What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Montauk, New York for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Montauk

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
1 - 10 of 10 answers
customer-avatar
Jim Flesor
Bay Shore, New York
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Halfback Charters on July 28, 2018
I had a great time and great success on my trip, but you have to keep in mind you're fishing and there is never guarantees you're going to catch the big one every time. If you have the right, experienced Captain like I did (Halfback Charters- Captain Cortes) you will have a great chance. I highly recommend this boat.

customer-avatar
Joe Martin
The Bronx, NY
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Premium Charters on August 12, 2018
We had a great time , Captain John and his mate took really good care of us and we are looking forward to booking our next trip with him soon .

customer-avatar
Ryan Strother
Mound, MN
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Four C’s Montauk Sport Fishing on August 4, 2018
Captain told us that late June/early august is best for Striped Bass, but we had a great time pulling up sea bass in August!

customer-avatar
Dean Campbell
Brooklyn, NY
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with November Rain Charters on August 3, 2018
If i were to recommend to anglers fishing in Montauk. It would be to go and book a charter with November Rain Charters.

customer-avatar
Jimmy Mistretta
Brooklyn, New York
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Capt. Ron’s Fishing Charters on July 30, 2018
Charter a boat, the captain, knows the water & can advise on what bait, where to fish and how to catch.

customer-avatar
Stan Persky
East Hampton, New York
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with My Mate Charters on August 9, 2017
Let the Capt. make the decisions for the species and manner of fishing. He fishes all the time and is in touch with the changing conditions.

customer-avatar
Tom Cush
East Hartford, Connecticut
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Al’s Fishing Charters on July 15, 2017
Find a few friends and a good Capt for a private 1/2 day charter...if you come back and are not hooked then fishing is not for you!

customer-avatar
Michael Desmarais
Bronxville, NY
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Halfback Charters on August 27, 2018
Go with an experienced captain who knows the waters and which baits are working.

customer-avatar
Rudolph Henriksen
Huntington, New York
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Moondance Charters Of Montauk on August 25, 2018
Fished Montauk twice for bass in August once on the 1st and again on the 25th both times did great.

customer-avatar
George Woodhull
Brooklyn, New York
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Four C’s Montauk Sport Fishing on October 2, 2017
Go earlier in season, August, Sept. A storm Saturday screwed up fishing for Mon.

Weather Protection
Weather Protection
Canceled due to bad weather? We'll help reschedule or refund.
Best Price Guarantee
Best Price Guarantee
Found the same trip for less? We'll refund the difference!
Service You Can Trust
Service You Can Trust
7 day customer support for a hassle-free fishing experience.
Trusted Payments
Trusted Payments
Book via our secure platform and enjoy flexible payment options.