What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Key West, Florida for the first time?
Answers by verified FishingBooker anglers who went fishing in Key West
Showing:
91 - 120 of 418 answers
91 - 120 of 418 answers

Daphne Ortiz
Weather was rainy then out came the sun a little later.....great time on the water!

David Mayorga
Lots of barracuda, snapper and sharks. ran into some bonefish but they werent willing to commit

Glenn Comeau
This is a great trip ,4 hours was good.Weather was perfect.Good variety of fish.

Margarito Martinez
Loved everything from food at the boat house and 1/2 shell restaurant 4th year going

Andrew Rohrs
Yessir! Use Reel Easy Fishing Charters! Our Captain was very patient and a great teacher!

Nickole Sabin
Come prepared for the sun. Highly recommend UV shirts and hats and don’t forget the sunscreen.

Mark Hobbs
Find a good captain, like Reinier Perez, that knows the area and knows where the fish are.

Michael Myers
It can be good for first time. Low gunnels on the boat. Safety issue with children plus best if can cast a rod.

Nicole Giordano
If you are a customer looking for a great fishing experience, well don’t loose time looking around, if you read this recommendation is because you already found the best fishing charter in KeyWest!

Andrew Ferguson
Anglers should start their search for a quality fishing guide months in advance of the scheduled trip.

Scott Gooch
Make sure to bring plenty of fluids to stay hydrated. Wear you sun glasses. And most importantly wear your sun screen!

Travis Trahan
If it's your first time, take Dramamine the night before and an hour before your trip. Worked well for multiple boat trips with varying conditions.

Tom Trimble
The weather was great. Not too hot!
It was a little windy but Captain John knew how to get into the quiet spots out of the wind.
I really like the end of April fishing here.

Dennis Wylie
It was a very good experience on our fishing charter. We would recommend the Cora Beth fishing charter to everyone.

Miken Spalding
There was a cold front that came through the area and made the fishing tough but that is expected for fishing

Edward Ritzmann
Be conservative about the accessories you bring because you’re going to be spending most of your time fishing.

Zach Lewis
VERIFIED
Went fishing with Second Nature Charters on March 28, 2025
Went fishing with Second Nature Charters on March 28, 2025
Ask questions. Theses guys are wealth of knowledge and seemed happy to tell us they did things a certain way. It was just. Great experience

JimandCathy Davison
The captain and mate are experience and would be helpful for first time and experienced anglers alike.

Lisa Kuemper
Take the motion sickness pills 1 hour before. It won't hurt if you don't need it, but once you feel sick, it is too late.

Dennis Delong
Pick a good charter such as Reef Runner and then trust your captain and crew to do the best for you. They know their fishery and they will work there hardest to give you a great day on the water.

Daniel Nesbitt
Westher was picture perfect and the boat and crew were amazing! This is definitely a must do in Key West. Ride the conchenstien !

Carey Grant
Book Blake, he will walk you through how to spot fish, appropriate casts, and how to catch incredible fish!

Dennis Landis
I highly recommend flats fishing in December. The fish are plentiful and the scenery is incredible.

Mark Asuma
This is your boat and crew for sure. The best time! We caught so much! You will not be disappointed!

Michael Schor
Expect to have fun, not to catch anything great. That way, when you do - it will be an awesome surprise.

Scott Roberts
Be ready for the chance of cooler temps and higher winds, but if you are from up north it will still probably feel like summer to you!

Shawn Swallow
Find an experienced captain with local experience and who can build a day around daily conditions and recent fishing spots

David Sanderlin
It’s great if you have a good captain that knows where the fish are my other charter was fantastic

David Sanderlin
Yes, no experience need with mate Ross he will make sure you have a great time and enjoy catching your fish! First rate mate who is very capable!

Julie Moyer
Great time and everyone on the boat was catching fish. Very knowledgeable crew and captain. Captain was great on finding the fish.