What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Islamorada, Florida for the first time?

Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Islamorada

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
61 - 90 of 248 answers
customer-avatar
Daniel Bogardus
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Danica Anne Sportfishing on June 28, 2025
Fish with a experience charter, follow their advice and knowledge. They know the waters and what bites when.

customer-avatar
Lewis Pulley
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Keys Aquatic Adventures on June 19, 2025
You’ll need to go deeper than 35 feet to find most of the legal fish. This means you either need to be really experienced free diving or just use scuba tanks.

customer-avatar
Melissa Martin
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Billy B Charter Services on June 7, 2025
Definitely book this charter and venture into the backcountry. So many people go offshore for sport fishing, but this experience in the backcountry is not one to be missed

customer-avatar
Shad Johnson
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Easy Does It Islamorada on June 2, 2025
Be patient as the weather can change very quickly and be flexible as nature can be kind of unpredictable in the keys.

customer-avatar
Michael Besich
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Reel Attack Charters on May 27, 2025
Definitely do the night time Tarpon trip and the full day Shark trip with Captain Jon from Reel Attack. You won’t be sorry!

customer-avatar
Al Crouch
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Midnight Fly Charters-Fly & Spin|Day & Night on May 20, 2025
Be flexible in times and target species. Hire experienced guides. More time on the water increases your chances of hooking up.

customer-avatar
Len Zavala
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Reel Attack Charters on May 18, 2025
To never use this captain and beware of the vetting process for the fishing charters they use. Worst fishing experience for all 4 anglers.

customer-avatar
Ronald Harris
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Eric Scoble Blackwater Charters on May 8, 2025
One of the greatest fishing destinations in the world. Be ready to make great memories, whatever your target fish may be.

customer-avatar
Gregg Lanternier
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Triple D Charter on April 16, 2025
Check the fishing reports and be flexible with your timing based on weather, moon, etc, if possible. If you can't be flexible, don't worry. Have a good attitude and have fun.

customer-avatar
Julie Andresen
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Midnight Fly Charters-Fly & Spin|Day & Night on March 14, 2025
Did had have a good experience fishing. I've never had the experience of not catching fish I could take home. We caught nothing that we were able to keep.

customer-avatar
James Smith
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Salty Bowline Charters on March 12, 2025
With kids be prepared that they are ready and willing to go fishing. It’s not a sight seeing trip and is meant for the true fishermen.

customer-avatar
Richard Poirot
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Dauntless Fishing Charters on March 10, 2025
Sometimes the weather is lousy and sometimes the fish don’t bite. That’s fishing. But Islamorada’s a pretty great place to have good luck with a wide variety of species.

customer-avatar
Mark Hashimoto
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Katz Charters on March 2, 2025
Go for the three hour to full day trip if you’re an experienced fisherperson so that Jason can maximize your

customer-avatar
Robert Struzziero
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Easy Does It Islamorada on February 26, 2025
Pick a time of year that suits the fish you’re trying to catch. There is always something to catch, but know your seasons so your not looking for something that is out of season.

customer-avatar
Jeffrey Huckle
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Islamorada Backcountry & Offshore on February 20, 2025
No guarantee that you will catch fish every cast or every spot. Just enjoy being on the water and keep trying.

customer-avatar
FishingBooker Member
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Salty Bowline Charters on January 2, 2025
I have fished all over Florida and I believe Islamorada is probably the most beautiful and also the best fishing area.

customer-avatar
Jon Garnier
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Pirate For Hire Charters on January 16, 2025
That they book with a captain that’s been in area for a long time, we were lucky enough to book captain Ron, pirate charters for hire.

customer-avatar
Joe Delia
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Capt. Trentin Leary on January 9, 2025
Check Fishing Booker for the guide and vessel you're looking for. It's so easy compared to the old days. Communication is streamlined and payment was so easy.

customer-avatar
Shirley Harris
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with True Island Adventures on January 3, 2025
Be careful about booking the trip that will catch what you were target, and if you want to keep it. This was a no go for us.

customer-avatar
FishingBooker Member
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Night Time Fishing Islamorada on December 19, 2024
Booking Captain Max Gaspeny. He knows how to guide beginners to the fish they want to catch or to fish they never dreamed of catching. He always asks what they want and delivers.

customer-avatar
FishingBooker Member
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Night Time Fishing Islamorada on September 15, 2024
It is a great time to be on the water. We were able to catch so many different kinds of fish. I was really surprised about the variety.

customer-avatar
Bruce Roy
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Liquid Gold Fishing Charters on September 13, 2024
Have patience and let the Captain and Crew do what they do to find the fish. The weather can be fickle in September so prepare yourself for the unpredictability of such.

customer-avatar
Jason Siegmund
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Pelagic Color Fishing Co. 42' Yellowfin on August 9, 2024
Captain Chase and Zac were outstanding! They were so knowledgeable and worked so hard to make sure we all caught fish… We will definitely be fishing with them again… Thank you guys!!!!

customer-avatar
Jon Franke
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Billy B Charter Services on July 22, 2024
Only thing to keep in mind is that it is *hot* and boats have limited shade. Sunscreen, water, hats, sunglasses are a must.

customer-avatar
Kathy Barbour
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with First Choice Charters on July 23, 2024
Be prepared for rolling waves and water. It can be choppy at times and it’s a long ride out for offshore to catch mahi

customer-avatar
Gary Hart
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Singing Reel Charters on July 10, 2024
Very hot but enjoyable. Excellent variety of fish to be caught and not too crowded at sea with too many boats.

customer-avatar
Stephanie Murphy
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Katz Charters on June 24, 2024
Understand fishing season if you’re trying for certain fish verse just fishing! We had success for our age kids, however are not professionals or sport fishing.

customer-avatar
Eric Christensen
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Easy Does It Islamorada on May 16, 2024
Listen to your Capt recommendation. I said the trip was appropriate for children because the Capt was excellent. The weather and sea this day would not have been.

customer-avatar
Susan Eisenreich
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with J&F eXcursions - 26 on April 30, 2024
The weather is a little unpredictable in April, but anytime you can go out on the water and fish is great.

customer-avatar
Colleen Nolan
VERIFIED  
Went fishing with Miller Time Sportfishing on April 3, 2024
Take some seasick pills. lol. Catptain Troy and mate, James are wonderful people and fun to fish with. Enjoy!