What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Nassau for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Nassau

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
1 - 30 of 92 answers
customer-avatar
Denise Noyer-Erez
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Cozy Waters "We Cook Your Catch" on July 23, 2025
Captain George and DeVaughn were great teachers. You can always learn on your own and when you have someone coach you that already has the experience it makes things way more enjoyable then you get further faster!

customer-avatar
Fortunato Puleo
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hunter Charters – Y Knot 26’ on July 19, 2025
If you plan on going offshore, you better eat your Wheaties first lol, after catching our first game fish I hooked into what felt like a small tuna and then no time it started ripping over 200 yards of wine, which was obviously a shark. The four of us on the boat fought it for over an hour until finally, it broke the line. Your body is going to feel that the next day. ?

customer-avatar
Mark Broderick
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing, Snorkeling, Island Hopping Tours on July 3, 2025
Be conscious of whether you want to keep what you catch. Depending on where you are staying, this may be a challenge. Make sure all the arrangements are clear before hand just to make sure you can keep what you catch.

customer-avatar
Eric Zinsitz
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Cozy Waters "We Cook Your Catch" on June 14, 2025
The high winds make the Waverley choppy and difficult to fish. The area is over fished. The fish are also highly pressured. I spent more time trying to finesse fish and catch him with a hook set. It’s not easy. This is no reflection on the crew.

customer-avatar
Kimberly Garcia
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with E.l. Watersports on April 26, 2025
Don’t always expect to caught something. It’s called fishing for a reason. I always say a day on the water is a great day rather you bring dinner home in the bucket or it’s empty being on the water is always a great day!

customer-avatar
Trennon Massengale
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captainctours on October 24, 2024
We caught a lot of fish, but this time of year the weather is not perfect if you’re trying to catch wahoo. If you’re coming just to Fish, I would wait until the second week of November. Unless you’re coming to have fun and it was an amazing trip.

customer-avatar
Jack Rountree
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with E.l. Watersports on October 13, 2024
We had an amazing time as a family trip with a child nine years old. Please keep in mind. We were bottom fishing with Live bait. Well, anything is possible most of the fish we caught were a pound to 2 pounds in weight. It was more about the experience overall. We had an awesome time. I’m sure if you’re looking for big fish Just message the captain beforehand to see how he can help you

customer-avatar
Aaron Budhisetiawan
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captainctours on March 15, 2024
We probably fished for a total of about 2.5HRS at no fault of Cpt. We wanted to have our fish cooked by a restaurant recommended which left us with limited time fishing due to our departure time. We caught a total of 16 keepers. Probably just as many if not more releases, and just as many if not more misses. There were 3 in my party. 1 avid fisherman, 1 done it before and can do it again, and 1 who has never held a rod in their hand. The catches worked out as you would expect. The novice missed as many bites as they got. The experienced missed a few. The avid caught the most but still missed some Bites.

customer-avatar
Marvin Beasley
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hunter Charters – 48’ Inagua Salt on July 15, 2024
Make sure AC works That’s why a paid the extra money and should have been notified-the AC wasn’t working -we sweated our butts off- we would have renegotiated rate Also wasn’t happy about the boarding fee that had to be paid at the dock- should have know about that also - it wasn’t that much but felt like it was BS

customer-avatar
Nick Koster
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captainctours on July 19, 2024
Great light tackle trip, lots of fish - nothing huge but plenty of action and the triggerfish fight hard. Also had a line in the water with bait for a predator so opportunity for larger fish is there.

customer-avatar
Johnathon Grumelot
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sunshine Charters on July 9, 2024
Prepare for the heat and stay hydrated. Trust the knowledgeable and experienced captains. They know where to go and how to best fish in the Bahamas. Also remember there is a lot of other things that can be done during the charter. Island hop, snorkeling and tours. The half day tours are great but a whole day is the best. Fishing may require patience and some trial and error.

customer-avatar
James Buckner
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captainctours on June 25, 2024
If you are fishing with individuals who want the action of actually catching fish, especially with younger children, this is absolutely a great charter. We did catch several good fish and a variety, enough in just an hour or so to cook a great meal during the trip.

customer-avatar
Stephanie Blackburn
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hook Um Fishing Charters on March 12, 2024
Be aware that you will be trolling most of the time - whether deep sea or in shallow waters. It is not “active” fishing like we’ve experience most other places. With a great captain you can still have a good time — and with luck you can still bring in fish!

customer-avatar
Barry Marontate
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing 242 Charters – 32' SeaVee on February 1, 2024
Make sure you read all reviews and how the Captain responds. Bad days of fishing can’t be predicted but bad service is another matter. Captain Teddy was a class act compared to other captain’s I’ve had here in the Bahamas

customer-avatar
Paul Apostolon
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captainctours on December 9, 2023
Fishing in December is limited and wind risky. However, temperatures are great. We caught a nice cross-section of fish. Mackerel, Barracuda, Grouper and Yellowtail. Early morning is best. Great outing.

customer-avatar
Stephen Carlisle
Waldo, FL
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Yellowtail Charters – Major Moves 32' on May 18, 2023
I fish a lot and the one thing I would recommend is to bring some ice to ice down your catch and keep it fresh. Its not so bad to not have ice on a 4 hour charter but I would definitely recommend bringing ice for the fish if you do a whole day charter.

customer-avatar
Thomas Jackson
Nassau, NP
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Chubasco Charters VI – 38' on April 9, 2019
If you expect to do sport fishing, deep sea fishing, book a 35-38 foot boat at a minimum. Boats that size and larger usually have restrooms and cabins and that can help make the experience much nicer for your first time out. Take tons of photos and videos. Get yourself ready for memories of a lifetime.

customer-avatar
Shay Eaton
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with 5 G’s Fishing Charters-45’ Hatteras on July 30, 2025
Bring sunscreen! It was a very hot and humid day, however the breeze on top of the boat was so nice and cooling!

customer-avatar
Amanda Shafer
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Cozy Waters "We Cook Your Catch" on July 10, 2025
Perfect experience for all experience levels. We caught everything from smaller reef fish to sharks.

customer-avatar
Dana Gardner
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Te'vaughn Adventures Charter on July 3, 2025
The weather was perfect. The water was calm and we caught a lot because Captain Ted is a pro and knew exactly where to go.

customer-avatar
Curtis Briles
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing 242 Charters – 32' SeaVee on June 13, 2025
Can’t give a true opinion, met people at the dock after our trip who crushed fish, but we caught just a few tiny fish.

customer-avatar
Morgan Stenberg
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Yellowtail Charters – Major Moves 32' on July 1, 2025
Just book the trip! It was wonderful just being on the water seeing all the views even if you don’t catch anything. We caught 2 fish and we were very happy!

customer-avatar
Patrick Halaszyn
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captainctours on July 19, 2025
Hope for good weather and boom with Cap’t Charlie! Andre and Bob are great.

customer-avatar
Julie Staub
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captainctours on July 2, 2025
Check the boat, it’s marina and what fish you’re targeting BEFORE your fishing day.

customer-avatar
Sara Phillips
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captainctours on May 22, 2025
We did a couple of fishing trips while we were here this vacation and this was the best overall experience

customer-avatar
Daniel Smith
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Yellowtail Charters – Yellow Tail 42' on April 24, 2025
Sunscreen, long sleeves for sun block. Hat with strap (windy) sunglasses a must. Listen and they will catch you fish.

customer-avatar
Harry Caulton
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing, Snorkeling, Island Hopping Tours on April 13, 2025
Do your research, I have expected Fishing Hooker to do theirs, but apparently not. I hope that they contact me for at least a partial refund.

customer-avatar
Tricia Macalka
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captainctours on April 17, 2025
Quantity over quality here. Not a lot of big fish, but a lot of decent grunt, strawberry grouper and squirrel fish.

customer-avatar
Christian Mielke
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captainctours on April 11, 2025
This was an excellent family experience and you do not need to be an expert. The Captain and First Mate were very patient with the kids who have limited fishing experience.

customer-avatar
Brittany Small
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Cozy Waters "We Cook Your Catch" on March 27, 2025
We had a really windy day and only caught 2 in the couple of hours we fished but on a better day I'm sure there'd be more bites