What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Marathon, Florida for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Marathon

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
121 - 150 of 197 answers
customer-avatar
Troy Scott
Gladwin, MI
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Jersey Key Charters on November 11, 2022
Find a Captain with a first mate and book a six hour Offshore/reef/wreck combo. If you are going with children and/or females look for a charter book with a toilet. Try to get above a 30 foot boat.

customer-avatar
Donna Osborn
Cleveland, TN
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing an Fun! on April 21, 2021
With this company you cant go wrong. Captain Joe will make sure you have a great time. Expect to catch fish you might never have seen before.

customer-avatar
Lynne Southern
Virginia Beach, VA
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Callion Fishing Charters on August 7, 2019
Be sure to use Jack Callion as your captain! You will catch fish and have a great fishing experience

customer-avatar
Dan Wilkerson
Wixon Valley, TX
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Buddy LaPointe on July 15, 2019
July is hot and can be a slow time to fish. Be sure you know if your targeted fish are here when you plan the time of your trip.

customer-avatar
James Whiting
Fort Mill, SC
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Buddy LaPointe on June 18, 2019
Get a guide like Captain Buddy LaPointe that knows exactly where the fish are running at any time of the year or day.

customer-avatar
Shenandoah Gugel Shackelford
Rock Hill, SC
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Johnny Maddox Charters “PapaPapa” on June 21, 2019
Take your time, fish in shore and near shore on your own, but make sure to take an off shore charter!

customer-avatar
Walter Tortorich
Pineville, LA
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sundance Sportfishing on June 5, 2019
Scrutinize the captain closely. The captain we thought we hired was in Michigan chartering fishing trips. His business won't last long down here if he doesn't clean up his act.

customer-avatar
Alfred Guidi
Florence, KY
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Savage Sportfishing Florida Keys on May 28, 2019
go out on party boat out of Robbies marina in Islamoradora I cant comment on Marathon fishing because my trip was canceled

customer-avatar
Joseph Goustin
Huntsville, AL
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Buddy LaPointe on May 19, 2019
Captain Buddy is an expert in the area; he is on the fish and also a great guy. Just show up and catch fish.

customer-avatar
Kasey Davis
Marathon, FL
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Savage Sportfishing Florida Keys on April 23, 2019
Sure. We have fished here on 3 prior occasions with fun and success. This was the one bad experience, and was due to the captain.

customer-avatar
Kevin Olsen
Middletown, New Jersey
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Jersey Key Charters on March 30, 2019
If this is your first trip to Marathon, try and book your trip on Jersey Key Charters. We had an awesome day. The fishing was amazing.

customer-avatar
Dusty Verbeke
West Branch, MI
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Savage Sportfishing Florida Keys on March 26, 2019
Choose guide wisely there are some that are sub par and some that over charge my guide was good price and knowledgeable.

customer-avatar
Neal Yoho
Erwin, NC
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Sundance Sportfishing on March 7, 2019
Can't say anything but book it. And offshore fishing, live the experience With Sundance charters out of Marathon Florida.

customer-avatar
Jeff Monyak
Dayton, WA
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Two Conchs Sportfishing – 30' on February 28, 2019
Wear your sunscreen Dont guide yhe guide and fish what hot insted of what you want. Do your research on what species are in and listen to your guide.

customer-avatar
Michael Kuck
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Infinite Blue – 50’ SeaRay, Veteran Owned on July 8, 2025
It was our first time in a charter. Loved it, would do it again in a heartbeat

customer-avatar
Donald Lawrence
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Johnny Maddox Charters Papa 2 on June 5, 2025
If you looking for a great charter to go on i highly recommend using Johnny Maddox.

customer-avatar
Donald Lawrence
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jay Charters 1 – 30' Mako on June 6, 2025
Captain Dez is a great captain that i highly recommend for any of your offshore fishing needs.

customer-avatar
Jamie Loose
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hennessy Sportfishing - Mako 28 on May 4, 2025
Loved these guys! I’m sure they would be a great time for families or a partying crowd

customer-avatar
Luke Thorpe
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Wet Tails Charters – Keys Fishing Experience on March 19, 2025
My first offshore trip so not sure i should make recommendations for anyone. Happy we caught a few

customer-avatar
Jeff Valenti
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jay Charters 1 – 30' Mako on March 3, 2025
Choose captain Jay charters and Captain Randy for the day and you will not be disappointed

customer-avatar
Miguel Lopez Marcussen
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jay Charters 2 – Bay Boat on January 24, 2025
Yes but not in jannuary, but in my case i dont have an option to came in other seasons

customer-avatar
Eric Beatty
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Riplines Charters / Johnny Maddox Charters on October 30, 2024
Keep an eye on the weather! Winds really affect the ability to get out on open water.

customer-avatar
Stephen Cessna
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jay Charters 2 – Bay Boat on October 2, 2024
Water was a little murky after hurricane Helene but we still caught plenty of fish.

customer-avatar
Elise Garrett
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Captain Jay Charters 2 – Bay Boat on August 29, 2024
Quick drying clothing and a towel or dry change of clothes, very possible to get a little wet!

customer-avatar
James ‘Eric’ Bell
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Manic Tritoon 2 WATERSLIDE on July 2, 2024
Bring live shrimp from further up in Florida. No live shrimp or pinfish anywhere in Keys this week

customer-avatar
Robert D
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Nite Life Charters – 27' Sea Hunt on June 21, 2024
Great time of year to fish. If you have never been to South Florida WEAR SUNSCRERN!

customer-avatar
James Faulkner
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Fishing an Fun! on May 21, 2024
The captain provided everything needed for fishing, just bring sunscreen and/or a fishing shirt.

customer-avatar
Rob Furby
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Wet Tails Charters – Keys Fishing Experience on May 3, 2024
Be aware of prevailing winds. Will affect your location opportunities for bigger catches

customer-avatar
Darleen Johnston
Tamarac, Florida
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hennessy Sportfishing - Mako 28 on April 3, 2024
Book with Hennessy Sportfishing. He knows where the fish are at and can help you get what you want!

customer-avatar
Cory Bearden
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Hennessy Sportfishing - Mako 28 on March 31, 2024
Light tackle, I was surprised how light we went. It was an absolute blast though.