What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Herradura, Puntarenas for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Herradura

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
31 - 60 of 103 answers
customer-avatar
Stephen Crossman
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Gitana Fishing on August 15, 2025
The captain made the trip easy. obviously bring sunscreen and a dry bag for you belongings.

customer-avatar
Jennifer Naumann
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hooked Up Sportfishing Costa Rica on August 5, 2025
Inshore can be rough- not what a “Gringo” expects…lol but a good time…and beautiful!

customer-avatar
Mckee Mckee
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Snook Sportfishing on August 4, 2025
Capt. Jorge was very professional and knew exactly where to get fish.I definitely would recommend him if you want a great experience.

customer-avatar
Justin Smith
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Luminare Sport Fishing on July 21, 2025
Let the crew know what fish you are after. They will take care of the rest. Bring sunscreen and a rain jacket.

customer-avatar
Steven Carroll
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Snook Sportfishing on June 8, 2025
Do not hesitate! Just do it! Book Snook, when you arrive find the green shuttle boats to take you out to your vessel!

customer-avatar
Aaron Pulone
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing CR on May 8, 2025
For some boats, you are required to get on a water taxi and ride out to the actual fishing boat. If there is any chop, this could result in getting hurt. Get a boat located in a marina

customer-avatar
Robert Jakiun
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Snook Sportfishing on March 5, 2025
When considering my next inshore trip. I think i would try a later trip. We were prepared for the inshore heat and fished hard for results.

customer-avatar
Jared Sartell
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Black Marlin Sportfishing on February 25, 2025
Give yourself a long enough charter to maximize your opportunities. Sunscreen and liquids are a must.

customer-avatar
Rick Sarten
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with R SPORT Fishing on February 16, 2025
Fish nearshore in smaller boats and only use boats 38ft or larger for off shore. January is the best time for the larger fish.

customer-avatar
Josh Glover
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Dream Boats Costa Rica – 32' Luhrs on January 23, 2025
Book fast as it’s busy season, we came planning to book here but the options were limited. But we ended up on the best boat with the best crew! Couldn’t have asked for anything better!

customer-avatar
James Grant
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Snook Sportfishing on January 16, 2025
Sunscreen, large billed hat, and a long sleeved sun shirt. These made it a lot more comfortable under the hot sun.

customer-avatar
Ivanhoe Romin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing Herradura on January 1, 2025
Great fishing location / pods of dolphins; yellow fin tunas jumping/ many sailfish/ some blue mains / lots of mahi mahi

customer-avatar
Gary Gibson
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing CR on December 31, 2024
Book close in short trips to catch fish to eat, and book day long trips to go out 20 miles for sailfish.

customer-avatar
Troy Didtrek
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing CR on December 11, 2024
Not many fish around this December. As the captain said “ you should have been here in November “

customer-avatar
Jessica Davis
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing CR on November 30, 2024
Rain jacket helped when we went through some rain. If you get motion sickness easily, bring Dramamine or something along those lines.

customer-avatar
Katherine Zhu
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with The Brother Alex Tour on September 14, 2024
Just be prepared to get dirty! You’ll get splashed on by the fish (lightly) and you might get some blood on you.

customer-avatar
Logan Herring
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Snook Sportfishing on September 7, 2024
Definitely bring a rain jacket and expect to have to brace yourself a bit for rough seas. Also, make sure to take some Dramamine.

customer-avatar
Geoff Hyland
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Snook Sportfishing on August 4, 2024
Yes the captain has great at finding the fish and we had a great time. Herradura was a good port to go out of. Would highly recommend.

customer-avatar
Zachary Esposito
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with The Brother Alex Tour on August 2, 2024
Fish Quepos/ Manuel Antonio if possible but if you’re looking for something near Jaco/ Herradura definitely book the Brothers Alex Tour.

customer-avatar
Brian O’neill
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Snook Sportfishing on July 17, 2024
Bring a cooler if you plan to take fish home. There is an ice vending machine just outside the launch beach.

customer-avatar
Andrew Burke
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing Herradura on July 15, 2024
Try a half day that is more affordable. If we would have chose a few of the other options and still not catch much, we would have been very disappointed.

customer-avatar
John Simonof
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hooked Up Sportfishing Costa Rica on May 4, 2024
Prepare for a long boat ride to get to the tuna this time of year; I thought we'd be much closer to shore. Sporadic action but when it's on...it's on.

customer-avatar
Jonathan Shouse
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing CR on April 22, 2024
I can see kids having trouble reeling in those larger fish. This trip was actually more than I expected, great lunch, beverages, knowledge and overall day. Just fabulous.

customer-avatar
Ghislain Poulin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Gitana Fishing on March 27, 2024
Make sure you have a clear plan with your captain, and make sure they understand what you want to catch. Find another spot if you're not catching.

customer-avatar
Blair Brannock
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Snook Sportfishing on March 28, 2024
The trip is behind the pelican restaurant next to los suenos. A mistake I made was going to los suenos marina. Then I had to walk 20 min. To the actual spot.

customer-avatar
Jordan Hartmeyer
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Snook Sportfishing on March 27, 2024
We caught a bad moon cycle and the fishing was a little slow.(some days are like that) however We did catch a really nice trophy size cubera.

customer-avatar
Roy DeCastro
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing Herradura on March 12, 2024
Captain said that they caught 13 fish the day before. Hard to believe we did not catch anything except two small fish.

customer-avatar
Daniel Flores
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing CR on February 12, 2024
Ask the captains what’s biting and fish for whatever that is. Don’t waste your time chasing a dream fish that’s not in the area at the time you’re there.

customer-avatar
Tracy Stein
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Luminare Sport Fishing on January 30, 2024
Fishing in january in this part of costa rica is one of the best times of the year highly recommended.

customer-avatar
John Lehman
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Snook Sportfishing on January 29, 2024
Understand if you want to fight or eat or both. Redfish are a great fight and taste great. Roosters are a good fight but are terrible on the table. Understand your bait.