What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Marathon, Florida for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Marathon

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
61 - 90 of 197 answers
customer-avatar
Alex Gunn
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Ana Banana Fishing Charters (Cpt JoJo) on December 26, 2024
Depending on weather conditions and your tolerance for ocean waves, it may be prudent to book an inshore charter if you have any reservations about sea/motion sickness

customer-avatar
Brittany Rohde
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Only Fins & Borden Company LLC on December 25, 2024
Reach out to Only fins and request to fish with Captain Rich. You will not regret it! Especially if you have kids or any mobility restraints.

customer-avatar
Stephen Colgate
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Jersey Key “inshore” on December 24, 2024
Be prepared for 2 foot seas. I have fished other times when the water was clear as glass. Not a problem for me, but others may assume calmer waters.

customer-avatar
Eric Prentice
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Johnny Maddox Charters “PapaPapa” on December 23, 2024
The weather can vary but if you book with an experienced crew such as Johnny and his guys you will not be disappointed

customer-avatar
William Boyd
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Infinite Blue – 50’ SeaRay, Veteran Owned on December 23, 2024
Just show up go out with cats and Rob. They have everything you need and start fishing for the best time of your life

customer-avatar
Marion Andrews
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hooked on the Keys on December 19, 2024
Select a date with nice weather and be patient. Many of the fish will be undersized but there are larger ones to be caught

customer-avatar
Austin Brewster
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Manicsportfishing 31 foot Cabin and Bathroom on December 19, 2024
I’d recommend researching the different methods of catching whatever kind is species you’re going after.

customer-avatar
George Einterz
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Callion Fishing Charters on December 14, 2024
I believe this excursion was more suited to teens and older. This opinion may be formed more by the weather as opposed to the actual trip.

customer-avatar
Jeff Odenthal
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Infinite Blue – 50’ SeaRay, Veteran Owned on December 4, 2024
Be ready for an amazing experience! Hold on to your phone tightly ?. Thanks Capt Robert for saving mine.

customer-avatar
Dan Miller
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Infinite Blue – 50’ SeaRay, Veteran Owned on November 12, 2024
Seas can be rough in November. Booking a larger vessel, like Infinite Blue, can save anyone with a tendency to get seasick.

customer-avatar
Earl Trevino
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jay Charters 2 – Bay Boat on October 20, 2024
Book with Captain Ben, it was our first time Ocean fishing, he really took the time to help us be successful!

customer-avatar
Myron Gurman
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing an Fun! on August 21, 2024
Fishing from the pontoon boat is a great way to introduce anyone to Marathon waters . The boat is stable & very comfortable. Plus, there’s ample sun protection .

customer-avatar
Robert Waldron
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Reel Destiny Shark And Sport Fishing Charters on August 8, 2024
Follow the captain’s recommendations. Richard Bradley know what’s biting and where they’re located.

customer-avatar
Doug Broughton
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing Kings on July 9, 2024
This is a great trip for experienced/beginners and cost-effectiveness. The caltiqn lives local was really good to make us feel welcome and suggested a cool restaurant to cooking or catch.

customer-avatar
Joel Bach
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Foodchain Fishing on July 5, 2024
All except way too hot!! Our best experience was the catch and recommendation for straight to the table for dinner that night!

customer-avatar
Jacie Meier
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing Kings on July 6, 2024
Remember your sunblock (not spray), take a hat and sunglasses, wear long sleeve ‘fishing’ shirts, make sure you’re drinking water!

customer-avatar
Justin Phillips
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Manic Tritoon 2 WATERSLIDE on June 25, 2024
Fishing was okay, perhaps they were also on vacation. It was still a good time and would do it again.

customer-avatar
Tim Vanderheiden
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Infinite Blue – 50’ SeaRay, Veteran Owned on June 30, 2024
Be aware the water temperature dictates the species and activity of bite. The higher the temp., the lower the activity.

customer-avatar
Ronald Stewart
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Top Notch Sportfishing on June 28, 2024
Lots of shoreline, shallow, and deeper water opportunities... fishing doesn't have to be expensive, but if looking for a charter ask locals, read reviews and the right packages can be found!

customer-avatar
Jake Dupree
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hennessy Sportfishing - Mako 28 on June 19, 2024
Expect the weather to change plans for what you’re fishing for. Be flexible if you can’t go after your target species and be ready to catch something different!

customer-avatar
Bill Canfield
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Jersey Key “inshore” on June 10, 2024
Hire a well rated charter n follow Captains instructions. They will work hard to put you on fish. Grill it at your rental or have restaurant cook your catch

customer-avatar
Bill Clayton
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Top Notch Sportfishing on May 28, 2024
There were tarpon around but not in large quantities. We hit the tail end of the season I would say.

customer-avatar
Robert Lapoint
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Saltnsun on May 19, 2024
Great fish variety on the reef. A good guide can find the nice sized fish. The big ones can hung up in the reef structure. As usual, the winds can make or break your day. I love fishing in Marathon!

customer-avatar
Darrell Oakes
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Callion Fishing Charters on April 30, 2024
If you love sport fishing and never Tarpon fished, put a trip with Captain John Callion on your bucket list

customer-avatar
Clayton Llewellyn
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with 5th Generation Fishing on April 4, 2024
Use knowledgeable Captains! 5th Generation Fishing Charters is the one! They go above and beyond to take care of you at any cost.

customer-avatar
Bob Rusch
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Ana Banana Fishing Company – 30' Grady White on April 4, 2024
Try to experience all different types of fishing. For us: Day 1 - 30 yellow tails, Day 2 - 3 Mahi Mahi, day 3 - 2 tarpon on, one landed (6’, 150#). Yes we got lucky but guides were awesome.

customer-avatar
Derik Frioud
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Riplines Charters / Johnny Maddox Charters on March 26, 2024
Weather only permitted us to go out 1 of 3 days, so probably not a reliable review on March fishing.

customer-avatar
Dusty Verbeke
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Johnny Maddox Charters Papa 2 on March 27, 2024
The wind was bad all week but got Lucky and got out on good day but we were not able to go on Atlantic side .

customer-avatar
Gina Harris
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Ana Banana Fishing Charters (Cpt JoJo) on March 25, 2024
If you are prone to getting seasick make sure to take something. Our trip today was very choppy but didn’t bother any of us. They worked hard to find us fish to catch and it was a success!

customer-avatar
Gina Harris
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jay Charters 2 – Bay Boat on March 24, 2024
After Bryce cleaned our fish, we brought it to Lazy Days Restaurant and had a great dinner! They cook your fish for you and it was incredible. Highly recommend it!