What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Fort Myers, Florida for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Fort Myers

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
1 - 30 of 159 answers
customer-avatar
Jim Jenkins
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Gulf Coast Charter Service on May 4, 2026
If you have not experienced a fishing charter before, book the half day option (4 hours). Many people underestimate the physical rigorousness of time on a moving boat in sometimes choppy water. An 8-hour trip is a long day on the water for most people who do not do this frequently or for a living.

customer-avatar
Eric Theriault
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Capt. Rey Rodriguez Fishing Charters on April 6, 2026
i was expecting another long boat ride out, with notging but 1 or 2 fish for the day. completely opposite of that!!!! 30 min boat ride and we were carching fish the whole trip!!!! The captian was just as excited as we were every time we hooked one!!!

customer-avatar
Steve Weskerna
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Reel Rednecks Fishing Adventures on March 17, 2026
Skipper Evan is a good guide. He worked his butt off to put us on fish, but the weather and sea conditions did not cooperate. He made the trip comfortable for my family. Judging by his determination and drive, I would certainly hire him again.

customer-avatar
Kim Stone
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Gulf Coast Charter Service on January 4, 2026
Highly recommend this trip. Captain was knowledgeable and out to make our trip what we wanted. We caught fish and he let me run alongside a school of dolphins. We will be repeating customers. Boat was very clean ! Very satisfied with our catch and he filleted them for us and gave us great cooking tips.

customer-avatar
MICHAEL HAMBY
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Boat Day Charters โ€“ Unique Boat - Lil' Yachty on October 22, 2025
We had an absolutely amazing day! Our only plan was to relax โ€” boating, soaking up the sunshine, taking in the beautiful views, and enjoying the tranquil breezes. But Captain Scott had even better ideas! He surprised us with a perfect lunch stop at Cabbage Key and made sure every detail was just right โ€” even curating the perfect music for our trip. It was our 25th anniversary, and thanks to Captain Scott, it became a truly unforgettable day.

customer-avatar
Kyle Gibson
Mooresville, NC
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fort Myers Shark Outfitters on July 15, 2025
Be sure that youโ€™re paying attention to the tide charts when you schedule your appointment. The are normally more active with an out going tide. You will also want to consider the bugs. They are pretty thick during the rainy season. You will want to pack bug spray with a high deet content. It would also be smart to wear long sleeves and pants if possible. A bug net is not out of the question. If you have your own beach chair, youโ€™re welcome to bring it although the captain does provide chairs for everyone. Fishing can be slow so itโ€™s nice to have something to do while youโ€™re out there. This is a fantastic excursion that we would do again in a heartbeat.

customer-avatar
Deleted User
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with deleted charter 25097 on February 22, 2024
The Snook were a little tougher to find since they were just starting to move into the coves. Perfect time for Sea Trout though, they were really high quality fish and we caught one after another, 22-23 inchers were common. Next time I may wait until the Snook season opens in March and maybe the Red Fish will be moved in a little more by that time. But, I would do this trip over again in a heartbeat, weather was perfect and we found fish everywhere the dolphins were not!

customer-avatar
Julie Katz
Palm Coast, Florida
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Blind Date Charters on March 20, 2020
Captain Tom is by far "THE FISH WISHPER"!! We caught fish consistently the entire trip. This great experienced angler really knows where all the honey holes are! This family owned company by far made us feel safe and had tons of fun! We caught everything from grouper, to snapper to name a few. They even offered to filet the fish to take home with us. I have been on many chartered deep sea fishing trips, and this was by far the best one. I would highly recommend Blind Date Charters to anybody looking for a great day fishing!!

customer-avatar
Jon Sourbeer
McLean, VA
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Indigenous Charters on March 7, 2019
Watch the weather patterns and try to get a few warm days in a row to make the snook more active. Still early forTarpon and the normally reliable sea trout are still recovering from the red tide last year so maybe next year might be better it you prefer that species. We had a great time catching lady fish when the water temps dipped and put the snook off their feed. Be prepared for some wind this time of year.

customer-avatar
Thomas Slaughter
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Gulf Coast Charter Service on August 8, 2025
The weather is constantly changing. While we didn't get rained on (heavily) there were definitely showers in the area. I would suggest bringing at least a change of clothes to have ready and waiting for you in the event you experience rain while on the water.

customer-avatar
Brian Schimming
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Chum Crazy Charters on January 6, 2025
Get ready to catch some absolutely stud fish. Cpt. Drew works hard for you to be able to fish hard! I recommend learning how to fish with a spin cast rod so you are ready for this adventure that you are about to embark on that way you don't miss a fish of a lifetime! Good luck fishing and listen to your captain

customer-avatar
John Mayer
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Gulf Coast Charter Service on December 28, 2024
Bring a camera, bring snacks, bring your drinks of your choice. And be ready to catch fish. The captain knows how to fish listen to him and you will catch fish. Lady fish bring the best fight, trout bring the best hits. Both hit light a north bound freight train.

customer-avatar
Jeffrey Abbott
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Tarpon Magic Charters on October 24, 2024
Ft. Myers has great opportunties for fishing. The Sanibel area is absolutely beautiful. A charter will help you take the worry out of species sizes and limits. They will also get you to the best fishing locations and know which techniques work.

customer-avatar
Jamie Day
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jackโ€™s Fishing Charters on March 25, 2024
If you are fishing in the morning, especially in March, make sure to dress appropriately (pants, jacket, etc). We used a waterproof case for our phones so we could take videos and pics quickly and didn't have to worry about getting phone wet. And most importantly, Jack knows what he is doing so just relax and enjoy the fishing time!

customer-avatar
Kelly Tracy
Commerce Charter Township, MI
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Flats Fishโ€™r Charters - Fort Myers on January 31, 2019
Only because January can be a crap shoot : ) It was cold the day we fished so things were a bit quiet - but 2 days later is was back in the mid/high 70's and I'm sure much better for those anglers :) :)

customer-avatar
Doug Dahlberg
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hookin' Snook Charters on August 12, 2026
Captain was awesome and very patient with us. I would strongly recommend them to anyone considering booking a charter.

customer-avatar
Amanda Johnson
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Luck o' The Irish Fishing Charters on August 4, 2026
This was a gift for my husband who is an avid fisherman. Doesnโ€™t sound like the boat went very far, had enough bait, or was the boat shown when booking.

customer-avatar
Wesley Sadler
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jackโ€™s Fishing Charters on August 4, 2026
Bring light tackle, use a cast net, go find "greenies" and throw them on a circle hook by structure to find mangroves either for fun or to eat.

customer-avatar
Joseph Zullo
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Make A Wake โ€“ Sanibel Island on July 20, 2026
Be prepared for rain and storms, stay flexible with techniques. And listen to the captains they know what they are doing

customer-avatar
Kevin Knight
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jackโ€™s Fishing Charters on July 9, 2026
I would definitely recommend Captain Jack time of year. The fishing here is outstanding in Captain knows his stuff.

customer-avatar
William Holshoy
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hookin' Snook Charters on July 9, 2026
Talking to locals at every opportunity, and booking a good charter will show you the best methods and locations for catching good fish!

customer-avatar
Tabby Winters
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Gulfshore Fishing Company on June 30, 2026
some fish arent in season so be prepared tou will likely cath thinga you cant keep. Sometimes you may not catch a ton of a specific species but youโ€™ll probably catch something!

customer-avatar
James Bloom
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Saltwater Excursions on August 13, 2026
Spend your money on near shore fishing trips if you just want tight lines and ripping lips.

customer-avatar
Kevin Larson
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with No Negativity Charters on August 12, 2026
Be prepared for the heat. Where long sleeves and a good hat, abd bring sunscreen.

customer-avatar
Amanda Cutter
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Boat Day Charters โ€“ Unique Boat - Lil' Yachty on August 5, 2026
Absolutely i would recommend Captain Scott- he was very kind , knowledgeable, and patient

customer-avatar
Eric Cline
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Capt. Bill Walker's Fishing Charters on June 14, 2026
Wear sunscreen. Be patient its fishing not catching. I have been out on 4 trips total with different Captains. Some days we caught alot , some not so much. But I have enjoyed them all.

customer-avatar
Michael Flaherty
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Free-Spirit Adventures on April 24, 2026
If a flying fish jumped into the boat, it would have escaped before we could grab it. I think it was National No Catch Day!

customer-avatar
Joseph Izzo
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Luck o' The Irish Fishing Charters on April 6, 2026
Nice little center console boat . These are spartan crafts without amenities but perfect for a 1/2 day in the back bays.

customer-avatar
Ted Hintze
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Blind Date Charters on March 27, 2026
I ABSOLUTELY would recommend fishing with Blind Date Charters whether it's a first-time (like my experience) or your 10th time, you won't be disappointed.

customer-avatar
Anne Scharmach
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jackโ€™s Fishing Charters on March 21, 2026
For someone visiting for the first time, the variety can be overwhelming, but focusing on key inshore and shore-based spots provides a great introduction to the area's rich fisheries.