

Even though the bite was tough due to bad weather cptn. George tried his best to get us on some fish and it paid off we started...

Michael P. recommends Keep It Tight Fishing Charters

Mark review as helpful

...

More charters like Keep It Tight Fishing Charters in East Massapequa More charters in East Massapequa

Settings

Keep It Tight Fishing Charters

Recently viewed

Keep It Tight Fishing…

Big Jim’s Charters

Go Deeper Too – 38'…

Keep It Tight Fishing Charters

Birthday Fishes Come True!

Birthday Fishes Come True!

Reviews by other customers

An Epic Catch on a Special Day

An Epic Catch on a Special Day

June fishing trip

June fishing trip

Great Time

Great Time

Loved our experience!

Loved our experience!

Fishing with George

Fishing with George

More charters like Keep It Tight Fishing Charters in East Massapequa More charters in East Massapequa

About FishingBooker

Discover

Sitemap

Support

Recently viewed

Birthday Fishes Come True!

Birthday Fishes Come True!

Reviews by other customers

An Epic Catch on a Special Day

An Epic Catch on a Special Day

June fishing trip

June fishing trip

Great Time

Great Time

Loved our experience!

Loved our experience!

Fishing with George

Fishing with George

More charters like Keep It Tight Fishing Charters in East Massapequa More charters in East Massapequa

Your review has been published!