What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Milwaukee, Wisconsin for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Milwaukee

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
1 - 22 of 22 answers
customer-avatar
Eric Brown
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hold'em Sportfishing LLC on August 29, 2024
Keep in mind there’s more to enjoy than catching fish. I’ve been on many charters between shoreline gulf in Florida, Lake Erie, and Lake Michigan. We’ve always caught fish. Sometimes 1 per hour and sometimes you don’t stop reeling them in. Captain’s bring the strategy but the fis

customer-avatar
Kevin Cipperly
Oak Grove, MN
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Leisure Time Charters on August 6, 2022
Be ready for a great experience, but remember it’s called fishing for a reason. We caught a lot of fish primarily rainbow trout and then lake trout too. We did not get salmon (which I would have loved to catch). But that’s why they call it fishing.

customer-avatar
Karl Vogel
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Threel Seaker Charters on June 10, 2025
Check ahead on fish if you can. We came during a tough time, between bites of Coho and King, just the wrong window.

customer-avatar
Roberto Serna
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hold'em Sportfishing LLC on June 1, 2025
Book this boat for a wonderful fishing trip. These people know what they are doing. Lots fish. Very knowledgeable captain and first mate

customer-avatar
Adam Shock
Columbus, OH
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hold'em Sportfishing LLC on May 26, 2025
Definitely take a charter, its worth it. Im sure some of the other charters are good but I can only speak on Hold'em Sportsfishing and highly recommend them!

customer-avatar
C. Jerod Silvers
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Reel Sensation Charters on August 8, 2024
If your fishing party is able to. Get the morning time slot. We had steady fishing, but the morning caught ten(10) more fish.

customer-avatar
Lily Hogue
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Leisure Time Charters on July 6, 2024
It was windy during transit so make sure to bring a sweater or jacket as it could get chilly but weather was perfect. Pack a small cooler with drinks/snacks if you have kids.

customer-avatar
David Martin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Blue Max Charters Salmon Fishing on July 12, 2024
Having a guide that is experienced in the waters and is friendly and knowledgeable which is what Captain Jim of Blue Max Charters is. We learned a lot from him on our trip.

customer-avatar
Scott Saari
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Crabby Charters - Trout & Salmon on July 1, 2024
Be willing to learn from Captain Crabby, as he is very knowledgeable and willing to help. Bring motion sickness medicine as you never know what Lake Michigan will be like.

customer-avatar
Max Rustan
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Blue Max Charters Salmon Fishing on June 3, 2024
May-June is great for salmon. Be sure to bring a jacket as it can be cold and windy in the morning.

customer-avatar
MaryAnne Majors
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Leisure Time Charters on September 10, 2022
September is late in the season for fishing on Lake Michigan for salmon. Rainbow trout and lake trout were what we caught.

customer-avatar
Melanie Schroeder
Milwaukee, WI
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Leisure Time Charters on July 16, 2021
I would recommend taking the early charters. We seemed to catch most of our fish early in the morning.

customer-avatar
Christopher Osgood
Chicago, IL
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Let's Joe Fishing Salmon Charters on July 5, 2019
If you are looking for a fun and learning experience with strong fish pulling on your line. Milwaukee is awesome.

customer-avatar
Scott Bowman
Oak Creek, Wisconsin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Let's Joe Fishing Salmon Charters on June 27, 2019
Let's Joe Fishing is a great choice for a Lake Michigan charter. I like the more personal experience that Joe gives.

customer-avatar
Lalchand Goyal
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Milwaukee Offshore Fishing, LLC on June 19, 2024
This is the best boat for first timers and experienced one We highly recommend this boat and crew

customer-avatar
Althea Price
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Blue Max Charters Salmon Fishing on July 8, 2023
We had a good return on catching. Would have loved to catch more but very satisfied for first time.

customer-avatar
Danilo Hipolito
Naperville, Illinois
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Blue Max Charters Salmon Fishing on May 20, 2023
Check the weather pattern and contact the boat captain for trends so you can plan the trip better.

customer-avatar
Kathy Rezutek
Lake Mills, WI
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Leisure Time Charters on June 19, 2021
dress warm - it can get cool on the lake - windy - won't be any sunbathing this trip!