What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Sarasota, Florida for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Sarasota

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
31 - 60 of 148 answers
customer-avatar
Jay Davenport
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with James Gibson Charters LLC on May 29, 2025
I only fished the intercostal waters but would have liked to try the gulf but not enough time.

customer-avatar
Glen Glace
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Stellar Action Fishing Charters – 23’ Parker on May 6, 2025
We were first timers and the captain took care of everything. Baits, shoes how to cast, advice on reeling in. Cleaned the fish for us.

customer-avatar
KYLE VANDEGRAAF
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sarasota Sport Fishing, Fish Guaranteed! on April 17, 2025
Wanted to spend a morning catching fish and everyone did. Fishing offshore in the Gulf was a great experience with the right boat and captain.

customer-avatar
Paula Mitchell
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Get Salty Charters on March 19, 2025
You don't have to know anything about fishing. The captains help with everything. Just relax and have fun.

customer-avatar
David Underhill
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sarasota Sport Fishing, Fish Guaranteed! on March 25, 2025
Captain Chris was very accommodating to my wife that wasn’t feeling well. Made my daughter feel better when her cobia broke off.

customer-avatar
Andy Kulas
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Rodbender Fishing Charters on March 25, 2025
Do not hesitate to book a charter with Captain Scoot, very reasonably priced and great experience! Caught a lot of fish!!!

customer-avatar
Charles Hughes
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Suncoast Fishing Adventures on March 14, 2025
Absolutely recommend fishing in Sarasota in March. We had a beautiful day and caught quite a few keepers.

customer-avatar
Nancy Brandenburg
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Reel Knowledge Fishing(FishGuarant) on February 14, 2025
Be sure to bring something light weight and long sleeved so you don’t get too much sun exposure. Hat is important too.

customer-avatar
David Pullen
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Always N Adventure Fishing Charter on December 28, 2024
Small charters are my favorite. Local captains that know the area and which techniques and baits work best keeps me coming back year after year.

customer-avatar
Kayla Ohm
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sarasota Sport Fishing, Fish Guaranteed! on December 22, 2024
Little chillier than we expected but we know for next time to dress warmer if we are fishing in the winter months.

customer-avatar
Sheri Schmutte
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Windward Fishing Charters on December 22, 2024
Set up with this option! We’ve done a few fishing trips in different places and this was by far the best! So fun and so many fish. We even saw a dolphin too! <3

customer-avatar
Jeffrey Stano
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sarasota Sport Fishing, Fish Guaranteed! on November 29, 2024
Don’t set your expectations too high, Fishing is gambling and on any given day, you could lose and not catch anything. Nothing in life is guaranteed

customer-avatar
Michael Burke
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Rodbender Fishing Charters on November 14, 2024
This was less than a 1/2 day boat rental and he had the equipment, bait, gear and licenses. He know the area and where to fish. He also taught me a ton.

customer-avatar
Mindee Mccurley
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sarasota Sport Fishing, Fish Guaranteed! on November 10, 2024
Best advice is to get in good with the locals, they know the best spots and the best times. They know tides, and how to target specific species. They also have the best recipes!

customer-avatar
Amanda Williams
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sarasota Sport Fishing, Fish Guaranteed! on September 1, 2024
Request Jose for your captain especially if you are first timers or have younger children. He has the patience of a saint!! Absolutely love him!!

customer-avatar
Alex Basti
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with TNT Freedom Fishing Charters – Siesta Key on July 30, 2024
although these summer months are tough, if you can suck up the heat its still an incredible experience to get out there on the water

customer-avatar
Amy Anderson
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jack's Fishing Charters on July 23, 2024
Fishing in water on the mangroves was a fun day of action, lots of different fish and action all morning.

customer-avatar
Gabriel Ruff
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sarasota Sport Fishing, Fish Guaranteed! on July 18, 2024
Sunscreen is a must as is reapplying regularly, hydration and snacks are equally important. Fishing only twice in my life, I caught many, many fish yesterday and had an absolute blast!

customer-avatar
Kyle Gandy
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sarasota Sport Fishing, Fish Guaranteed! on July 13, 2024
Can be warm, but able to drink and enjoy the time. Recommend sunscreen and a patient attitude. Fish are biting.

customer-avatar
Charlotte Bimba
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jack's Fishing Charters on July 3, 2024
I cannot imagine a better experience for my son and two grandsons! You will not be disappointed with Captain Jack! He is wise beyond his years.

customer-avatar
Matthew Ferro
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Get Salty Charters on July 1, 2024
Ask around for a good hook and cook (restaurants that cook/prepare your fresh catch you just caught that day!) we went to Walt’s Fish Market and Restaurant.

customer-avatar
Rodney Johnson
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Reel Tight Fishing Charters – Siesta Key on June 25, 2024
Bring a small bag of snacks if you have kid's. And a small cooler. If you want your fillets from different species separated I would bring my own gallon bags.

customer-avatar
Ian Mcdonald
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Dandy Charter Fishing on June 22, 2024
Long sleeves and plenty of sunscreen! It’s going to be hot so just accept it and you will have a blast.

customer-avatar
Dan Anderson
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with TNT Freedom Fishing Charters – Siesta Key on June 7, 2024
I only have one data point and don’t know how things vary with season etc. I’d do this again either the same time of year or another time.

customer-avatar
Kevin Quier
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Siesta Key Fishing Charters on May 25, 2024
Captain Bryan is extremely knowledgable of the waters and knows the best spots to go catch a lot of fish! You will have a great experience with him!

customer-avatar
Tim Alley
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with TNT Freedom Fishing Charters – Siesta Key on May 23, 2024
Tide coming in made things a little more difficult with fish behavior, but we still caught quite a few fish of various species.

customer-avatar
Frank Kish
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Windward Fishing Charters on May 18, 2024
May inshore - based on what we caught and what we saw at the dock - expect snook, some red snapper, occasional bluefish, saltwater catfish, kingfish.

customer-avatar
Julie Gilles
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sarasota Sport Fishing, Fish Guaranteed! on May 12, 2024
Fish we caught were out of season or too small. Not a lot of”Good” bites but still had a great time on the water with the family and a fun captain,

customer-avatar
James Cella
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Rodbender Fishing Charters on April 7, 2024
Spend the extra money and get a bigger charter boat that can handle the gulf in slightly windy conditions

customer-avatar
Gary Stratton
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Rodbender Fishing Charters on March 23, 2024
Definitely watch the weather! It was windy so we didn’t get on all the big fish we wanted but still a great time and memory we won’t forget